42 comments

  • Goodliff a day ago

    This is a good thing.

    And I hope California is even stricter for self-driving semis.

    Once autonomy Level 3 and especially Level 4 vehicles are robust and better than human-driven vehicles (which, honestly, shouldn't be that hard...) our roads will get progressively safer.

    AEB (automatic emergency braking) in newer vehicles is already helping to reduce front-to-rear crashes by 49% to 50% compared to unequipped vehicles, according to the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety.

    Next: investigate the Tesla accidents and deaths...

    • dmitrygr 20 hours ago

      > AEB (automatic emergency braking) in newer vehicles is already helping to reduce front-to-rear crashes

      Have you driven a car with modern AEB? It is insanely bad on both Tesla and GM vehicles, falsely triggering more than once daily. Someone should seriously considering starting a business making AEB disable dongles for people who are tired of being jerked to a hard stop in the middle of an empty road for no reason.

      • redwall_hp 19 hours ago

        Sounds like a problem with those companies. I've had a few AEB equipped Hondas dating back to 2017 model year, including a 2026, and they never have erroneous braking.

        My Civic will flash the "[BRAKE]" warning sometimes if someone is slower than anticipated turning off the road, or if I'm a little late on starting to brake, but it takes a lot to proceed to the beeping stage, and I've never had it apply the brakes. You have to be facing an imminent collision before that happens. And that's after adjusting it to the more sensitive option in the settings.

        • dmitrygr 19 hours ago

          > You have to be facing an imminent collision before that happens.

          Yes i understand the theory of AEB. It is the practice that does not match it that bugs me

      • thebruce87m 13 hours ago

        I have never had that happen on a 23 Model Y in autopilot or manual driving in 30k miles driven.

        I’ve had it alert on parked vehicles that I am driving towards and intend to drive around - it highlights them in red and there is an audio alert - but never apply brakes.

        • persolb 11 hours ago

          It was an issue before covid; I had it happen twice. Have never had it happen since. Sitting at over 100k miles; 96% FSD (since that metric has been available).

      • rationalist 16 hours ago

        I have a RAM 1500. Even on the lowest setting, the AEB is terrible. It usually only activates when the vehicle in front of me is turning onto a side street and they will clear the shared lane well before I reach them. Even if they magically lost all momentum and came to a dead stop, I still have enough time and space to manually brake. Sometime I need to get around to unplugging the sensors in the bumper.

      • m463 17 hours ago

        Tesla - hw4+v14 software is pretty good.

        surprisingly hw1 with ap1 was pretty good too.

        that said, i say that for false braking, but never really tested actual emergencies.

      • therealpygon 9 hours ago

        Are you sure that doesn’t say more about your driving than the cars emergency system?

      • chung8123 20 hours ago

        I have not had an issue with my parents toyota. Is it braking early or just randomly?

        • dmitrygr 19 hours ago

          Sometimes hundreds of yards from a car i am already slowing down to not hit, sometimes while on cruise control on a wide open highway. both tesla and GM

      • SJetKaran 10 hours ago

        My Hyundai had no such issues.

  • asdff 21 hours ago

    The way they handle merging is honestly a little scary sometimes, like coming to a complete stop for lack of taking initiative when it ought to.

    • akamaka 18 hours ago

      I think that it will be eventually proven that merging is inherently unsafe. It works for humans because we work up the courage and just go for it, having some faith in the other drivers to let us in. But a self-driving car is only considering the physics which indicate an imminent accident.

      There will eventually be a dilemma where we have to choose between turning down the safety thresholds of self-driving cars, taking away decisions from human drivers, or physically redesigning the more challening highway ramps.

      • asdff 6 hours ago

        You said it yourself, its unsafe because the self driving cars lack any subconcious communication layer like the human driver, who will get that same visual input but either speed up to get out of the way or slow down to let the car in. The merging human also knows they cannot just come to a complete stop and wait in an active roadway for a gap, and that they have the power to force a gap.

        The rigid rule following of self driving cars has lead to them do something either stupid or dangerous all the times I’ve tried out waymo. Human rideshare yeah you gotta talk to the guy but they actually can drive and aren’t going to route me through a parking lot and double my trip eta.

  • solyin a day ago

    For how long, because of why, what fixes do they need to see before allowing them to do that again?

    • wilbo 21 hours ago

      It's in the linked article and all seems like a ban is reasonable.

      It's until Waymo can demonstrate they've corrected the bad behaviors, specifically driving into an active construction site and trying to bypass law enforcement vehicles performing a traffic break.

      Seems very reasonable.

      • lokar 7 hours ago

        I hope they release more detail.

        Did the car “see” the flashing lights and understand they were police vehicles? Why did it decide to pass?

    • a day ago
      [deleted]
    • a day ago
      [deleted]
    • a day ago
      [deleted]
  • akurilin a day ago

    The comments on that article are something else. Polar opposite of my experience as an occasional Waymo customer.

    • Goodliff a day ago

      Yeah, I used to write tech reports about AVs (autonomous vehicles) and driver assistance technologies, and most people have an outsized fear of them

      They probably haven't driven in LA, or NYC, or other places where the human drivers are a menace.

      I agree that the AVs are not quite ready. But they are getting there. And we'll be much safer when there are more cars on the road with driver assistance safety features and Level 4 AV that are truly robust and can handle edge cases well.

      Multimodal LLMs are helping fill in the gaps between mere perception and actual understanding of a situation and the environment surrounding the vehicle.

  • christianqchung a day ago

    This seems like a fairly troubling development for Waymo. There are already more Cybercabs than Waymos in Texas now, and I can't find any high profile Cybercab incidents yet despite the lack of LiDAR.

    • ctoa a day ago

      There are not more Cybercabs than Waymos in Texas. Very recently, the fleet sizes for the Tesla Robotaxi increased (up from barely existing). On registrations, there are now about the same number of vehicles registered for Tesla and Waymo. Briefly Tesla was ahead, but Waymo has also expanded. Only half of the Tesla cars are Cybercabs. Tesla does no highway Robotaxi operations in Texas.

      It took quite a while for these complaints to occur for Waymo, specific to highway driving edge cases. I don't think there's any reason to think that Tesla is especially free of problems that will get seen at scale given how limited their operations have been until very recently.

    • toomuchtodo a day ago
      • christianqchung 21 hours ago

        > Four happened in driverless “Robotaxi” service, and none topped 5 mph. The other four happened with a test driver on board and Tesla’s driver-assist engaged, including one where a Cybercab hit a car at 53 mph on a highway in Philadelphia.

        Fair enough, although the 4 driverless cases were really slow apparently, and the rest were apparently test drivers (which is still not good, but not as bad as a paying customer).

        • toomuchtodo 21 hours ago

          > Those numbers say more about where Tesla lets the system drive than about the software itself. As we reported last month, Robotaxi sticks to low-speed routes inside small geofenced zones and largely stays off highways.

    • TealMyEal a day ago

      https://electrek.co/2026/11/16/tesla-autopilot-fsd-overturne...

      not a cybercab but not an ideal look for FSD

  • jacobgold 20 hours ago

    I hope they unban it soon. I love taking Waymo on the freeway.

  • bko a day ago

    Call my cynical but I feel like there's a bigger story behind this ban. Something like a rift with lobbyists or something.

    My favorite California story is how there was an exemption to the minimum wage that applies to only Panera Bread. I love the creative phrasing.

    > (2) “Fast food restaurant” shall not include an establishment that on September 15, 2023, operates a bakery that produces for sale on the establishment’s premises bread, as defined under Part 136 of Subchapter B of Chapter I of Title 21 of the Code of Federal Regulations, so long as it continues to operate such a bakery. This exemption applies only where the establishment produces for sale bread as a stand-alone menu item, and does not apply if the bread is available for sale solely as part of another menu item.

    Being a lawyer must be mostly boring but every once in a while you get to create a clause like this and it makes it all worth it.

    https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml...

    • BatchJob 19 hours ago

      Maybe the construction workers that could have been killed when 3 different waymos drove through a marked construction site, or the CHP officers that could have been killed if a swerving Waymo that was trying to pass them while holding traffic for a caltrans installation "lobbied them".

      • anon7000 15 hours ago

        Color me completely unimpressed by stories of Waymos making rare dangerous mistakes. Human drivers make very common, very dangerous mistakes every day. I’d bet good money there are more drivers in SF scrolling on their phones while driving than there are Waymos. At least the Waymo is observing the road in the first place.

        Anyways, Waymo should of course fix those issues, but once done, Waymo will be less likely to make the same kind of mistake again. Give a human a ticket for a DUI and they’re likely to turn around and get another DUI the same day. (True story)

        • autoexec 12 hours ago

          > At least the Waymo is observing the road in the first place.

          If it were it wouldn't be plowing into construction sites.

          > Anyways, Waymo should of course fix those issues, but once done, Waymo will be less likely to make the same kind of mistake again.

          That doesn't seem to be the case either. At least not for buses https://autos.yahoo.com/safety-and-recalls/articles/waymo-ta... or puddles https://www.techtimes.com/articles/317003/20260522/waymo-hal...

        • lokar 7 hours ago

          Watch the CHP video. It is aggressively trying to pass two CHP cars running a break for caltrans.

          If any of us did that we would end up in cuffs laying on the pavement. It’s not an honest or normal error a human would ever make.

          https://youtu.be/22m2NTT2nos

        • BatchJob 8 hours ago

          The people who insist on comparing human mistakes with the automation of death in the form of incapable software are doing the biggest disservice of anyone to the future of automated driving if it has a future at all.

          The state is to blame for allowing these things on the road. The companies are to blame for lying about the readiness of their software...continuously. And the fact that they continue to lie should cause them to be banned permanently.

  • ChrisArchitect 19 hours ago
  • a day ago
    [deleted]
  • jocelyner 20 hours ago

    [dead]

  • thundercleeze a day ago

    “The Department determined that Waymo’s driverless freeway operations pose an imminent hazard to public safety due to recurring incursions by its vehicles into active construction zones where construction workers, vehicles and equipment are present,” Groveman said.

    So when will they ban humans from driving on freeways?

    • lokar 7 hours ago

      They do ban humans that do this stuff. Try passing a CHP car with lights on and see what happens.

      Waymo is effectively one driver. Make an egregious error like this and all the cars get banned until it’s fixed.