As you probably noticed, our domain codeberg.org is entirely unreachable.
It was registered with namesilo and entirely disappeared from our account. We're waiting for their customer support to investigate the situation.
Update: We have received the confirmation that our domain was suspended and our case got forwarded to the abuse team. We're still waiting for a final decision.
I had a similar problem last week. My registrar suspended my account without further notice. Customer support told me to pay 90 euros per domain for recovery.
I got attention by creating a post on social media, some higher level people reached out to me and resolved the issue.
Is there anything one can do to prevent the entire company from going dark?
- What if my registrar suspends my account? => Use different registrars for different domains.
- What if the whole TLD has an outage (DENIC had that before)? => Fallback tld?
Should I really setup all SaaS apps with fallback-domain support that is registered by a different registrar on a different tld?
Not everything a company writes in the terms and conditions is legal, not to mention morally defensible. For domains in particular, the registry and not the registrar sets the rules ultimately.
Sure, doesn't make it less scammy. Where I live, you can't just add whatever to the T&C and be able to legally force people to follow it, has to be stuff reasonable people would expect. Such term isn't one of those, so to small claims court I'd go, tends to scare most companies into action in my experience.
This story made me want to run my own registrar with a “no automated enforcement” policy as my differentiator. While other services streamline by using AI for all operations, I would guarantee to you that my admin named “Steve“ would personally call your phone or notify you by overnight delivery if we thought such an action was necessary. You, of course, would need to pay a $$ deposit to cover the postage.
Or do bother by having two domains at different registrars. Some websites that are at risk of TLD-level blocks do that proactively (mostly piracy related, but it's still something to learn from)
Oh you can suspend and destroy anything – not limited to domain names. The important part is – can someone stop you, or can someone prosecute you by virtue of you being from certain countries and the power and reach of said countries?
I've learnt and acknowledged that all this talk of "use your own domain", "degoogle", "pay for the email" (and I do), etc are safe until someone resourceful enough eyes your domain with the wrong kind of look.
.eu or member state cc-TLD paired with providers with matching jurisdiction seem fairly solid, based on what I heard. They would have to ask a court at my place, and that court will discuss the matter with me in my preferred language before doing anything harmful - and apply a high standard to claims of urgency.
Why not? The registry and registrar can suspend whatever they want, that constantly happens with piracy sites for example, which is why they all use random TLDs like .pk or .sk
The contract (RAA) between ICANN and the registrars also says they are required to suspend sites engaging in DNS Abuse, such as malware distribution, spam, or fraud.
Not sure why people are acting surprised about this. This seems like an extremely obvious thing that would be in place...
(The hilarious part is Namesilo doesn't even action valid malware abuse reports I send them but apparently does for codeberg, which is a legitimate service? Figures. Maybe I will submit that ICANN complaint after all.)
Yes, in my eyes rather annoying as it makes it difficult/impossible to get something malicious taken down in such cases, since I have no tool to hit registrars over the head with. But I guess it makes sense.
Yeah, I understand those are not just random letters. I meant "random" as in it's not a major TLD and it wasn't chosen because the website is somehow related to that country. Whois shows they're registered with some obscure registrar in the Bahamas which doesn't even have a working website.
Probably because TPB is an irrelevant low-quality wasteland, that honey traps people who otherwise would've gone to more useful sites. Those other more useful sites regularly get their domains suspended.
It's pretty simple really. The registry or registrar just decides you shouldn't have a domain and poof! you don't.
I expect the domain will remain permanently suspended since Codeberg violates US law, and .com and .org are US TLDs. They should have done codeberg.de witha German registrar, since they're operating within DE law they would be able to sue the registry or registrar for contract violation.
Good time to remind people that there are direct registration TLDs. Obviously not always a viable option but I prefer to use them as there is one less (useless and often scammy) middleman to deal with.
I’m surprised that as a German organization, you are using an American registrar, where such issues are inherently more difficult to handle, and are possibly more likely to happen.
This doesn't always work. In many cases they'll try to call your bluff, and you'll have to actually back up your threats with real action. Of course with a real legal team that wouldn't be too much of a problem, but you wouldn't have prevented anything.
A real legal action would recover whatever money you lost because of the registrar's decision, so you wouldn't actually care that the downtime occurred.
Use a registrar whose HTML <title> isn't "Cheap domain names".
I don't mean to be facetious, but cheap domain registrars don't have enough margin to have decent abuse departments.
Github use https://www.markmonitor.com/ . I have no idea who they are, but "See why half of the top 10 most trafficked websites in the world are managed via Markmonitor.", and their prices aren't listed.
I'm guessing these guys don't fold, and customers don't hear "We have received the confirmation that our domain was suspended and our case got forwarded to the abuse team."
It's back up. They get $75k from memberships and $50k from donations, spend $220k (almost entirely on salaries) and draw down capital reserves to make up the difference.
You are being facetious. This is like a village having problem of their property being routinely stolen and the suggestion is everyone in the village should become billionaires and hire their own private militias.
I initially didn't have the paragraph on Github/Markmonitor. I later added it because it seemed interesting, but I realise it made my overall point weaker.
I suppose the gap is that there are domain providers between namesilo and Markmonitor.
Torrent sites too, and bulletproof hosts. Sometimes I make a note of who's getting on the various USA warning lists because I know those companies won't take down my stuff for no reason.
It was a shitty site made by/for shitty people, which made it a great test how different providers handle such cases. It took considerable "internet outrage" for Cloudflare to drop them. So I guess that is the type of provider you want to stick with it, that will usually wait for actual court order, not just turn your site off on a whim.
Yes but they could still use a registrar that operates under their laws, is more friendly to them and does helpful things like notify them of the problem and give them a chance to remediate it before suspension. Yes the US can still reach them but it would require due process. Of course we only have one side of the story here, it is possible Codeberg did not respond in the required timeframe for something.
You get what you pay for. At the end of the day it's a business decision, and if this downtime isn't worth that cost then that's the executive's decision.
I get a feeling you have a skewed view of what codeberg is. It's not a company, there are no "executives", at least not like you'd see in a commercial organization, and they have a million things of much higher priority that could use money (like additional hardware) than extremely expensive registrars mostly used by billion to trillion dollar megacorps.
"proper registered association" means they had the 7 people needed to register one in Germany, threw together vaguely sensible bylaws & submitted them. No more and no less.
Of course Codeberg is more than that, but it does not mean they're rich. If they have non-profit status, they are also required to not waste money, and the German tax authorities occasionally audit that (since they hand out non-profit status).
(Source: I've registered two BGB §21 associations, both non-profit, and one BGB §22 association.)
Them having money is unrelated to them being a registered association. They are a registered association, and they have enough money from membership fees.
Looking at their annual budget, they estimated to get around €75k/year from membership fees and €50k from donations in 2026. Not even enough to pay for all their day-to-day operational costs, so they expected to use up some financial reserves to compensate.
They're also "contact us", i.e. even if money doesn't matter, giving them the money will cost you an absurd amount of time. Something that can be set up within an hour anywhere else will be weeks of dancing around with sales etc.
Cloudflare is at least somewhat responsible, although I guess codeberg wouldn't want to associate with them for many reasons.
Internationally, porkbun has good customer support despite the silly name, I haven't had bad experience with them yet.
Although for anything truly important the company I work for uses registrars with a physical presence in my country, where they can relatively easily be reached through court, or by going to the office and "yelling" at someone until the problem is resolved. Probably the best solution for an organization, even non profit?
As a German entity, I'm surprised that Codeberg e.V. decided to go with an American registrar. From my past experiences, there are certain services where I'd prefer a local contact. Domain registration is one of them, if possible.
> They'd be dealing with the American organization Public Interest Registry anyway
No, the domain is on clientHold. This means their registrar is the one responsible instead of the .org registry. PIR doesn't factor into this (as of now).
That surprised me to considering I'm with German registrar. INWX. The whole point of using CodeBerg is that it's supposed to be hosted entirely in the EU and not subject to some US off switch.
Anyway CodeBerg decided they won't accept any AI contributions so I opted for CodeFloe which is in the EU and seems to be hosted, registrared on Hetzner and with Bunny.net as CDN.
In fact all TLDs other than the two-letter country codes are American. Just another part of the exorbitant privilege we give to ICANN.
.com and .org and .edu aren't part of that exorbitant privilege though, they've been there since the time when the internet was an America-only thing, and grandfathered in.
I think the point is not the registrar is American, also with a European one for a .org the registry is still PIR in the US. The real problem is that today one click in an abuse office on the other side of the ocean switched off one of the few European alternatives to GitHub, without any judge. We are trying to leave the American house, but the key of our new house is still in their pocket.
I don’t. I encourage you to read my comment again, with an open mind. It’s about having a local contact in roughly the same timezone as yourself, and having not to deal with a completely different legal system. In complicated matters, it is also beneficial to be able to communicate in your native language.
They're talking about having a local contact, where local in this case just happens to mean Germany or at least the EU, rather than the US. They're not making it about any specific countries.
Germany is notorious for suspending domains for copyright. In fact its one of the first countries in Europe to implement blocking of websites and suspending domains due to copyright.
2021: The German highest civil court Bundesgerichtshof (“BGH”) [German Federal Supreme Court] has now held that domain registrars have duties of care to disconnect domains used by structurally copyright infringing websites
Sure, but considering Codeberg a "structurally copyright infringing website" is a bit of a stretch, isn't it? I mean, they explicitly banned AI-generated projects, amongst others to avoid hosting code with questionable copyright...
It did not sounded a cultural war matter about which nation's providers fail bigger, but sounded like a dealing with organisations in the local legislation thing, to me at least.
If you don't engage with the legal system that's true, but Codeberg is a registered German organisation that can afford to deploy lawyers when needed (they are cheaper in Germany).
German companies generally want to know your identity in class they need to sue you, and will kick you out by default for not telling them it, that's why it's seen as risky to use a .de domain for anything. However this does not apply to Codeberg. And it cuts both ways, they would also know their registrar's identity and be able to sue them.
Lest you think this is ridiculous, German people sue each other more per capita than Americans do.
"The domain is slowly recovering. Many users are able to connect to our systems again. Some might need to wait for DNS propagation.
We haven't yet received an official response from Namesilo's abuse department about the incident."
A bad look for Namesilo. I remember seeing this registrar as one of affordable and stable, like, as a alternative to more "mainstream" ones, and even used it in the past, but now I'm not so sure.
I was also surprised that Codeberg would use it instead of an EU-based registrar.
> clientHold: This status code tells your domain's registry to not activate your domain in the DNS and as a consequence, it will not resolve. It is an uncommon status that is usually enacted during legal disputes, non-payment, or when your domain is subject to deletion.
Thanks, but note to everyone: after adding that to your hosts file, open a new *private* window, then check the certificate. Ensure the certificate was issued (not valid before) well before the takeover. Anyone, once in control of the domain, can get a cert for it.
This + the whole quad9 thing sounds like maybe some hackers should go out and come up with DNS but decentralized and federated?
This is only going to get worse, but we can fix it. The system was designed for a world that doesn't exist anymore, but we can build one that is designed for the one that does.
While we're at it, maybe we can also fix the whole CA HTTPS nonsense?
Have been unemployed for almost all this year after being replaced by ai, my portfolio is hosted by Codeberg pages and now if anyone wants to take a look at it can't do it. Yikes!
I know of one subreddit where they didn't like the subreddit so they banned all the moderators for moderating the subreddit, and then banned the subreddit for being unmoderated.
> Abide by community rules. Participate authentically in communities where you have a personal interest, and do not spam or engage in disruptive behaviors (including content manipulation) that interfere with Reddit communities.
About time root zone came out of California based org's control. I am a networking noob so I don't really know how much that has been solved with that record being distributed across the globe
The country codes are safe-ish from the USA, there would be a riot if the USA tried to remove China or Iran and half the world would put it back in.
The problem is that all non-country TLDs are USA-controlled, and that the USA prints new ones for profit. Yes this includes ones like .tokyo and .berlin
"We decided not to enable codeberg.eu as a quick workaround: There are several technical difficulties (e.g. multi-domain support, SEO, Two-Factor-Authentication). The benefit of a temporary workaround compared to the effort is quite low (updating all the Git remotes and other references)."
this is crazy, guess i'll wait for codeberg to come back
Huh. As of 11:28am GMT I'm able to reach codeberg.org from Australia. Either the situation is resolved, or is it possible some DNS registries are not complying and are resolving the entry directly anyway? I think I have Google & Cloudflare for my DNS. I never use Codeberg, so I don't have any special entries in a hosts list.
This is what paying tax to Europe brings to you? This is an European business, so it needs to be taken seriously from the European Authorities.
Whatever Registry did this: namesilo or else, need to be investigated. A good reminder is that All the infrastructure (cables, electronics etc) are maintained and lay in European soil, meaning European laws apply for it. I am reporting it, this is not ok.
Great that they're back, it seems a no-brainer to get an IP address certificate as a fallback, to always have something reachable with TLS (and to commit to not move to other IPs without ample notice)
IMO people should not treat codeberg as another GitHub to dump random projects, they should develop at least a passing relationship with the people in the organisation if not joining it themselves, and treat it as what it is - a group of people trying to fight back against big tech.
It would be net better to spend your activism effort organizing a truly decentralized way to utilize already well-decentralized Git, instead of investing it into another centralized git host alternative. Especially if such operates as an opinionated & authoritarian non-profit in an overregulated country.
DNS and domain registrar is such an abusable single-point-of-failure that I can see it happens more and more often in the foreseeable dystopian future.
DNS is only single-point-of-failure if you're soley using a DNS server you have no control over (Google or Cloudflare) and have no fallback servers. DNS architecture is quite resilient due to its distributed nature.
DNS hosting isn't the problem here, it's their point of tie-in to the ICANN name registry that was cut off. And that can always be cut off and will be cut off more and more. The whole ecosystem is extremely banhappy since pirate sites, malware C&C, etc register domains at high rates and they want to ban those.
They should have used a .de domain through a German registrar. This would put their eggs in fewer country baskets. They have practically no recourse against namesilo but if a German company did it they'd sue them and win damages.
Fine as long as it's delegated at a high enough level. If it was codeberg.de they would have to cut off the whole .de, and they wouldn't dare. That would truly create a splinternet. But domains have come to be treated as arbitrary character strings with the political factors being ignored.
Note that's specific to .de which is a fairly powerful internet force. Some countries like .me are USA-controlled registries.
ENS is probably the best one, but a lot of people don't want to use crypto and only Brave supports it natively. Solana also has it's own equivalent with lower fees. Handshake, Unstoppable and Namecoin are just less secure versions of these two.
Domains are a global consensus problem so you either need a blockchain or a single trusted party.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but stealing a name in ENS is basically irreversible, yes? Say someone got access to your wallet and transferred the name to their wallet.
Maybe a protocol where only those with a private key corresponding to owning the domain can start a "dispute", and the arbiter entity (or consensus vote of multiple) can only choose which of the disputants gets reissued the domain.
There are many decentralised alternatives where you can actually own your domain: Namecoin[1], Gnunet's GNS[2], Ethereum Name Service[3], etc.
It's not a particularly hard problem to solve, I think it's just very unlikely that any of these will gain any traction. The average Joe couldn't care less about this issue and goverments and corporations would likely want to maintain the grip on the Internet they currently have.
DNS has one advantage that these cryptocurrency alternatives can't solve, and that's the ability for a human to decide you can have your domain name back after you've been hacked.
Practical control issues are becoming more of a political issue now that the USA has said the quiet part out loud by electing Trump and his cronies, but the cost of replacing DNS at this point is extremely high while the benefits are debatable for many people. This is mostly an issue for fringe groups, such as advocacy groups, non-commercial hosting providers, and individuals.
In codeberg's case the law is on their side but only in Germany. They should use a single .de domain. The government could still censor it, but that risk already exists since they publish their names and addresses and Germany is quite happy to raid apartments unannounced - it wouldn't add any new risk the way a US domain does.
Maybe we could post out "Internet Directories" once a year, which provides the domain name and IP address.
Of course, that would be quite a lot so perhaps it lists the Internet Sites in your area, and you can contact an operator ("Internet Directory Enquiries") to obtain the IP address of a Domain outside your area.
They actually used to do this. There was one lady in an office who managed the internet hosts file, accepted requests to change it and periodically sent out the new file. DNS was invented to replace it.
Gitea is superb too. Especially if you're going to set up a local git server for your agents to spazz on. It has built-in MCP support or something. The performance is shockingly good.
Or gitolite + cgit if you don't need the additional features like issue tracking and pull requests. It's harder to set up than Gitea, Forejo, or GitLab, but is a lot more flexible with things like repository layout. I've written custom install scripts to help with this.
You can use SSH directly, but using something like gitolite makes managing the git repos easier.
My main gripe with this setup (gitolite + cgit) is the lack of repository labels/tags. You can define a namespaced/scoped category, but that's not as flexible as a hierarchical tag system.
Yep. Not enough people know you can just "git init" a folder either on your machine or on any machine you can SSH into, and it just magically works.
The syntax for SSH access is user@hostname:/path/to/git/repo which you might recognise from github. You can use this syntax with any machine, not just GitHub. It invokes a real ssh subprocess to do the connection, so all of your .ssh config and private keys apply. It runs an internal git command on the server to do the data transfer (git receive-pack or git upload-pack).
thanks. well I can host my own git or Forgejo anywhere, and without need for DNS (pure IPs etc), but Codeberg.org meant for a distinct role analogous to Github.
As you probably noticed, our domain codeberg.org is entirely unreachable.
It was registered with namesilo and entirely disappeared from our account. We're waiting for their customer support to investigate the situation.
Update: We have received the confirmation that our domain was suspended and our case got forwarded to the abuse team. We're still waiting for a final decision.
Check 1984.hosting. They will go to court for you.
> We do not give in, no matter the cost to us in legal fees, security arrangements or peace of mind.
https://1984.hosting/policy/ https://litigation.1984.hosting/
I had a similar problem last week. My registrar suspended my account without further notice. Customer support told me to pay 90 euros per domain for recovery.
I got attention by creating a post on social media, some higher level people reached out to me and resolved the issue.
Is there anything one can do to prevent the entire company from going dark?
- What if my registrar suspends my account? => Use different registrars for different domains. - What if the whole TLD has an outage (DENIC had that before)? => Fallback tld?
Should I really setup all SaaS apps with fallback-domain support that is registered by a different registrar on a different tld?
What happens to my company mails?
I wanna be a plumber!
> Customer support told me to pay 90 euros per domain for recovery.
That's incredibly scammy.
It is scammy. But I would expect that they have it in terms and conditions.
Not everything a company writes in the terms and conditions is legal, not to mention morally defensible. For domains in particular, the registry and not the registrar sets the rules ultimately.
Sure, doesn't make it less scammy. Where I live, you can't just add whatever to the T&C and be able to legally force people to follow it, has to be stuff reasonable people would expect. Such term isn't one of those, so to small claims court I'd go, tends to scare most companies into action in my experience.
1. Hosting and domain registrars should be two different companies. Every time.
All other points are useless if you don’t follow the first one and the shite hits the fan…
This story made me want to run my own registrar with a “no automated enforcement” policy as my differentiator. While other services streamline by using AI for all operations, I would guarantee to you that my admin named “Steve“ would personally call your phone or notify you by overnight delivery if we thought such an action was necessary. You, of course, would need to pay a $$ deposit to cover the postage.
What had happened? Which registrar was this? What did they ask you to pay that 90 euro for?
The registrar seems to be namesilo
Never use a provider you can't litigate in court for business. That means use local providers and your national TLD
Don't even bother trying to be robust against your TLD failing.
Or do bother by having two domains at different registrars. Some websites that are at risk of TLD-level blocks do that proactively (mostly piracy related, but it's still something to learn from)
Did Namesilo notify you that the domain was suspended before you asked about it? And did they give a basis/reason at all? Weird situation
I wonder how a domain can be "suspended".
Is this something specific to the `.org` domains? I don't think you can "suspend" a `.com`?
> I don't think you can "suspend" a `.com`?
Oh you can suspend and destroy anything – not limited to domain names. The important part is – can someone stop you, or can someone prosecute you by virtue of you being from certain countries and the power and reach of said countries?
I've learnt and acknowledged that all this talk of "use your own domain", "degoogle", "pay for the email" (and I do), etc are safe until someone resourceful enough eyes your domain with the wrong kind of look.
.eu or member state cc-TLD paired with providers with matching jurisdiction seem fairly solid, based on what I heard. They would have to ask a court at my place, and that court will discuss the matter with me in my preferred language before doing anything harmful - and apply a high standard to claims of urgency.
Why not? The registry and registrar can suspend whatever they want, that constantly happens with piracy sites for example, which is why they all use random TLDs like .pk or .sk
Can they? Would that not be a breach of contract law to suspend a customer's domain name without cause?
Every contract between you and any business always says they can cancel the contract without cause but you can't
And the contract between ICANN and registrars says the registrars can't just do what ever they feel like.
The contract (RAA) between ICANN and the registrars also says they are required to suspend sites engaging in DNS Abuse, such as malware distribution, spam, or fraud.
Not sure why people are acting surprised about this. This seems like an extremely obvious thing that would be in place...
(The hilarious part is Namesilo doesn't even action valid malware abuse reports I send them but apparently does for codeberg, which is a legitimate service? Figures. Maybe I will submit that ICANN complaint after all.)
And country codes don't have this contract between them and ICANN, which is important. Each country is allowed to set its own rules.
Yes, in my eyes rather annoying as it makes it difficult/impossible to get something malicious taken down in such cases, since I have no tool to hit registrars over the head with. But I guess it makes sense.
Who says it is without cause?
They are required to suspend for example if the contact details are invalid. Not saying it is the case here.
https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/registration-data-accu...
.pk isn't random. It's Pakistan's ccTLD and .sk is Slovakia's. Random would be .fyi, .tkfjksbkfs, and that .god-knows-what-new-edgy-tld.
Yeah, I understand those are not just random letters. I meant "random" as in it's not a major TLD and it wasn't chosen because the website is somehow related to that country. Whois shows they're registered with some obscure registrar in the Bahamas which doesn't even have a working website.
It's weird, because the pirate bay's .org domain still works, after decades of copyright holders trying to get rid of it.
Maybe Codeberg should use whatever registrar TPB is using.
I think Njalla did unlist Sci-Hub, though (<https://x.com/ringo_ring/status/2012865526637228312>), so I don't know how reliable it is.
Probably because TPB is an irrelevant low-quality wasteland, that honey traps people who otherwise would've gone to more useful sites. Those other more useful sites regularly get their domains suspended.
Eh, rutracker also has their .org domain despite not being an "irrelevant low-quality wasteland"
It's pretty simple really. The registry or registrar just decides you shouldn't have a domain and poof! you don't.
I expect the domain will remain permanently suspended since Codeberg violates US law, and .com and .org are US TLDs. They should have done codeberg.de witha German registrar, since they're operating within DE law they would be able to sue the registry or registrar for contract violation.
> registry or registrar
Good time to remind people that there are direct registration TLDs. Obviously not always a viable option but I prefer to use them as there is one less (useless and often scammy) middleman to deal with.
For example .is and .at offer this.
And .de does too: https://direct.secure.denic.de/en/
Given codeberg has a German nonprofit it seems like a good fit to run de domain too.
How does Codeberg violate US law?
Codeberg is where projects tend to go when they are taken off of Github for violating DMCA.
There’s precedent too, in 2016 Namecheap suspended Openload's domain because of DMCA reports against the domain (they later reinstated it tho).
They host gallery-dl for example.
They've been used for phishing and to distribute malware. Maybe they haven't done enough to stop that.
There is many orders of magnitude more malware distributed by Google, Microsoft, Amazon, etc.
And Codeberg has removed malware that Microsoft & Google refused to remove for obscure reasons, so this makes no sense.
So has pypi, npm, github, aws, azure and everything else.
Do they take down projects when the USA sends them legal demands?
> since Codeberg violates US law
source for this claim?
> I expect the domain will remain permanently suspended since Codeberg violates US law
And its back :-P
I'm happy to inform you that you were wrong.
Many reasons. For example if codeberg has not fixed invalid contact info for the domain.
I’m surprised that as a German organization, you are using an American registrar, where such issues are inherently more difficult to handle, and are possibly more likely to happen.
Consider switching to a .eu domain it might have better governance.
They should do .de
The .eu TLD has France as stakeholder, which gives much stronger sovereignty guarantees than simply relying on Germany alone.
That just means either France or Germany can ban it, like France banned Quad9.
our case got forwarded to the abuse team. We're still waiting for a final decision.
This is so crazy.
How are high-availability services supposed to block this failure mode? Become your own registrar?
Have enough money to afford a legal team capable of posing a threat to the registrar if they pull something like this.
Registrars do this to the little guys because they know they can get away with it.
This doesn't always work. In many cases they'll try to call your bluff, and you'll have to actually back up your threats with real action. Of course with a real legal team that wouldn't be too much of a problem, but you wouldn't have prevented anything.
A real legal action would recover whatever money you lost because of the registrar's decision, so you wouldn't actually care that the downtime occurred.
I dropped the usage of DNS registrars since they are nearly all gated by whatwg cartel web engines, and I do include the payment systems.
Honest question: how exactly do you do that? I would appreciate an explanation.
You could use an overlay network like I2P, Yggdrasil, Tor. You could use your hosts file. You could use an alternative DNS system like OpenNIC.
At this point just use an IP address.
Multiple domains with different registrars/TLDs. And real (non-CNAME) DNS records for all of them.
markmonitor
Use a registrar whose HTML <title> isn't "Cheap domain names".
I don't mean to be facetious, but cheap domain registrars don't have enough margin to have decent abuse departments.
Github use https://www.markmonitor.com/ . I have no idea who they are, but "See why half of the top 10 most trafficked websites in the world are managed via Markmonitor.", and their prices aren't listed.
I'm guessing these guys don't fold, and customers don't hear "We have received the confirmation that our domain was suspended and our case got forwarded to the abuse team."
> and their prices aren't listed
Last I heard, there was a ~$10k/year minimum spend, but that was a good few years back
When it's back up, we can compare that to Codeberg's entire annual budget: https://codeberg.org/Codeberg-e.V./Documents-Public/src/bran...
I'm not sure what this will demonstrate, but it is undeniably this sub-thread's destiny.
It's back up. They get $75k from memberships and $50k from donations, spend $220k (almost entirely on salaries) and draw down capital reserves to make up the difference.
You are being facetious. This is like a village having problem of their property being routinely stolen and the suggestion is everyone in the village should become billionaires and hire their own private militias.
I initially didn't have the paragraph on Github/Markmonitor. I later added it because it seemed interesting, but I realise it made my overall point weaker.
I suppose the gap is that there are domain providers between namesilo and Markmonitor.
kiwifarms has entered the chat
You're being downvoted but you're right. Sites that are incredibly unpopular are a good canary for who won't remove your site at the first complaint.
Torrent sites too, and bulletproof hosts. Sometimes I make a note of who's getting on the various USA warning lists because I know those companies won't take down my stuff for no reason.
Care to explain to the uninitiated?
It was a shitty site made by/for shitty people, which made it a great test how different providers handle such cases. It took considerable "internet outrage" for Cloudflare to drop them. So I guess that is the type of provider you want to stick with it, that will usually wait for actual court order, not just turn your site off on a whim.
They are more than "shitty" people, they are below human.
Their targeted harassment/doxxing drove many good people to suicide themselves (e.g. byuu emulator developer from Bsnes/Near fame).
kiwifarms still exists, they just run their own protection now
Cloudflare was making a lot of data profit from being the MITM to a bunch of shitty people.
> It was registered with namesilo
Why do people use these penny ante companies for anything important?
A bit more concerning aspect is an European FOSS (beer+freedom) git host is using an American domain registrar.
But then what else because for .org: registrar -> PIR -> ISOC or ICANN -> the US of A.
Something like .eu might have been better. Maybe?
Either way, ICANN has a long history of being an instrument of US interests. That's just the DNS system for you.
It's a .org domain so it's American no matter what.
Yes but they could still use a registrar that operates under their laws, is more friendly to them and does helpful things like notify them of the problem and give them a chance to remediate it before suspension. Yes the US can still reach them but it would require due process. Of course we only have one side of the story here, it is possible Codeberg did not respond in the required timeframe for something.
Why does this need to be an anti-USA issue? I don't expect the country, laws, or culture had anything to do with the domain being suspended.
This particular issue doesn't need to be caused by the USA but you should definitely avoid USA domains regardless of that.
Is the concern that US politicians will compel registrars to take sites down or something?
Yes? They do it quite a lot. They can compel both registrars and registries.
Because at first it's not important, then it works and then it's not a priority to change it.
Who do you suggest?
Maybe the registrar that thepiratebay.org uses.
MarkMonitor Inc. It's what Craigslist uses, and you can be sure people have tried to steal that one out from under them.
Same MarkMonitor as these assholes? https://torrentfreak.com/tag/markmonitor/
What exactly are we meant to be paying attention to here?
Isn't it very expensive? Codeberg runs on very little money.
You get what you pay for. At the end of the day it's a business decision, and if this downtime isn't worth that cost then that's the executive's decision.
I get a feeling you have a skewed view of what codeberg is. It's not a company, there are no "executives", at least not like you'd see in a commercial organization, and they have a million things of much higher priority that could use money (like additional hardware) than extremely expensive registrars mostly used by billion to trillion dollar megacorps.
MarkMonitor is extremely expensive.
Everyone that matters uses MarkMonitor.
MarkMonitor prices are "contact us". So, it's NOT cheap.
...oh except for Apple, that uses some similar "contact us" registrar, I forgot the name but simple to find out.
And Meta, they run their own registrar that is just for them.
Codeberg is a proper registered association that can afford lawyers and stuff when needed. They could at least contact them to find out the pricing.
"proper registered association" means they had the 7 people needed to register one in Germany, threw together vaguely sensible bylaws & submitted them. No more and no less.
Of course Codeberg is more than that, but it does not mean they're rich. If they have non-profit status, they are also required to not waste money, and the German tax authorities occasionally audit that (since they hand out non-profit status).
(Source: I've registered two BGB §21 associations, both non-profit, and one BGB §22 association.)
Them having money is unrelated to them being a registered association. They are a registered association, and they have enough money from membership fees.
Looking at their annual budget, they estimated to get around €75k/year from membership fees and €50k from donations in 2026. Not even enough to pay for all their day-to-day operational costs, so they expected to use up some financial reserves to compensate.
They're also "contact us", i.e. even if money doesn't matter, giving them the money will cost you an absurd amount of time. Something that can be set up within an hour anywhere else will be weeks of dancing around with sales etc.
I am very happy with dns.services.
Cloudflare is at least somewhat responsible, although I guess codeberg wouldn't want to associate with them for many reasons.
Internationally, porkbun has good customer support despite the silly name, I haven't had bad experience with them yet.
Although for anything truly important the company I work for uses registrars with a physical presence in my country, where they can relatively easily be reached through court, or by going to the office and "yelling" at someone until the problem is resolved. Probably the best solution for an organization, even non profit?
Exactly my question.
can’t tell if you’re talking about namesilo or codeberg
This is how you fight BigDomain - you use your organic, locally grown, ethically sourced mom&pop domain name register.
Fight the system!
Do you have a recommended workaround? E.g. another domain or putting an IP into hosts?
Add the following to /etc/hosts:
https://social.anoxinon.de/@codebergstatus/11763718771117769...
> The domain is slowly recovering. Many users are able to connect to our systems again. Some might need to wait for DNS propagation.
> Thank you so much for your patience. We're sorry for the serious disruption.
> We haven't yet received an official response from Namesilo's abuse department about the incident.
As a German entity, I'm surprised that Codeberg e.V. decided to go with an American registrar. From my past experiences, there are certain services where I'd prefer a local contact. Domain registration is one of them, if possible.
They'd be dealing with the American organization Public Interest Registry anyway, who manages .org, not sure if this makes much of a difference.
> They'd be dealing with the American organization Public Interest Registry anyway
No, the domain is on clientHold. This means their registrar is the one responsible instead of the .org registry. PIR doesn't factor into this (as of now).
The registry will also want to suspend them at some point since they host stuff that's illegal in America. They should definitely go fully German.
Oh so you have no idea about the difference between clientHold and serverHold. Thanks for your valuable contributions to this thread.
Do you know the meaning of the word "also"?
From your multiple repetitions of this wrong statement all over the place, I seem to understand that's some kind of wish of yours.
That surprised me to considering I'm with German registrar. INWX. The whole point of using CodeBerg is that it's supposed to be hosted entirely in the EU and not subject to some US off switch.
Anyway CodeBerg decided they won't accept any AI contributions so I opted for CodeFloe which is in the EU and seems to be hosted, registrared on Hetzner and with Bunny.net as CDN.
Even an American TLD. I hope one day we'll stop being so cute about them and use the ones we have in the EU for services based in the EU.
.org isn't an American TLD though... any more than .com or .edu are
.com and .edu are too - even more so.
All of those are literally American TLDs.
In fact all TLDs other than the two-letter country codes are American. Just another part of the exorbitant privilege we give to ICANN.
.com and .org and .edu aren't part of that exorbitant privilege though, they've been there since the time when the internet was an America-only thing, and grandfathered in.
I think the point is not the registrar is American, also with a European one for a .org the registry is still PIR in the US. The real problem is that today one click in an abuse office on the other side of the ocean switched off one of the few European alternatives to GitHub, without any judge. We are trying to leave the American house, but the key of our new house is still in their pocket.
Yeah like german registries dont suspend domains for anything without actually checking anything . Dont make it a country issue.
Yes, but it will be easier to act upon this if a German legal entity uses a German service provider.
The German company can just say to refer to ICANN copyright dispute procedure which wont be handled by a German company for .org.
That's why they should use a .de domain
I don’t. I encourage you to read my comment again, with an open mind. It’s about having a local contact in roughly the same timezone as yourself, and having not to deal with a completely different legal system. In complicated matters, it is also beneficial to be able to communicate in your native language.
They're talking about having a local contact, where local in this case just happens to mean Germany or at least the EU, rather than the US. They're not making it about any specific countries.
German registrars aren’t subject to the DMCA for one.
Germany is notorious for suspending domains for copyright. In fact its one of the first countries in Europe to implement blocking of websites and suspending domains due to copyright.
2014: German court finds domain registrar liable for torrent site’s copyright infringement
https://www.pcworld.com/article/443769/german-court-finds-do...
2021: The German highest civil court Bundesgerichtshof (“BGH”) [German Federal Supreme Court] has now held that domain registrars have duties of care to disconnect domains used by structurally copyright infringing websites
https://legalblogs.wolterskluwer.com/copyright-blog/rogue-we...
Sure, but considering Codeberg a "structurally copyright infringing website" is a bit of a stretch, isn't it? I mean, they explicitly banned AI-generated projects, amongst others to avoid hosting code with questionable copyright...
That's not why they banned AI content.
It’s one of many reasons why they did it.
Codeberg isn't a torrent site.
It did not sounded a cultural war matter about which nation's providers fail bigger, but sounded like a dealing with organisations in the local legislation thing, to me at least.
Well yes but actually no.
I believe it's much easier to get your domain suspended in Germany vs in the US.
If you don't engage with the legal system that's true, but Codeberg is a registered German organisation that can afford to deploy lawyers when needed (they are cheaper in Germany).
German companies generally want to know your identity in class they need to sue you, and will kick you out by default for not telling them it, that's why it's seen as risky to use a .de domain for anything. However this does not apply to Codeberg. And it cuts both ways, they would also know their registrar's identity and be able to sue them.
Lest you think this is ridiculous, German people sue each other more per capita than Americans do.
Update 2026-11-18 12:30 CET
"The domain is slowly recovering. Many users are able to connect to our systems again. Some might need to wait for DNS propagation. We haven't yet received an official response from Namesilo's abuse department about the incident."
https://mastodon.social/@codebergstatus@social.anoxinon.de/1...
A bad look for Namesilo. I remember seeing this registrar as one of affordable and stable, like, as a alternative to more "mainstream" ones, and even used it in the past, but now I'm not so sure.
I was also surprised that Codeberg would use it instead of an EU-based registrar.
Thanks, but note to everyone: after adding that to your hosts file, open a new *private* window, then check the certificate. Ensure the certificate was issued (not valid before) well before the takeover. Anyone, once in control of the domain, can get a cert for it.
This + the whole quad9 thing sounds like maybe some hackers should go out and come up with DNS but decentralized and federated?
This is only going to get worse, but we can fix it. The system was designed for a world that doesn't exist anymore, but we can build one that is designed for the one that does.
While we're at it, maybe we can also fix the whole CA HTTPS nonsense?
Zooko's Triangle. You can pick any two: secure, decentralised, human-readable. (Secure means that a name resolves to the same address for everyone)
Secure and human-readable: DNS
Secure and decentralised: .onion
Decentralised and human-readable: petnames or hosts files
Have been unemployed for almost all this year after being replaced by ai, my portfolio is hosted by Codeberg pages and now if anyone wants to take a look at it can't do it. Yikes!
It's back up. You can stop hyperventilating.
r/Codeberg has been banned from reddit:
---
r/Codeberg is banned
This community was banned for violating Rule 2.
You agree that use of this site constitutes acceptance of Reddit’s User Agreement and acknowledge our Privacy Policy.
---
https://www.reddit.com/r/codeberg/
Archive.org shows that's a totally dead subreddit with zero activity,
https://web.archive.org/web/20250214215322/https://old.reddi...
I'd guess it was taken over by spambots at some point.
Probably not even that, merely was unmodderated. They've closed a lot of subreddits over that, even with active communities.
I know of one subreddit where they didn't like the subreddit so they banned all the moderators for moderating the subreddit, and then banned the subreddit for being unmoderated.
Yep, I too am aware of such cases.
It's weaponization of the rules at it's finest.
Who cares about Reddit any more? Half of it is a ghost town that's been banned, and the other half is a massive bot propaganda operation.
Rule 2 is:
> Abide by community rules. Participate authentically in communities where you have a personal interest, and do not spam or engage in disruptive behaviors (including content manipulation) that interfere with Reddit communities.
https://redditinc.com/policies/reddit-rules
Sounds serious. What is going on here? Did not comply with the AI Overlords?
About time root zone came out of California based org's control. I am a networking noob so I don't really know how much that has been solved with that record being distributed across the globe
https://www.iana.org/domains/root/files
https://www.iana.org/domains/root/servers
I know UN's ITU might not be the best org for this but this has to come out of USA.
The country codes are safe-ish from the USA, there would be a riot if the USA tried to remove China or Iran and half the world would put it back in.
The problem is that all non-country TLDs are USA-controlled, and that the USA prints new ones for profit. Yes this includes ones like .tokyo and .berlin
"We decided not to enable codeberg.eu as a quick workaround: There are several technical difficulties (e.g. multi-domain support, SEO, Two-Factor-Authentication). The benefit of a temporary workaround compared to the effort is quite low (updating all the Git remotes and other references)."
this is crazy, guess i'll wait for codeberg to come back
> updating all the Git remotes and other references
Why update all the remotes if you can just add a `HostName` entry to your OpenSSH client config?
Point is still that every user would have to do that. It's not exactly an easy fix for the majority of users
I mean if you're using git repositories you can also be asked to edit such a config file.
Not everything is OpenSSH
Git is
/etc/hosts:
I like the `c0de` part
When you have IPv6 you almost always get the last 64 bits to yourself and sometimes you get the next 16 as well.
Huh. As of 11:28am GMT I'm able to reach codeberg.org from Australia. Either the situation is resolved, or is it possible some DNS registries are not complying and are resolving the entry directly anyway? I think I have Google & Cloudflare for my DNS. I never use Codeberg, so I don't have any special entries in a hosts list.
restored in my US location now too. its DNS record was only suspended for approx 4 hours (?). from say 1:30am to 5:30am US Central tz.
This is what paying tax to Europe brings to you? This is an European business, so it needs to be taken seriously from the European Authorities.
Whatever Registry did this: namesilo or else, need to be investigated. A good reminder is that All the infrastructure (cables, electronics etc) are maintained and lay in European soil, meaning European laws apply for it. I am reporting it, this is not ok.
Take a breath buddy. Yes this needs to be fixed, no this doesn't need to be escalated to an international incident.
Why not, imagine if an European registrar does that to github? I would say this establish a precedent if not dealt properly.
I'd expect it to get fixed quickly and move on.
It’s back online again - https://social.anoxinon.de/@codebergstatus/11763718771117769...
It is back!
Works for me as of 12:25 CET
Great that they're back, it seems a no-brainer to get an IP address certificate as a fallback, to always have something reachable with TLS (and to commit to not move to other IPs without ample notice)
(https://letsencrypt.org/2026/01/15/6day-and-ip-general-avail...)
nintendo?
did the emulators move to codeberg?
i thought this was a serious project. No backup domain for a platform that host repositories.
Can someone dare to explain why this happened ? Why did Namesilo suspend the domain ?
I feel bad for everyone who migrated from github to codeberg because "github has terrible uptime"
I wonder how many projects will move back after this?
IMO people should not treat codeberg as another GitHub to dump random projects, they should develop at least a passing relationship with the people in the organisation if not joining it themselves, and treat it as what it is - a group of people trying to fight back against big tech.
It would be net better to spend your activism effort organizing a truly decentralized way to utilize already well-decentralized Git, instead of investing it into another centralized git host alternative. Especially if such operates as an opinionated & authoritarian non-profit in an overregulated country.
Does a decentralised model preclude groups coming together to share costs? You can also start your own codeberg yes.
I migrated because github is terrible, not because it has terrible uptime.
Also codeberg is up again.
restored!
DNS and domain registrar is such an abusable single-point-of-failure that I can see it happens more and more often in the foreseeable dystopian future.
DNS is only single-point-of-failure if you're soley using a DNS server you have no control over (Google or Cloudflare) and have no fallback servers. DNS architecture is quite resilient due to its distributed nature.
DNS hosting isn't the problem here, it's their point of tie-in to the ICANN name registry that was cut off. And that can always be cut off and will be cut off more and more. The whole ecosystem is extremely banhappy since pirate sites, malware C&C, etc register domains at high rates and they want to ban those.
They should have used a .de domain through a German registrar. This would put their eggs in fewer country baskets. They have practically no recourse against namesilo but if a German company did it they'd sue them and win damages.
you cannot use redundant registrars. And the registrar is the one who can change/drop the NS records.
EDIT: didn't see you were writing about DNS specifically, not about registrars
Yep, registrars are kinda free to do whatever they want unfortunately.
You still have the ICANN DNS root as a single point of failure.
Fine as long as it's delegated at a high enough level. If it was codeberg.de they would have to cut off the whole .de, and they wouldn't dare. That would truly create a splinternet. But domains have come to be treated as arbitrary character strings with the political factors being ignored.
Note that's specific to .de which is a fairly powerful internet force. Some countries like .me are USA-controlled registries.
Agree. Any alternatives in mind?
ENS is probably the best one, but a lot of people don't want to use crypto and only Brave supports it natively. Solana also has it's own equivalent with lower fees. Handshake, Unstoppable and Namecoin are just less secure versions of these two.
Domains are a global consensus problem so you either need a blockchain or a single trusted party.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but stealing a name in ENS is basically irreversible, yes? Say someone got access to your wallet and transferred the name to their wallet.
any entity that can reverse something like that can also unilaterally block your domain, so...
Maybe a protocol where only those with a private key corresponding to owning the domain can start a "dispute", and the arbiter entity (or consensus vote of multiple) can only choose which of the disputants gets reissued the domain.
But reversibly.
There are many decentralised alternatives where you can actually own your domain: Namecoin[1], Gnunet's GNS[2], Ethereum Name Service[3], etc.
It's not a particularly hard problem to solve, I think it's just very unlikely that any of these will gain any traction. The average Joe couldn't care less about this issue and goverments and corporations would likely want to maintain the grip on the Internet they currently have.
[1]: https://www.namecoin.org/ [2]: https://www.gnunet.org/en/gns.html [3]: https://ens.domains/
DNS has one advantage that these cryptocurrency alternatives can't solve, and that's the ability for a human to decide you can have your domain name back after you've been hacked.
Practical control issues are becoming more of a political issue now that the USA has said the quiet part out loud by electing Trump and his cronies, but the cost of replacing DNS at this point is extremely high while the benefits are debatable for many people. This is mostly an issue for fringe groups, such as advocacy groups, non-commercial hosting providers, and individuals.
Tor onion services aren't a bad idea for this. Many sites have one. https://community.torproject.org/onion-services/
Have multiple domains
This is probably the only practical solution, though it's not without its drawbacks.
Multiple trusted domains is a great way to teach your users to trust any domain that looks like yours.
In codeberg's case the law is on their side but only in Germany. They should use a single .de domain. The government could still censor it, but that risk already exists since they publish their names and addresses and Germany is quite happy to raid apartments unannounced - it wouldn't add any new risk the way a US domain does.
And the relevance for a Wikipedia article listing them.
That's working pretty well for Library Genesis, Anna's Archive etc..
Handshake - https://hns.sh
Not very confidence inspiring that one of their featured links goes to some crypto page: https://e.hnsfans.com/
Handshake is a cryptocurrency project.
Manual entries in /etc/hosts.
Maybe we could post out "Internet Directories" once a year, which provides the domain name and IP address.
Of course, that would be quite a lot so perhaps it lists the Internet Sites in your area, and you can contact an operator ("Internet Directory Enquiries") to obtain the IP address of a Domain outside your area.
They actually used to do this. There was one lady in an office who managed the internet hosts file, accepted requests to change it and periodically sent out the new file. DNS was invented to replace it.
To replace her/them, technically lol
GitHub got so jealous of Codeberg uptime that they resolved to social engineering to oh so charitably give Codeberg some downtime hah
Codeberg doesn't exactly have great uptime itself anyway (which is somewhat understandable given their limited resources, but still).
jesus make it stop
Codeberg.org was my backup/alt git forge provider, in migration from and mitigation of GitHub/MS clownery
If you can host locally, forgejo is a good option.
Forgejo is hosted on Codeberg!
haha indeed, and Codeberg is built on Forgejo! :-D
Gitea is superb too. Especially if you're going to set up a local git server for your agents to spazz on. It has built-in MCP support or something. The performance is shockingly good.
Or gitolite + cgit if you don't need the additional features like issue tracking and pull requests. It's harder to set up than Gitea, Forejo, or GitLab, but is a lot more flexible with things like repository layout. I've written custom install scripts to help with this.
You can use SSH directly, but using something like gitolite makes managing the git repos easier.
My main gripe with this setup (gitolite + cgit) is the lack of repository labels/tags. You can define a namespaced/scoped category, but that's not as flexible as a hierarchical tag system.
I'd say Tangled.org is the best option.
Also for solo projects, just git on its own is pretty good as well.
Yep. Not enough people know you can just "git init" a folder either on your machine or on any machine you can SSH into, and it just magically works.
The syntax for SSH access is user@hostname:/path/to/git/repo which you might recognise from github. You can use this syntax with any machine, not just GitHub. It invokes a real ssh subprocess to do the connection, so all of your .ssh config and private keys apply. It runs an internal git command on the server to do the data transfer (git receive-pack or git upload-pack).
thanks. well I can host my own git or Forgejo anywhere, and without need for DNS (pure IPs etc), but Codeberg.org meant for a distinct role analogous to Github.
You migrated from the (granted, clownery) Github to a platform that forbids AI use? o_O
Not sure which one is clowner.
oh I'm sure. heh
Put the IP addresses in your hosts file and everything will appear normal.
Whatever you do, don't go back to big tech. They're causing this.
Jesus is currently unavailable to handle your tech support issues