The H1B program has been heavily abused for years. While there has been some collateral damage with the current crackdown, it’s pretty hard to defend what was going on in this space prior to the crackdown.
The latest action by the administration is to eliminate the 60 day grace period that non-immigrant employees have to either arrange their affairs prior to leaving or find a new position.
I have seen plenty of defense of that action, such as the claim that "immigrants have no rights." Typically, the same people also defend the executions of Alex Pretti and Renee Good. People who aren't completely ignorant of reality know that the administration's actions have absolutely nothing to do with "protecting American workers."
Adam Serwer could have never imagined that his amazingly poignant phrase "The Cruelty Is the Point" would continue to be spot-on for almost eight years now: https://archive.ph/vuY5r.
The word semantics aspect of the argument here doesn't hold. Renewable statuses are called "permanent" like permanent residency in Canada which requires renewal subject to conditions.
Well the indentured servants that need to compete with China on an industrial scale need to come from somewhere. It just turns out the program importing them is based on a system of caste & race, and achieving goals isn't necessarily a part of bilking people.
Also, pointing this out tends to be a form of noticing the emperor is indeed, not wearing clothes...
Letting the executive play with policy seems like a wild overreach. I wish congress limited those powers.
>Among the highest lottery entrants in FY2026 were Cognizant, Infosys, and
Tata, which submitted 100%, 91%, and 95% fewer registrations in FY2027, respectively
Very effective in bringing down abuse. It doesn't comment on the impact of fields where immigrants are needed and they can't afford the $100k
universities, despite being cap-exempt, are not exempted from this fee. This has basically killed academic hiring of foreign academics (i.e. the ability for American universities to brain-drain foreign ones as they historically have).
The US produces almost 2M more college graduates every year than it has jobs for. Those universities can hire US labor or go without. Frankly, many of them can shutter and we’ll still have plenty of higher education capacity, there are already far too many colleges for forward curve of future need.
We have plenty of folks underemployed or unemployed with masters and phd credentials already. How will importing more folks help?
> A new estimate projects that 442 of the nation’s 1,700 private, nonprofit four-year colleges and universities, with a combined 670,000 students, are at risk of closing or having to merge within the next 10 years.
> A 2024 report by the Burning Glass Institute and Strada Institute for the Future of Work found that, a year after graduation, about half of US college grads were in jobs that “do not require a degree or make meaningful use of college-level skills.”
I agree that a lot needs to change about the H-1B program, but I don't love how much of it has come from executive orders and worse: just offhand statements that drive employers into anxiety and uncertainty. Uncertainty is just the worst thing for the market (and my own salary prospects). The $100,000 fee felt like it was rolled out in jolts. Who was affected? Who was exempt?
At least with laws passed, we see it coming from a long way away. IMO, congress should reduce the powers the executive branch can just wield on this or that, and set the agenda, rather than letting the agenda be set by the president every 4/8 years.
You gotta take a civics class. You cant move fast and break things with legislation. The precendent of the executive branch disturbing the balance of power by making laws and policy like this is not worth the benefit of this one issue being expedited. We need to have congress solve this problem because that maintains the balance of power
I think you’re the one who needs a civics course. These are powers vested in the executive since this country’s inception, and this is hardly the first time they have disturbed the “balance of power”, especially when almost every EO this administration has put out has been judicially challenged at every point, whether the challenge had actual legal standing or not.
I agree that congress should speak on this (and codify more strict immigration laws), but EOs are only enforcing the powers within the executive branch, not creating new laws. When they restrict an agency’s abilities or empower them, these are simply internal orders within the executive branch, in large part because no singular law or laws govern agencies and defines their explicit day-to-day. EPA, DEA, and NSA are all examples of executive-led agencies made without explicit law codifying their creation. And, such as with H1B, even when the legislation created it the laws are loose enough to give the executive full legal control without disturbing anything from a civics perspective.
Congress spoke in ‘52 and set the ceiling. Executive speaks today and tells you how that ceiling will be reached, if at all. Judicial speaks tomorrow and ensures that orders from today follow the rules from ‘52, and due to the current laws they do.
Civics class isn’t going to make Congress functional. The evidence is the executive branch can do a lot of what it’s done, and if Congress does nothing, there are no consequences for doing so.
Balance of power only exists if you allow it to, if you have power. If you can’t be or aren’t bound by a counterbalance, there is no balance of power, its honor system.
Congress has had over two decades to fix this. They haven’t. Someone else did.
They are, also, not American citizens. The duty of the American government is to ensure the American citizens are not being taken advantage of first and foremost. This does not, and should never extend, to putting non-citizens above citizens.
Wish to gain those same privileges? Then become a citizen, not an eternal immigrant.
Reading through the comments it is easy to see that everybody is MAGA when it comes to their own jobs. All of the people harping on ICE actions being bad somehow support kicking out H1-B folks same day when they lose their jobs.
> Reading through the comments it is easy to see that everybody is MAGA when it comes to their own jobs.
So you're saying that they're pitiless jerks when it comes to other people's jobs? "Some of you may lose your jobs, but that's a price I'm willing to pay to save myself some money."
It would be interesting to see three other data points along side with the timeline of these actions.
- The pace of job migration permanently into eastern Europe, India or elsewhere.
- The drop in Graduate and PhD enrollment from abroad.
- Direction of wage changes of tech workers in the US.
Overall, U.S. campuses saw a 9% decrease in international enrollment this fall compared with last year, according to a survey from the Institute of International Education. And the number of new students entering the United States for the first time fell by 15%. (https://www.cbsnews.com/news/us-universities-fewer-foreign-s...)
NYT analyzed data from 27 of the nation’s top research universities. Between 2024 and 2025, new Ph.D. enrollments declined by about 18 percent in engineering programs and by about 10 percent in science and health disciplines. New enrollments in math and computer science programs also dropped by roughly 10 percent. (Visual: https://static01.nytimes.com/newsgraphics/GM5Fq9Q3ZdykmA/_im...)
This is the first thing I can genuinely remember in nearly my entire lifetime that a president has done that directly impacts most Americans in a positive, universal, bipartisan way. Too bad Congress ignored, and actively aided and abetted, this abuse for decades. Trump has been horrible in a lot of ways, but even a broken clock is right occasionally and I'll give him credit on this one. And democrats would have cowered and wilted before ever even doing this--they have no backbone to have any sense of national civic duty to protect actual Americans.
I disagree. I’d rather have the Indian immigrants one way or the other. They are incredibly beneficial to the US economy from a founder perspective and in higher education.
People are incredibly hypocritical when it comes to what they perceive to impact their own jobs and your post is a good example of this. Indian Americans are 1% of the population and pay 6% of the taxes and this will disproportionately impact Indians and put them under very harsh conditions even those who've been here for decades waiting for Green Cards but yeah, go Trump.
I, as a full-blooded American, wish to see my country and people prosper. You, as a full-blooded Indian (not “Indian American”, unless you are a dual citizen to India and America) wish to see your people prosper in my country.
I understand, you want what is best for your people, but I and many other Americans want what is best for ours.
The H1B program has been heavily abused for years. While there has been some collateral damage with the current crackdown, it’s pretty hard to defend what was going on in this space prior to the crackdown.
The latest action by the administration is to eliminate the 60 day grace period that non-immigrant employees have to either arrange their affairs prior to leaving or find a new position.
https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/09/11/2026-18...
Forcing people to leave the same day they lose their job is completely indefensible.
I have seen plenty of defense of that action, such as the claim that "immigrants have no rights." Typically, the same people also defend the executions of Alex Pretti and Renee Good. People who aren't completely ignorant of reality know that the administration's actions have absolutely nothing to do with "protecting American workers."
Adam Serwer could have never imagined that his amazingly poignant phrase "The Cruelty Is the Point" would continue to be spot-on for almost eight years now: https://archive.ph/vuY5r.
[flagged]
I have no children and rent. I would find leaving the same day extremely difficult.
H1B is also not a temporary visa. It's renewable indefinitely with an approved I140.
[flagged]
The word semantics aspect of the argument here doesn't hold. Renewable statuses are called "permanent" like permanent residency in Canada which requires renewal subject to conditions.
> Renewable is temporary.
A green card needs to be renewed too. Only citizenship is pretty much permanent...
> There is no guarantee your I140 will be approved.
You misunderstood. The I140 has to be approved prior to renewal.
Why 14 and not 60? Is some American worker going to benefit by having this person leave 46 days earlier?
> Is some American worker going to benefit by having this person leave 46 days earlier?
A different foreigner can enjoy more housing supply and lower prices, 46 days sooner.
Unless you assume every immigration issue is citizen vs foreigner?
The one thing they need to do above all else is ban body shops from sponsoring. That is the core of the abuse and they'll never touch it.
Well the indentured servants that need to compete with China on an industrial scale need to come from somewhere. It just turns out the program importing them is based on a system of caste & race, and achieving goals isn't necessarily a part of bilking people.
Also, pointing this out tends to be a form of noticing the emperor is indeed, not wearing clothes...
> indentured servants
Highest paying industry worldwide.
> caste & race
Yep, we all know of elite leetcode interviews around caste.
/s
> Highest paying industry worldwide.
The finance industry produces more billionaires and centi-millionaires than the tech industry.
Always has. Always will.
Do you see people from that one country succeeding in finance? Nope.
Hell, that one country lost the AI race. They are nowhere to be seen at US frontier labs or US quant HFT firms.
Sorry can you clarify what you mean here? Which country are you talking about?
I think he's talking about India.
> nowhere to be seen
big if true
> Sorry can you clarify what you mean here? Which country are you talking about?
India.
And they tend to report/flag comments that talk ill of them.
don’t worry man, I won’t flag
Letting the executive play with policy seems like a wild overreach. I wish congress limited those powers.
>Among the highest lottery entrants in FY2026 were Cognizant, Infosys, and Tata, which submitted 100%, 91%, and 95% fewer registrations in FY2027, respectively
Very effective in bringing down abuse. It doesn't comment on the impact of fields where immigrants are needed and they can't afford the $100k
Congress is STILL free to limit those powers. They always have been.
Though mentioned in long lost documents such as the so-called "US Constitution," scholars almost universally agree Congress is a mythical body.
> It doesn't comment on the impact of fields where immigrants are needed
uhhh "needed", what would that look like?
universities, despite being cap-exempt, are not exempted from this fee. This has basically killed academic hiring of foreign academics (i.e. the ability for American universities to brain-drain foreign ones as they historically have).
The US produces almost 2M more college graduates every year than it has jobs for. Those universities can hire US labor or go without. Frankly, many of them can shutter and we’ll still have plenty of higher education capacity, there are already far too many colleges for forward curve of future need.
We have plenty of folks underemployed or unemployed with masters and phd credentials already. How will importing more folks help?
The End Of The Golden Age Of Master’s Degrees - https://www.forbes.com/sites/ryancraig/2025/07/09/the-end-of... | https://archive.today/ybTEs - July 9th, 2025
How many PhDs does world need? Doctoral graduates outnumber academia jobs - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44361130 - June 2025 (68 comments)
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49379006
> A new estimate projects that 442 of the nation’s 1,700 private, nonprofit four-year colleges and universities, with a combined 670,000 students, are at risk of closing or having to merge within the next 10 years.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49378010 (citations)
> A 2024 report by the Burning Glass Institute and Strada Institute for the Future of Work found that, a year after graduation, about half of US college grads were in jobs that “do not require a degree or make meaningful use of college-level skills.”
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49279800 (citations)
Good, that limits the extent of American imperialism.
The US is always the bad guy. If we refuse immigrants, we're nativist/xenophobic. If we accept them we're imperialist.
Such double binds are everywhere when people criticize the US.
That's not what imperialism means!
>It doesn't comment on the impact of fields where immigrants are needed and they can't afford the $100k
Why worry about fields that don't exist?
I agree that a lot needs to change about the H-1B program, but I don't love how much of it has come from executive orders and worse: just offhand statements that drive employers into anxiety and uncertainty. Uncertainty is just the worst thing for the market (and my own salary prospects). The $100,000 fee felt like it was rolled out in jolts. Who was affected? Who was exempt?
At least with laws passed, we see it coming from a long way away. IMO, congress should reduce the powers the executive branch can just wield on this or that, and set the agenda, rather than letting the agenda be set by the president every 4/8 years.
1. "I agree a lot need to change"
2. "we need make sure to take power away from $entity_changing it and give it to $entity_who_has_had_decades_and_fixed_nothing"
3. ???
4. profit
how do you expect change if you keep asking for the entity who has had ample time and fixed nothing to have more power?
You gotta take a civics class. You cant move fast and break things with legislation. The precendent of the executive branch disturbing the balance of power by making laws and policy like this is not worth the benefit of this one issue being expedited. We need to have congress solve this problem because that maintains the balance of power
I think you’re the one who needs a civics course. These are powers vested in the executive since this country’s inception, and this is hardly the first time they have disturbed the “balance of power”, especially when almost every EO this administration has put out has been judicially challenged at every point, whether the challenge had actual legal standing or not.
I agree that congress should speak on this (and codify more strict immigration laws), but EOs are only enforcing the powers within the executive branch, not creating new laws. When they restrict an agency’s abilities or empower them, these are simply internal orders within the executive branch, in large part because no singular law or laws govern agencies and defines their explicit day-to-day. EPA, DEA, and NSA are all examples of executive-led agencies made without explicit law codifying their creation. And, such as with H1B, even when the legislation created it the laws are loose enough to give the executive full legal control without disturbing anything from a civics perspective.
Congress spoke in ‘52 and set the ceiling. Executive speaks today and tells you how that ceiling will be reached, if at all. Judicial speaks tomorrow and ensures that orders from today follow the rules from ‘52, and due to the current laws they do.
Civics class isn’t going to make Congress functional. The evidence is the executive branch can do a lot of what it’s done, and if Congress does nothing, there are no consequences for doing so.
Balance of power only exists if you allow it to, if you have power. If you can’t be or aren’t bound by a counterbalance, there is no balance of power, its honor system.
Congress has had over two decades to fix this. They haven’t. Someone else did.
This is brutal. H-1b employees are legal immigrants.
They should first pass laws to protect them through employment laws.
The employers are the ones who assumed liabilities to start with while hiring.
They can't throw them on the road and make them a burden on the public.
They are, also, not American citizens. The duty of the American government is to ensure the American citizens are not being taken advantage of first and foremost. This does not, and should never extend, to putting non-citizens above citizens.
Wish to gain those same privileges? Then become a citizen, not an eternal immigrant.
[dead]
Reading through the comments it is easy to see that everybody is MAGA when it comes to their own jobs. All of the people harping on ICE actions being bad somehow support kicking out H1-B folks same day when they lose their jobs.
> Reading through the comments it is easy to see that everybody is MAGA when it comes to their own jobs.
So you're saying that they're pitiless jerks when it comes to other people's jobs? "Some of you may lose your jobs, but that's a price I'm willing to pay to save myself some money."
> Reading through the comments it is easy to see that everybody is MAGA when it comes to their own jobs.
Even Indians, after receiving a green card/PR, suddenly want stricter immigration laws.
Pull up the ladder behind you. Tale as old as time.
It would be interesting to see three other data points along side with the timeline of these actions. - The pace of job migration permanently into eastern Europe, India or elsewhere. - The drop in Graduate and PhD enrollment from abroad. - Direction of wage changes of tech workers in the US.
Overall, U.S. campuses saw a 9% decrease in international enrollment this fall compared with last year, according to a survey from the Institute of International Education. And the number of new students entering the United States for the first time fell by 15%. (https://www.cbsnews.com/news/us-universities-fewer-foreign-s...)
NYT analyzed data from 27 of the nation’s top research universities. Between 2024 and 2025, new Ph.D. enrollments declined by about 18 percent in engineering programs and by about 10 percent in science and health disciplines. New enrollments in math and computer science programs also dropped by roughly 10 percent. (Visual: https://static01.nytimes.com/newsgraphics/GM5Fq9Q3ZdykmA/_im...)
Non-pdf alt: https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/IN12747.html
This is the first thing I can genuinely remember in nearly my entire lifetime that a president has done that directly impacts most Americans in a positive, universal, bipartisan way. Too bad Congress ignored, and actively aided and abetted, this abuse for decades. Trump has been horrible in a lot of ways, but even a broken clock is right occasionally and I'll give him credit on this one. And democrats would have cowered and wilted before ever even doing this--they have no backbone to have any sense of national civic duty to protect actual Americans.
I disagree. I’d rather have the Indian immigrants one way or the other. They are incredibly beneficial to the US economy from a founder perspective and in higher education.
Like they were beneficial for their own economy and education?
You’d be surprised how well India is doing, relatively speaking atleast.
People are incredibly hypocritical when it comes to what they perceive to impact their own jobs and your post is a good example of this. Indian Americans are 1% of the population and pay 6% of the taxes and this will disproportionately impact Indians and put them under very harsh conditions even those who've been here for decades waiting for Green Cards but yeah, go Trump.
I, as a full-blooded American, wish to see my country and people prosper. You, as a full-blooded Indian (not “Indian American”, unless you are a dual citizen to India and America) wish to see your people prosper in my country.
I understand, you want what is best for your people, but I and many other Americans want what is best for ours.
The tech outages are definitely not the result of discouraging talents from participating in US workforce. /S
definitely not! There is no company more committed to quality and profit sharing than Microsoft