We are currently in the "smoking is good for you" era ...
It'd be great if people could control the parameters of their feeds; they're incredible discovery tools. Banning outright will just make the next addiction lever get invented faster.
The thing about systemic problems(people's mental bandwidth and health are being fucked globally) is that personal solutions(being able to do X about them) almost never solve them.
We absolutely need to ban anti-human dark patterns being employed to sabotage all humans with access to the internet to earn pennies on the dollar off siphoned attention, and what we need to do when the next addiction lever gets invented is to ban it too.
That'd be like letting companies put toxic chemicals in their products just in case they find something worse instead.
> when the next addiction lever gets invented is to ban it too
Agreed in principle but the problem in practice is, what's an addictive pattern. People have yet to reach agreement.
> letting companies put toxic chemicals in their products just in case they find something worse instead
This analogy looks ok on the surface but doesn't quite work. The equivalent of "toxic chemicals" in the analogy would be "all dark patterns" - but, we haven't yet discovered them all or named all of them much less put them under a toxic / non-toxic taxonomy that has achieved universal enough agreement to be a foundation for policy.
Banning only the stuff we have found so far is more like banning just one toxic chemical or a few; we still don't know what else is left unbanned.
We're starting to see laptops recognised as detrimental to learning in schools and scaled back.. that was definitely a "smoking is good for you era" (Laptop for every child)
I remember 15 years ago reading on this very website articles about how to make apps addictive.
No problem, since mental illness will be solved by AI in 10 years, according to Amodei.
My AI therapist claims it's already solved
We are currently in the "smoking is good for you" era ...
It'd be great if people could control the parameters of their feeds; they're incredible discovery tools. Banning outright will just make the next addiction lever get invented faster.
The thing about systemic problems(people's mental bandwidth and health are being fucked globally) is that personal solutions(being able to do X about them) almost never solve them.
We absolutely need to ban anti-human dark patterns being employed to sabotage all humans with access to the internet to earn pennies on the dollar off siphoned attention, and what we need to do when the next addiction lever gets invented is to ban it too.
That'd be like letting companies put toxic chemicals in their products just in case they find something worse instead.
> when the next addiction lever gets invented is to ban it too
Agreed in principle but the problem in practice is, what's an addictive pattern. People have yet to reach agreement.
> letting companies put toxic chemicals in their products just in case they find something worse instead
This analogy looks ok on the surface but doesn't quite work. The equivalent of "toxic chemicals" in the analogy would be "all dark patterns" - but, we haven't yet discovered them all or named all of them much less put them under a toxic / non-toxic taxonomy that has achieved universal enough agreement to be a foundation for policy.
Banning only the stuff we have found so far is more like banning just one toxic chemical or a few; we still don't know what else is left unbanned.
We're starting to see laptops recognised as detrimental to learning in schools and scaled back.. that was definitely a "smoking is good for you era" (Laptop for every child)
Laptop != Unrestricted Internet access
[flagged]