Jensen has not demonstrated any real remorse or taking steps towards regaining the trust of the Nvidia board. What is fact is that he created a structural single point of failure in the management structure and then behaved in a way that put that structure at high risk, and ultimately caused it to fail. He may be an amazing businessman when it comes to sales and technical vision, but the personal liberties he took and behavior that enabled it does not just go away because he feels sorry.
Edit: if I think about it more, what he probably feels sorry about is the fact that he got caught.
Jensen knew (as with anyone who have dealt with China and Chinese companies) that it is only a matter of time when China will be able to more or less compete with Western companies in the GPU and semicon tech space, including building their own semicon lithography tech (via DUV multi-patterning, nanoimprint lithography (NIL), alternative EUV architectures, etc). And he was aware that this Chinese tech blockade will ultimately be useless in the long-term and was simply trying to maximize his profits while the window was open (before the chinese catch up and buy cheaper locally made chips).
The board has one job - maximizing shareholder value. I am ~100% sure that Jensen is the way to do that, and enforcing morality as per HN user Makeitmakesense is not.
You're making the right observation but drawing the wrong conclusion. The board obviously would not completely dismiss Jensen, the single biggest rainmaker out there today, if all this amounted to was infidelity, and probably not even if he was "just" a victim of a honeypot.
The fact that they are so unequivocally dismissing the possibility of his return, despite the obvious immediate financial risk to themselves, as well as pressure both internal and external to bring him back, ought to be a big indicator that there is, in fact, a lot of there there, vis-a-vis the Chinese smuggling. Possibly even Jensen's active role in it, and possibly concern that it's the thread that will be pulled to unravel the company's whole circular financing scheme.
I think this is simply the issue. There is too much political risk right now with Jensen. By firing him they deflect that political risk away from themselves. It wasn’t Nvidia that made those deals it was Jensen, and now we have fired him, so don’t punish us. He will testify and unless there is new evidence against him, I think he will do okay.
On the other hand, I am not sure Howard Lutnick will survive this.
Putting all of the salaciousness aside, my read on the situation is that Nvidia was selling to Singapore. Officially, they knew nothing about who the GPUs were for. Unofficially, of course they knew, but better not ask a question they didn’t want the answer to. And even if they did know who was using the GPUs. Doesn’t matter because they are following the letter if not the spirit of the law.
At any point, the Trump administration could have closed the loophole. They could have sent a simple letter telling Nvidia to stop and they almost certainly would have.
I think Jensen will make it out okay legally. I think Nvidia might get a slap on the wrist. I think Howard Lutnick gets fired or impeached.
He might get through legally, but this process is fully unlikely to leave his reputation unscathed. Companies will surely do anything to avoid their CEOs being in even closed door testimony.
And just because Milton Friedman said that in the 70s and everyone has repeated it a million times, that doesn’t make the “only maximize shareholder value” thing a truism.
Jensen gave speculators, bears and competitors exactly what they wanted, an Nvidia entangled in scandal that will impact share value even if he stayed. A CEO you have to police and second guess is not ideal for shareholders. Your premise assumes that Jensen will resolve his behaviors 100% and never be a risk again. Thats not how risk management works.
His remorse isn’t relevant. What matters is whether rehiring him would expose the company and board members to additional criminal liability. I guarantee you Nvidia’s lawyers are like “fuck no,” even if Huang prostrated himself in Times Square for all to see.
They can reinstate him but he has to do the job from prison.
My opinion is clear, this guy, and others in the leadership should be in prison.
Its fine to advocate for different export policy, but knowingly and systematically circumventing them is something that should get in prison. And his money should be mostly confiscated too.
Do you have decent quality evidence that nVidia was breaking the law? As the bits and pieces I’ve seen/heard suggest they were following the letter of the law, but that the law maybe wasn’t sufficient - as shown by it now being strengthened? But IANAL and IANAE.
Just based on the patterns of sales after the China ban, seeing a massively increased flow to Singapore and then them stopping to reporting that is more then enough for me to turn the organization upside down and look at their email and so on.
So no I personally don't have quality evidence but I would say if I were a government that actually hands out export bans, the whole 'they just gave it to somebody who re-sold it' excuse wouldn't work for me. And I don't believe that nVidea was so naive to believe that.
Specially when the CEO was literally fucking the CEO of the company that was doing the reselling.
And its not like these are new issues. The same thing happened back in the day with the Soviet Union. And lots of efforts was done to punish people who just gave stuff to middle men.
I don't think the new law changes actually matter. Yes the renting out data-centers to China was not illegal. But there is evidence that lots of it actually did go to China.
Also, many in the US government already were going hard on this, so it was known that something fishy was happening. And they were protected by Trump and his corrupt gang of fascist goons from investigation.
I personally wont believe for 1 second that Jensen was unaware of some sales going to China. Even if they can't find evidence of it. He is not a fucking idiot.
Good. I can't stand this weird time we're in of everyone glorifying the celebrity tech ceos. Ceos should be boring same as our political leaders. Boring is good, I hate that my pension can tank because of individual people.
It's so sad seeing people glorify billionaires that couldn't give a shit about them
Maybe but as they say, their business isn't really in peril. They're not going to lose customers over it. Their product is the top tier resource everyone wants to feed their bid in the AI bubble.
Whoever is at the top job isn't going to stop them from buying. They're in a sellers market if there ever was one.
They might get lobbied into letting him come back but it's not a risk to their business.
Additionally, congress is about to be giving them metaphorical cavity searches for the next several years and they might hurt less if he is gone during that period.
Well that I'm sure of. Besides all these relationships on the side (and probably some that haven't yet been uncovered) he also seems to have been making deals left right and center without any kind of oversight or paperwork which for this level of company really isn't ok. There are things like tendering processes to consider, and insider trading. When you do billion-dollar deals you can't just do things like that.
There's definitely a can of worms that's going to be opened and saying "the guy that did it is already gone" will really help them.
I think we forget how tenacious Satya was during that time convincing the board to reinstate Sam. He openly offered positions to all employees at Microsoft.
It is not in shareholders’ interest for the company to be put at even greater risk of criminal liability. Better to lose some of your money than most or all of it.
To do what? They can't -- and shouldn't -- provide legal cover for potentially criminal activities. Their job is to legislate, not override companies' decisions on who should fill a given role. The American model is that government mostly stays out of private business and its decisions, and I don't think we want to change that.
And why would you want to restore a person to a job who potentially committed criminal acts that, if proved, could harm the company even more than any reduction in stock price that's already been priced in by his departure?
it's very obviously a political hitjob, this information of their relationship has been public knowledge for over a year, yet it becomes a massive scandal... right after the democrats take over the house and senate, when anthropic (a company vehemently opposed to huang's position on open models) is right about to ipo.
It’s not about him having an extramarital relationship. It’s about whether he committed criminal acts that could put the entire company in legal jeopardy.
Jensen has not demonstrated any real remorse or taking steps towards regaining the trust of the Nvidia board. What is fact is that he created a structural single point of failure in the management structure and then behaved in a way that put that structure at high risk, and ultimately caused it to fail. He may be an amazing businessman when it comes to sales and technical vision, but the personal liberties he took and behavior that enabled it does not just go away because he feels sorry.
Edit: if I think about it more, what he probably feels sorry about is the fact that he got caught.
Contrarian view:
Jensen knew (as with anyone who have dealt with China and Chinese companies) that it is only a matter of time when China will be able to more or less compete with Western companies in the GPU and semicon tech space, including building their own semicon lithography tech (via DUV multi-patterning, nanoimprint lithography (NIL), alternative EUV architectures, etc). And he was aware that this Chinese tech blockade will ultimately be useless in the long-term and was simply trying to maximize his profits while the window was open (before the chinese catch up and buy cheaper locally made chips).
Today's news about the new Huawei Ascend 950DT based data center underscores this: https://www.scmp.com/tech/big-tech/article/3374791/chinas-to... .
Ascend 950DT's parity to H200 is about 80%, but I foresee Huawei will move aggressively to close the gap in future models.
It doesn't fucking matter what his opinion on China development is. Just because you are rich and powerful you can't break the law.
What the fuck is this attitude?
What if Musk believes its totally fine give his Raptor engine to China? Should he just be able to do that because its his opinion.
Do laws have meaning?
well he should do that but alas
The board has one job - maximizing shareholder value. I am ~100% sure that Jensen is the way to do that, and enforcing morality as per HN user Makeitmakesense is not.
You're making the right observation but drawing the wrong conclusion. The board obviously would not completely dismiss Jensen, the single biggest rainmaker out there today, if all this amounted to was infidelity, and probably not even if he was "just" a victim of a honeypot.
The fact that they are so unequivocally dismissing the possibility of his return, despite the obvious immediate financial risk to themselves, as well as pressure both internal and external to bring him back, ought to be a big indicator that there is, in fact, a lot of there there, vis-a-vis the Chinese smuggling. Possibly even Jensen's active role in it, and possibly concern that it's the thread that will be pulled to unravel the company's whole circular financing scheme.
>> The fact that they are so unequivocally dismissing the possibility of his return
Not really per other recent reporting https://www.semafor.com/article/11/17/2026/some-nvidia-direc...
Those people are insane. They cannot keep him safe from testimony on the Hill and it is not going to be good for them.
I think this is simply the issue. There is too much political risk right now with Jensen. By firing him they deflect that political risk away from themselves. It wasn’t Nvidia that made those deals it was Jensen, and now we have fired him, so don’t punish us. He will testify and unless there is new evidence against him, I think he will do okay.
On the other hand, I am not sure Howard Lutnick will survive this.
Putting all of the salaciousness aside, my read on the situation is that Nvidia was selling to Singapore. Officially, they knew nothing about who the GPUs were for. Unofficially, of course they knew, but better not ask a question they didn’t want the answer to. And even if they did know who was using the GPUs. Doesn’t matter because they are following the letter if not the spirit of the law.
At any point, the Trump administration could have closed the loophole. They could have sent a simple letter telling Nvidia to stop and they almost certainly would have.
I think Jensen will make it out okay legally. I think Nvidia might get a slap on the wrist. I think Howard Lutnick gets fired or impeached.
> I think Jensen will make it out okay legally.
He might get through legally, but this process is fully unlikely to leave his reputation unscathed. Companies will surely do anything to avoid their CEOs being in even closed door testimony.
And protect the company. Jensen is a risk.
And just because Milton Friedman said that in the 70s and everyone has repeated it a million times, that doesn’t make the “only maximize shareholder value” thing a truism.
I was referring to the United States Supreme Court case where they very clearly explained it actually. Dodge v. Ford Motor Co. from 1919
In 2016 the Supreme Court said there is no requirement for corporations to pursue profit at the expense of everything else. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39643452
You should update your knowledge base. It's currently premised on myths. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1013744
I read it. It says the case was bad. Cool. That is an opinion. The case remains citable and has not been overruled.
You should look up the meaning of "dead letter law". Also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shlensky_v._Wrigley
commenting as a reminder to check back later and see if na is legally beholden to shareholder primacy
There is no such legal requirement. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50540884
Jensen gave speculators, bears and competitors exactly what they wanted, an Nvidia entangled in scandal that will impact share value even if he stayed. A CEO you have to police and second guess is not ideal for shareholders. Your premise assumes that Jensen will resolve his behaviors 100% and never be a risk again. Thats not how risk management works.
> Your premise assumes that Jensen will resolve his behaviors 100% and never be a risk again
Nope, i assume he will keep doing exactly what he was doing, and thus keep raising the stock price.
No the board has another job, following the law and making sure the company has a culture of following the law.
His remorse isn’t relevant. What matters is whether rehiring him would expose the company and board members to additional criminal liability. I guarantee you Nvidia’s lawyers are like “fuck no,” even if Huang prostrated himself in Times Square for all to see.
They can reinstate him but he has to do the job from prison.
My opinion is clear, this guy, and others in the leadership should be in prison.
Its fine to advocate for different export policy, but knowingly and systematically circumventing them is something that should get in prison. And his money should be mostly confiscated too.
Do you have decent quality evidence that nVidia was breaking the law? As the bits and pieces I’ve seen/heard suggest they were following the letter of the law, but that the law maybe wasn’t sufficient - as shown by it now being strengthened? But IANAL and IANAE.
Just based on the patterns of sales after the China ban, seeing a massively increased flow to Singapore and then them stopping to reporting that is more then enough for me to turn the organization upside down and look at their email and so on.
So no I personally don't have quality evidence but I would say if I were a government that actually hands out export bans, the whole 'they just gave it to somebody who re-sold it' excuse wouldn't work for me. And I don't believe that nVidea was so naive to believe that.
Specially when the CEO was literally fucking the CEO of the company that was doing the reselling.
And its not like these are new issues. The same thing happened back in the day with the Soviet Union. And lots of efforts was done to punish people who just gave stuff to middle men.
I don't think the new law changes actually matter. Yes the renting out data-centers to China was not illegal. But there is evidence that lots of it actually did go to China.
Also, many in the US government already were going hard on this, so it was known that something fishy was happening. And they were protected by Trump and his corrupt gang of fascist goons from investigation.
I personally wont believe for 1 second that Jensen was unaware of some sales going to China. Even if they can't find evidence of it. He is not a fucking idiot.
Good. I can't stand this weird time we're in of everyone glorifying the celebrity tech ceos. Ceos should be boring same as our political leaders. Boring is good, I hate that my pension can tank because of individual people. It's so sad seeing people glorify billionaires that couldn't give a shit about them
But they’ll change their minds later.
Maybe but as they say, their business isn't really in peril. They're not going to lose customers over it. Their product is the top tier resource everyone wants to feed their bid in the AI bubble.
Whoever is at the top job isn't going to stop them from buying. They're in a sellers market if there ever was one.
They might get lobbied into letting him come back but it's not a risk to their business.
Additionally, congress is about to be giving them metaphorical cavity searches for the next several years and they might hurt less if he is gone during that period.
Well that I'm sure of. Besides all these relationships on the side (and probably some that haven't yet been uncovered) he also seems to have been making deals left right and center without any kind of oversight or paperwork which for this level of company really isn't ok. There are things like tendering processes to consider, and insider trading. When you do billion-dollar deals you can't just do things like that.
There's definitely a can of worms that's going to be opened and saying "the guy that did it is already gone" will really help them.
Shame that the Open AI board didn't have the same guts as the nvidia board does
I think we forget how tenacious Satya was during that time convincing the board to reinstate Sam. He openly offered positions to all employees at Microsoft.
- Jensen is still under internal company investigation.
- He is set to testify in front of Congress on national security breaches and chip sales to China.
- DOJ and the Commerce Department have separate investigations into Megaspeed and Alice Huang over export control violations.
- There is a new SEC probe into Nvidia and Jensen about misleading shareholders.
Did people expect the board would just go "yeah nothing is wrong, Jensen is back!!"
Acting against shareholders interest
It is not in shareholders’ interest for the company to be put at even greater risk of criminal liability. Better to lose some of your money than most or all of it.
I am a shareholder and I am not interested in Nvidia getting busted for criminal activity. I suspect there is a balance to be found here.
is there a publicly available petition i and other shareholders can sign to reinstate him? or anything else we can do to help bring him back?
There’s nothing you can do, even if you are a shareholder. It’s simply not going to happen. There’s too much legal exposure.
i'm sure with enough people there is something we can do to move the needle. i mailed my senator and representatives.
To do what? They can't -- and shouldn't -- provide legal cover for potentially criminal activities. Their job is to legislate, not override companies' decisions on who should fill a given role. The American model is that government mostly stays out of private business and its decisions, and I don't think we want to change that.
And why would you want to restore a person to a job who potentially committed criminal acts that, if proved, could harm the company even more than any reduction in stock price that's already been priced in by his departure?
it's very obviously a political hitjob, this information of their relationship has been public knowledge for over a year, yet it becomes a massive scandal... right after the democrats take over the house and senate, when anthropic (a company vehemently opposed to huang's position on open models) is right about to ipo.
It’s not about him having an extramarital relationship. It’s about whether he committed criminal acts that could put the entire company in legal jeopardy.
Are you a Republican?
I’m sure the answer will be “independent” or “libertarian” but of course these people only vote GOP.