20 comments

  • MiroslavPokorny 21 hours ago

    The real problem is not planned obsolescense but abandoned security updates.

    Any always online system today needs continued updates. By not providing security updates when new bad stuff appears, renders the device unhealthy to use.

  • syradar 17 hours ago

    I would rather have my phone only repairable by Apple than the hellscape of getting my phone stolen for parts.

  • mikestew a day ago

    Apple is accused of configuring its software to "make it impossible to repair or refurbish" the phones outside its authorised network, the source added.

    I don’t think “planned obsolescence” means what the French courts think it means. Take it to the Apple Store, they fix it, phone works again. The fact that you might have to take it to Apple might be something, but it ain’t what the title suggests.

    • Grombobulous 18 hours ago

      The article explains this: various repairs aren’t possible outside of Apple’s direct service because of software restrictions on replacement parts.

      Combine that with the fact that Apple stops repairing older models with their service centers and, there ya go, planned obsolescence.

    • throwawayffffas a day ago

      My desktop from 2017 is humming along as a file server. I am running a 2019 server next to it. My phone from 2021 is running a bit slow but generally fine.

      All my apple devices became literally e-waste 4 to 5 years after purchase.

      • NoPicklez 19 hours ago

        You can't compare your desktop to your mobile phone as we all know those are different.

        I've had my iPhone 12 since 2020 and its working just fine, apart from standard battery degradation.

      • digikazi a day ago

        [dead]

      • mikestew a day ago

        Anecdotes are fun: 2012 MBP is still in use, 2019 iMac is serving garage/print server duty, and my 2021 phone (iPhone 13 mini) runs just fine as a daily driver.

        Anecdotes aside, your comment still doesn't make the case for "planned obsolescence". You're just saying you don't keep your Apple stuff, without saying why.

        • throwawayffffas a day ago

          Because the OS updates always stop. What OS are you running in your 2012 MBP and 2019 iMac?

          • kstrauser a day ago

            And so what if it does? I know companies using 2014 Mac Minis in production, with several-year-old OSes, not Internet-facing, cheerfully chugging away and making money for their owners.

            Toyota hasn't updated the infotainment system in our minivan since the day we bought it, but the van runs perfectly. Updates are always nice, when they actually fix things, but the lack of them doesn't mean a thing isn't usable.

            • boznz 3 hours ago

              >Toyota hasn't updated the infotainment system in our minivan since the day we bought it, but the van runs perfectly.

              The tape system in my truck is still working perfectly too. No idea what the fuss is.

          • mikestew a day ago

            [dead]

          • desolate_muffin a day ago

            As opposed to Windows and Android where updates also always stop? Are you trying to say everything should be Linux? As far as I can tell, Apple has a better track record for long-term support than both Microsoft and Google.

      • jen20 19 hours ago

        Curious. My Apple laptops from 2012, 2015 and 2016 are all running fine in daily productive use. My iPhone from 2021 is in secondary use as a children’s media device, but fine.

        What are you doing to mistreat products such that they become e-waste?

    • gib444 15 hours ago

      You missed out the $300-600 fee because they just want you to buy a new phone

  • nozzlegear 18 hours ago

    Gotta pay for those pensions somehow.

    /s

  • mmmlinux a day ago

    Apple should just let European models use aftermarket and used parts. When the incidents of pick pocketing skyrocket even higher than they already are, maybe they'll change their minds.

    • Grombobulous 17 hours ago

      A really simple middle ground could be found here: if you’re a company and you stop providing repair services for your products, you have to disable software restrictions on repair parts for that device.

      In other words my proposal is that the brand new iPhone can have those restrictions, but as soon as Apple stops being willing to repair it themselves, they have to disable software restrictions in part swaps.

    • Dylan16807 a day ago

      They obstruct repairs in a lot more ways than blocking used parts.

      And, you know, there could be an official process to decommission a non-stolen phone into usable spare parts.

    • hurfdurf 13 hours ago

        When the incidents of pick pocketing skyrocket even higher than they already are,
      
      So after a decade or more these restrictions don't deter thefts (not "reuse) at all, obviously? If the criminals cannot "recycle" the phone, they just toss it, but you're out of your device either way.

      In a way that crossbody strap case is a better theft deterrent than serialization of parts and iCloud restrictions ever were.