33 comments

  • ROOFLES 27 minutes ago

    All just speculation and almost no hard facts. Demand could still drop dramatically if they run out of investors / can't build all the datacenters they are planning. I dont care if manufacturing is "booked" for 100years if no one will be actually buying. Manufacturers know this is not going to continue like this. Thats why no one is building out manufacturing capacity.

    • hypendev 15 minutes ago

      >Thats why no one is building out manufacturing capacity

      But they are. And there is no putting this genie back into the bottle. The more companies and users use AI, the more data is generated, the more storage is required.

      Byte-per-byte, my data generation at least 1000x'd. Code, projects, user storage for each of it, images, videos, songs, voiceovers, games, sessions, worktrees, throw-off sideprojects, work data, inference done on data, trained model weights... insanity.

      And with coming years, more and more people will do that. The upcoming capacity isn't even close to meeting basic extrapolated demands, but we still have the "economic disbelief" that it will scale like that.

      On another note, Apple somehow still offers the cheapest cloud pricing out of all providers.

      • ShinyLeftPad 10 minutes ago

        > basic extrapolated demands

        Basic extrapolation used to say human population will approach infinity this November...

        • hypendev 2 minutes ago

          What are the possibilities here tho?

          >Companies will stop AI adoption and technology won't penetrate the market

          Not likely. Only a small subset has adopted it for now and doesn't seem to be slowing down.

          >Users will stop using AI to generate images, videos or text

          Also not likely. AI still has small market penetration and you can already see GPT slop everywhere.

          >We will find a 10-fold improvement to SOTA compression

          Not likely, but even if we did, you'd need to scale it globally in a few years.

          >Less people will buy phones, consoles, computers

          This could be possible due to high prices, but not in a manner that impacts the overall market demand.

          So if these are all not likely, what is left as likely?

          >Prices grow because demand skyrockets >New players enter the market to catch up with demand

          And even if a few neoclouds fail and some data center buildout stops, it really is just a temporary setback to an evergrowing machine.

      • blauditore 2 minutes ago

        A lot of the generated data is slop and often not worth storing long-term. People will realize this and introduce more aggressive deletion mechanisms - how much and how quickly depends on the pricing of storage.

        This has happened in the past: Email providers (e.g. Microsoft) offered "infinite" storage, i.e. growing over time, but eventually crawled back and applied a hard limit.

        You can't just claim scaling will go on like this forever. Extrapolating the number of Huang's affairs makes it look like he will have dozens of them by next year.

      • trentor 13 minutes ago

        Found Gaving Belsons HN account. Data-Geddon is right around the corner for decades now.

  • mastermage 32 minutes ago

    I hope you are right. I would also like RAM and GPU Prices to go down aswell.

  • novaRom 27 minutes ago

    If RAM will also follow this trend then it's done with insane token prices and large compute data centers - AI, LLMs will become commodity. Most companies will either rely on small scale national providers or have some compute in-house sufficient to run coding and other agents.

  • jpgvm 23 minutes ago

    Wishful thinking. Opposition to data centres is nowhere near universal enough to dent demand, nowhere near enough supply is coming online.

    • greggoB 12 minutes ago

      Wasn't it given as a major factor in the exit polls for the US midterms? It definitely also ties into affordability, which definitely was one, so I'd assume there is quite some mandate to start curtailing their rolll-out. But maybe it's not enough as you say.

      • yorwba 6 minutes ago

        There are lots of places where data centers could be built. If 100 towns reject data center construction and one allows it, the data center gets built. Doesn't even have to be in the US.

  • zeristor an hour ago

    I’m guessing there will be a lot of pent up demand as the prices go lower.

    • illidan1000 an hour ago

      Yes but once supply stabilizes, demand will go down, as well prices.

  • mesm7903 27 minutes ago

    Even if prices fall in the second half of next year, I'll believe it when I see retail prices actually drop. The recent spikes have made me hold off on any upgrades for now.

  • illidan1000 an hour ago

    I regret not upgrading my PS5 hard drive space when I had the chance.

    • rbanffy 16 minutes ago

      With luck you will have that chance with the PS6.

    • _rwo 28 minutes ago

      yeah, I gave up on upgrading/purchasing any gaming hardware at all tbh... can't justify the price; enjoying some 6y+ old games tho; too bad I didn't get myself any handheld as I thought it was too expensive (and now it costs pretty much 2x, oh well)

    • zodwick 4 minutes ago

      me 1.5 years ago: who needs a TB of storage ? everything is backed up in cloud - even if i want an ssd is so much cheaper than the price apple wants ! lemme just get the 256 gb MBP

      me rn : (T_T)

  • signalbright 38 minutes ago

    The 'honest outlook' and 'straight answer' in this article are a bit suspicious

    • teekert 17 minutes ago

      Was gonna say: I'm so glad it's the honest outlook, imagine we'd get a dishonest outlook, no human would want to read it. So be honest... straight from the system prompt into TFA!

  • xpct 30 minutes ago

    The analysis part is missing from this analysis article.

  • on_the_train 37 minutes ago

    I doubt it. Maybe costs will get lower, but end-user prices? Hardly ever

    • Jtarii 30 minutes ago

      The price of computer components has decreased a lot since the 80s.

      • ftchd 2 minutes ago

        See you guys in 2066

    • ozgrakkurt 29 minutes ago

      It might go up slower which will mean it is getting cheper since there will be THE BEST inflation in a year because of the BEST president THE WORLD HAS EVER SEEN.

    • Kina 27 minutes ago

      I mean, I agree given the way this was rigged that they’re going to see how far they can keep the prices. I suspect we’re going to see a recession soon, so let’s see how long they can keep this racket going if they end up with excess inventory or low sales.

  • ckx 15 minutes ago

    yeah right

  • ReptileMan 14 minutes ago

    If I can quote the great thinkers known as backstreet boys - quit playing games with my heart. The only way silicone to become cheap is the AI bubble to pop and hard or massive new capacity to come online. In the first case we won't have money to buy and the second - we all will be graybeards.

  • traceroute66 22 minutes ago

    I call bullshit.

    As long as the US/Israel stuff is going on in the middle east, there's going to be no downwards movements in any prices, SSDs or otherwise. End of story.

    Why ?

    For a start, before you consider anything else, stuff needs to be shipped around. For that you need (a) Oil (b) The ability to use shortest-route transport routes.

    The middle east nonsense messes all that up completely. And even if the war stopped tomorrow, it will still take some time for things to return to some semblance of normality, such is the extent of the disruption.

    • A_D_E_P_T 9 minutes ago

      No, that hardly matters.

      The other day my firm was looking to ship about 180kg of expensive materials packed into 9 large crates from Korea to the US -- which, if it were SSDs, would be a lot of SSDs.

      You're absolutely right that it's much more expensive than ever, what with the war and the holidays and all. But we were still quoted just $2600 for Air Freight and $1300 for Sea Freight. Which, if it were SSDs, would work out to pennies per unit. (For expensive goods, tariffs are a much more punishing cost.)

      It's demand driven. The Iran War might raise prices more by cutting off Asia from helium used in chip production, rather than by driving up oil prices...

    • citrin_ru 13 minutes ago

      Shipping cost affects cheap (compare to mass/volume) products but in RAM price shipping is a negligible fraction. Where Iran war affects the more AFIK is the cost of credit which slows investments into new capacity by the manufactures. All thing being equal low interest rates allow to expand capacity faster.

    • sandworm101 12 minutes ago

      Most SSD/RAM and chips generally ship by air. At the value density of such things, nobody wants to maintain stock sitting on ships. Interest rates alone would cover the cost of air cargo. Just think of how much ram can be on a single pallet, let alone in a 40-foot shipping container.