35 comments

  • mainecoder a day ago

    Their main contention is that the US is exercising extraterritorial jurisdiction and there is precedent for that as well, and there is a growing group of lawmakers who are willing to explicitly have it so.

    From the article, ""The bipartisan legislation would give U.S. allies, including the Netherlands and Japan, 150 days to align restrictions on sales and servicing of advanced chipmaking equipment to China with those imposed by Washington, or show progress toward doing so. If they fail to comply, the U.S. Commerce Department would be required to extend American export controls unilaterally to equipment supplied from those countries." The US implicitly has jurisdiction over the Netherlands and Japan in that neither country has full sovereignty to resist the demands of the US. The issue for them seems to be the very explicitness of the law saying it will extend export controls unilaterally. Is this understanding correct?

    • _heimdall a day ago

      > The US implicitly has jurisdiction over the Netherlands and Japan in that neither country has full sovereignty to resist the demands of the US.

      That's not my read on this situation. Japan and the Netherlands are free to choose not to comply, the US doesn't have jurisdiction and can't force compliance. The countries may not like the results though, at which point choosing to comply us the less shitty option.

      Having leverage to put another country in a difficult decision is different than having jurisdiction over them.

      • 1718627440 a day ago

        You are free to choose to not comply with the laws in your country, but you might not like the resulting actions your countries executive will take.

        Sovereignty of states means that they are only responsible with their actions towards themself. Using leverage to influence the decision of another country IS trying to subvert their sovereignty.

        • _heimdall a day ago

          What you're talking about is the use of leverage and politics. Its not a fun game, and I'd rather people didn't feel the need to play it, but telling another country "do what I want or there will be trade implications" is very different from having jurisdiction over the other country.

          That's all my point was here, leverage != jurisdiction.

        • halJordan a day ago

          Like ok, but here in the real world living means engaging with the people around you. The Dutch have to engage with the Americans. Sovereignty isn't a magical word. And you know we're in a great area where you magical demonizations fall, bc it is just as correct to hammer on ASML for their capitalist need for profit which is impacting the US right to sovereignty.

      • erkt a day ago

        Uhhh the US cannot force compliance? How many missiles do you think it would require to take ASML out of competition?

        • piva00 a day ago

          Without ASML the US wouldn't be able to source the best semiconductors ever produced, sure it can force compliance by destroying it all but it'd be creating a much larger issue for itself than other means available to force compliance (like sanctions).

          Either way, forcing compliance through destruction or sanctions, has a diplomatic and political cost, if that's what the USA chooses to do it will be spending the little political capital it has left with its closest allies.

          • cowlevel a day ago

            NL couldn't sanction ASML from the US without causing a serious financial loss, perhaps the end of ASML and its acquisition by a Chinese company. Like most politics it's a multiway standoff.

            • piva00 a day ago

              I meant the US could sanction NL entities if they don't bend the knee, it's a way for the US to force compliance not the other way around.

              It's why I mentioned the USA would spend the very little left political capital they have with allies if that was done, would work in immediate terms but hurt the USA itself in the longer term since it'd accelerate decoupling.

              • cowlevel 16 hours ago

                The US would seem to be the losing one if it bans itself from receiving GPUs. It would never do that.

        • _heimdall a day ago

          Is your expectation here that this issue would lead directly to a military conflict? Not my expectation in anyway, it seems like it just lead to more stupid trade wars from the Trump administration.

          • 1718627440 a day ago

            A blockade or siege is a militaric tactic and sanctions are basically the dynamic pricing variant of them. Sanctions are applied as an answer to a militaric threat all the time and are intended to change the outcome of a war. Wars are won with logistic and economy ultimately and this is a measure intended to alter the logistic and economic capability of a another country.

            • _heimdall a day ago

              Sanctions are not military, there economic. Its well within a person's, company's, or state's rights to decide who they want to do business with and what terms they're willing to agree to.

              That's all this is, regardless of whether we agree with the terms themselves.

              • 1718627440 7 hours ago

                The USA make sure that the sanctions they create are not only enforced by them. If that were the case, I would agree with you, but as the USA wants to be the world police, I don't.

          • cowlevel a day ago

            I think that's a reasonable expectation. The US does it regularly, but usually in south america, not europe. Doing it in europe would be something new, but they've done a lot of new things.

        • ErroneousBosh a day ago

          How brutal do you think the consequences would be for the US if they attacked a NATO country?

        • Balinares a day ago

          I'd recommend saving what few missiles remain from failing to get control of Hormuz back from Iran. As a bonus that'd save some dignity too.

    • Molitor5901 a day ago

      I think that is what I got out of it.. The US absolutely has the sovereign authority to restrict exports of American technology; for better or for worse. Likewise, the Netherlands has the same authority over Dutch technology. I think the headline perhaps makes this a little ambiguous... The argument I see is really how much authority the US should have over Dutch companies and Dutch-made equipment that incorporate American technology.

      • sergdigon a day ago

        I am really curious if NL or Japan actually have "the same authority". I had in mind that the extraterritorial control US has over its technology was somewhat "american exceptionalism" and not fully recognized in Europe (but that they often comply in practice under US pressure). If someone more expert than me on the question can enlighten me, I would be happy. In the meanwhile, I found an article a bit older but with more details on the problem [1].

        [1] https://www.techpolicy.press/why-asmls-semiconductor-monopol...

    • a day ago
      [deleted]
  • bradknowles a day ago

    Here’s the most critical paragraph from TFA:

    > ASML has never shipped its most advanced extreme ultraviolet, or EUV, machines to China. The Netherlands already introduced export controls on less advanced deep ultraviolet, or DUV, machines back in 2023. The MATCH Act would expand those controls to more types of DUV chipmaking equipment and tighten rules on servicing machines already in China.

    In this case, the US should work with The Netherlands specifically, and the EU in general, to work out the systems that will or will not be exportable to China.

    They can make whatever noise they want about what trade export controls they want, but the final decision lies with NL and EU.

    On the flip side, I worked at ASML years ago as a contractor. I ended up running their in-house e-mail systems. I even got a nice invited talk out of it: http://shub-internet.org/brad/papers/sistpni/

    But what I saw from was that the ASML sales agents in China were casually sharing entire 100GB+ DVD and Blu-Ray video libraries with their Chinese clients, and sending those by e-mail. Across a single E-1 line back to HQ in Veldhoven, and from there out to the broader Internet. This clogged the E-1 lines and prevented any real traffic from ever being able to be transmitted over them. So, I cut the maximum message size that was allowed to be sent through the mail servers down to just 1MB. And suddenly, those E-1 lines became usable again.

    That was the early 2000s, and they didn’t give a flying Mongolian cluster f*ck about copyright or intellectual property law then. I can’t see that anything has improved since.

    • BigTTYGothGF a day ago

      > That was the early 2000s, and they didn’t give a flying Mongolian cluster f*ck about copyright or intellectual property law then

      Going by another story currently on the HN front page we can see that the French don't give one (flying Monacan) about copyright or intellectual property law either.

  • expedition32 a day ago

    This is a clash between pragmatism and jingoism.

    The Dutch position is that either ASML sells to China or they are going to have their own ASML in 20 years and the Netherlands ends up with nothing. The US thinks it can delay the inevitable.

  • kylehotchkiss a day ago

    Isn’t the team building the EUV light sources in San Diego? I don’t totally understand if that means lasers or optics.

    I’m sure threatening to nationalize that office is a bargaining chip here

  • RetroTechie 20 hours ago

    Let the US please keep up this kind of thumb-squeezing! That will kick EU into gear & follow China's path of self-reliance for any technology (and energy + raw materials) deemed critical. Would take a while but EU countries have the know-how, funds and a high-tech base to build on. US stands to loose truckloads of $$ already as EU companies & governments move IT services/infra back to Europe.

    Sanctions? That means another round of tariffs. Should go down great with the US public.

    Hell, the NL could even threathen to LIFT current restrictions & ship EUV machines to China wholesale. Keep in mind China is busy getting there by itself - it's a closing window in any case.

    US doesn't have as much leverage here as it seems to think. And certainly no jurisdiction. Military options? Not happening.

    This will be watered down one way or the other.

  • 6510 a day ago

    ASML is half of the dutch machine industry and 1.6% of the economy.

  • 28304283409234 18 hours ago

    Well, we are the Ferengi afterall, you know.

  • HSO a day ago

    `us` should finally stop meddling in other countries get out of europe and asia and maybe you can take your OWN country back first instead of being pathetic cucks to a tiny pseudo-`country`

  • spwa4 a day ago

    Doesn't that mean that ASML is behaving ... about double as bad as what Nvidia is accused of?

    • blahblaher a day ago

      how so? The Netherlands doesn't have a "national security" issue with China, that's a US problem. If they export machines to China that they said they wouldn't then the US could have some justification to be pissed, and might impose sanctions to the Netherlands, but US laws don't apply to other countries.

      • spwa4 a day ago

        Obviously the Netherlands does have such a national security issue, and furthermore they are dependent on US help in order to be able to militarily resist other countries, including China.

        Since they're making it easier for China to attack mostly other countries with this move, I can only assume appropriately massive amounts, I mean it's China so it would have to be absurd like 100x Dutch GDP, probably even more than that, have been allocated in the Dutch government budget to provide aid to the countries whose lives they're making more difficult.

        By the way, since the Netherlands is partly responsible for giving Pakistan and then in turn North Korea nuclear weapons (yes, really, look it up), I'd love to hear an update on how they've helped the target of those nukes, India and South Korea, militarily. I mean, legally speaking, speaking of fairness, that's what they'd have to do, isn't it? Again, easily 10x the entire GDP of the Netherlands wouldn't even come close to how much those countries have to invest to deal with the fallout of that Dutch fuckup, so I'm preparing to be thoroughly impressed by the amounts ...

        Because if they don't contribute to that, this would be a SERIOUSLY asshole move, wouldn't it? Are they just doing this to make some money and push the costs on everyone else?

        Wait ... they give those countries nukes and contribute NOTHING to the fallout? WOW they are serious assholes.

        • WhyNotHugo a day ago

          The Netherlands doesn't need any support for a military defence against China, because China is a trade partner that's made no military threats of any sort.

          In fact, it's the US that has threatened to invade the EU or to attack The Hague multiple times and quite explicitly in the last couple of years.

          • spwa4 a day ago

            You neglected to cover what the Netherlands should do about having made the mistake that gave nukes to Pakistan and North Korea, because obviously that is a MAJOR military threat to India and South Korea. One that is costing them many time the Netherland's GDP, and that the Netherlands has just walked away and left the rest of the world to deal with those nukes at great cost while just not caring. Please explain fairness again with this in mind ...

            As for China's threats, I believe the list of countries that disagree with you on China's threats now includes Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Phillippines, Indonesia, Malaysia and very occasionally Australia.

            • vrganj 20 hours ago

              > Pakistan and North Korea, because obviously that is a MAJOR military threat to India and South Korea.

              Notably, not to the Netherlands.

              > Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Phillippines, Indonesia, Malaysia and very occasionally Australia.

              Notably, not the Netherlands.

    • cowlevel a day ago

      There's nothing wrong Nvidia is doing, nor ASML. So technically yes, two times zero is zero.

      The US regime likes to think that Nvidia selling to china is wrong, but them saying it doesn't make it true. It's not immoral to violate a sanction.