GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece

(bloomberg.com)

33 points | by bundie an hour ago ago

45 comments

  • HelloUsername 39 minutes ago

    Perhaps more relevant to hackernews crowd: "GTA6 Digital Foundry's Tech Review" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qsBU0bcpONA

    • Aaargh20318 4 minutes ago

      frame drops to low 20's when anything interesting happens on screen. OUCH.

      Even on PS5 Pro it's not entirely stable but the situation seems much worse on base PS5 which is what the vast majority of players will be using.

      Targeting a game at 30fps in 2026 is certainly a choice, but it not even being a locked 30 is hugely disappointing.

  • dmix an hour ago

    Relying on early game reviews from major media sites for hyped up AAA games is always a bad idea.

    • tnolet 6 minutes ago

      What does this even mean? It's just a review of a video game? There is no "idea" or "relying".

    • lp92 33 minutes ago

      This game is going to sell regardless of reviews.

      • lemoncookiechip 31 minutes ago

        It's already pre-sold over 14 million, and will likely go to sell at least 200 million over the course of its life.

    • petcat an hour ago

      nobody is "relying" on anything. The people who are going to buy it are going to buy it regardless.

  • poisonborz 5 minutes ago

    My problem with GTA franchise is that it doesn't try to say anything. Technically it is incredibly impressive, may be the last technically impressive game where details were made by human crafting. Stellar, even considering the 10 year dev time and $1bn+ budget.

    But on the surface, the world building basically became Fast & Furious. The "witty" takes on society were reduced to "Fruit" phones and mocking recreation of daytime news. Nothing unsafe. Not wanting preachy storylines, just that there should be something to _experience_, something serious besides "oh this is realistic, let's try to land that jumbo on the beach". Maybe GTA4 was the last entry that had great overtones about migrant life.

    I mean, it is a big sandbox and you can roleplay whatever, but the already thin GTA5 was diluted down to water with stupid mictrotransactions, Shark Cards, and the dumbest multiplayer experience there is, and they made a bank on that. I don't expect this to be different, and it just makes the taste sour, despite the otherwise brilliant execution.

  • pipes an hour ago

    Didn't bother reading, but how many hours can they have played it for?

    GTA3 is one of the few games I finished. I tried playing the subsequent ones, they were pretty much the same formula with better grapgics so I couldn't be bothered with them. I'll not play this one as in my 40s I really don't have time.

    • baud147258 7 minutes ago

      > but how many hours can they have played it for?

      I heard on Twitter that reviewers had access to preview copies like 2 weeks ago.

    • dmix 42 minutes ago

      Article says he played for 45 hours

    • testerius 34 minutes ago

      So what do you do these days? I also do not play computer games anymore. However if I really want to play, I think I could find some time for playing. But you know what? I prefer watching YouTube movie while somebody was playing (without commentary), joined few hours of gameplay that looks like a real movie.

      • lp92 32 minutes ago

        I never understood people who watch other people playing games.

        • lukan 24 minutes ago

          I never did either, then my time became much more limited and now to get at least a glimpse into a game, I do not find the time fully diving into, I sometimes enjoy it nowdays.

        • nstents 26 minutes ago

          It's a natural evolution of watching sports.

        • Gracana 27 minutes ago

          Is that something you want to change?

        • animuchan 14 minutes ago

          Honestly I don't understand it either. Especially non-computer games, such as football/soccer — it's the stupidest thing ever.

          Computer games though, especially professional matches or speedruns (and actual physical-world motor sports racing onboards, all in that same bucket) sometimes click with me, not sure why. It's monotonous but can be engaging in a "vibes" way.

    • bena 20 minutes ago

      Really? San Andreas is probably the pinnacle of the PS2 engine games. From the controls to the amount of things you can do, it’s just better than 3.

      Hell, from a gameplay perspective, San Andreas is probably my favorite. It’s the only one I’ve played through multiple times

    • epolanski 43 minutes ago

      Sometimes the same formula is okay.

      But one of my biggest issues with the GTA games is the lack of any sort of challenge whatsoever. At each version two things change:

      1. the game gets easier. I think I died twice (once due to a bug) in the whole main campaign of GTA 5

      2. they keep shoving more and more story and dialogue and interruptions in the game. Honestly I hate it, RDR 2's first 4 hours felt like being a spectator of a film, and I hate it. If I'm interested in a story I read a book or play games with that specific focus.

      • gertrunde 21 minutes ago

        I had similar feelings about the uncharted series, 1 & 2 I enjoyed, 3 I just stopped playing after a few hours, as I found myself spending more time making cups of tea while an unskipable cut scene plays, than actually playing the game itself.

      • billynomates 21 minutes ago

        On point 2, the article says this one is a bit different. Compared to RDR2 and GTA5, "there are plenty of slow, deliberate moments, but the game is often content to just be a game."

      • pipes 32 minutes ago

        The main character not speaking in GTA 3 was a feature, much like Gordon freeman in half life.

        I had similar issues with metal gear solid 2. I gave up due to cut scenes.

  • cassonmars an hour ago
  • drbscl 4 minutes ago

    Very glad I held my TTWO

  • haunter 9 minutes ago

    Wish I could play it but getting a PS5 just for one game… ehh

  • tnolet an hour ago
    • claykkari 29 minutes ago

      "It all very much feels like RDR 2 as well. Similar to Arthur, Jason and Lucia feel a little heavier than the GTA 5 trio in a pleasing way that grounds them more in the world and gives them a more convincing sensation of inertia as they otherwise seamlessly transition from one action to another."

      What a relief. The GTA5 characters were way too cartoonish for me, which hurt the immersion compared to RDR2.

  • pelagicAustral an hour ago

    I feel almost forced to buy a PS5 so I can play this... since there is zero chance I can afford a new gaming rig with the current hardware prices.

    • wishfish 11 minutes ago

      If you're willing to take a chance on a weaker machine, Xbox Series S would be substantially cheaper than a PS5. I bought one a few years ago when I didn't have enough for a gaming PC at the time. Did very well with RDR 2 and the recent Assassin's Creeds.

      Early reports and videos seems to show the S doing ok with GTA 6. Looks like it's 720p upscaled to 1080p via FSR 4. Mostly 30fps but with some dropped frames. Looks good enough that I'll give it a try on this hardware.

    • robot_jesus 41 minutes ago

      The bad news is that PS5s are about as expensive as entry gaming rigs. Used PS5 Pros are going for ~$1400 these days

    • pgoggijr 26 minutes ago

      The game isn’t out on PC yet anyway

  • Surac 5 minutes ago

    Im sure young hunans can learn a lot in GTA6

  • baal80spam 3 minutes ago

    Bloomberg reviews games now?

  • emoII an hour ago

    Can't believe I read this as GPT 6

  • snapplebobapple 12 minutes ago

    Hot take: the last good gta was gta 2. Top down ftw!

  • tokai an hour ago

    Bloomberg is maybe one of the last publications I would trust on a video game review.

    • falcor84 34 minutes ago

      I'd say that Jason Schreier is the relevant brand here, rather than Bloomberg.

    • gbil an hour ago

      Probably the intention of the OP is to show that even such publications are in the GTA craziness

    • pizza234 an hour ago

      It got 99 on Metacritic though, which is extremely high.

      • tupac_speedrap an hour ago

        Nobody is going to give a bad pre-release review to such a big company or they'll lose a lot of views from being blacklisted

  • Onewildgamer an hour ago

    paywalled

  • rvz 39 minutes ago

    This is the reason why the Steam Machine will not sell.

    As predicted, [0] the consumer will go as far as to buying a console (either Xbox or a PS5) to play GTA 6 as it is not available on PC and does not run on Linux.

    [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48890623

  • dude250711 an hour ago

    [flagged]