Very much agree with you that there is a pattern emerging. I think I agree with your conclusion as well.
There are a couple of things to keep in mind with nsanet though:
- It can handle anywhere between confidential to TS//SCI information
- It is largely (completely?) an off-infra network, meaning that it doesn't run over the same infrastructure that the open internet uses. It uses an entirely(?) discrete backbone. SIPRNET uses similar architecture.
- You cannot easily cross pollinate data from unclassified networks to nsanet. Everything from removable media to EMSEC is considered prohibited without proper channels being informed and paperwork being performed.
- Lastly, we're unaware of the timing of this supposed source. This could have been over the last week or a month ago or <n>. Scant detail is given, so I'm unwilling to believe "lolz nsa pwnd" just yet.
It occurs to me that even if the recent outages are mostly just growing pains from rapid/careless AI adoption, a sufficiently advanced AI cyberattack would be designed to be indistinguishable from normal outages.
They are so far, but I would expect the same kind of public do-not-fear response if this was a coordinated cyber attack and the US is at war with an adversary that has experienced the power and consequence of targeted cyber capabilities. If they didn't pursue their own program in earnest after StuxNet I would be shocked.
We collectively are very much in arm-chair speculation at this point. If this is a coordinated cyber attack the US government right now wouldn't want to demonstrate weakness or fault. Iran would be the obvious culprit... but going full arm-chair on speculation... There was a major and disappointing result in our elections to the current powers that be...
If this was a staged set of attacks carefully done to minimize casualties... I bet it would be enough to declare a state of emergency and get additional executive powers "legitimately". If that was the case I would expect more propaganda and less bury it under the rug if that was going on.
Be careful out there the world is scary. Don't take any of this as fact, this is all personal speculation based on my own observations. Let me stand-up from my armchair and go for a walk...
They could just be asking AI to attack different things and find weaknesses as an attack everything goes down things go down 1 by 1 its more like testing. Or more cynical read it could be the plan to hose the american people for all the AI investment scare them into investing in and allowing ai data centers
We're in an interesting time when Hanlon's razor seems to be being tested. "Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity".
AI-accelerated attacks, I think most of the cybersecurity ones are attributable to that exploiting previous incompetences. But the flight grounding and microsoft outages? Looks more like direct incompetence to me
Either way I think the takeaway is that we've been slacking for a long time and now we have something that doesn't need man-hours, caffeine, and obsessive human focus to take advantage of that fact. At least for those of us who have been in the field for a while there's lots of work cleaning up these messes for the foreseeable future but I been on calls with peers of mine in infosec who have definitely been losing valuable sleep and health over it
Hanlon's razor reads more to me like a malicious thought terminating cliche than an actual law via averages that still requires testing. Anyone operating with Hanlon's razor can have their perception of anything easily hacked by simply pretending to be stupid, thus converting an act of malicious intent presumably brought about through some motive into an opaque act that requires no further scrutiny.
Although I don't know the answer, and have not done the work to analyze this situation properly, in cases like this I find it helpful to try to focus primarily on the overall epistemological framework rather than only the matter at hand (since it is easy to get lost in all the uncertainty, lack of knowledge, and presence of disinformation); an especially useful and simple tool here is Bayesian inference.
For instance, I have heard that Iranians have developed rather sophisticated cyber-warfare capabilities. I don't know if that is true, and if true, I don't know how likely it would be that they would have reached capabilities to cause the observed outages. But even if you assume that the probability (or rather degree of belief) is quite small but still realistic, say between 0.1 and 10 percents, than considering the current situation it might be absolutely rational to see it likely that they are behind these outages. The full analysis requires estimation of the probability that this is all just a coincidence, and of other major "non-coincidental" branches. But one can do this at various levels of precision and explicitly observe how the output depends on the priors and the estimated probabilities (and therefore, on the assumptions).
The size and scale of something like SIPR, JWICS mean they're interacted with by tens of thousands of people at facilities worldwide on a daily basis as part of their regular relatively mundane work. It would be hard not to notice.
I am just surprised this is not happening all the time, after piling on layers upon layers of software and merely looking for a checkbox to check and someone else to blame (and pay).
Even the vertically integrated tech companies that used to be in control of the whole stack are having their Outlook moments now, everyone else is worse off.
Not to defend the cut or weigh into politics, but how much of 18F was specifically security related? Because that's what's required here, rather than tech generalists.
I cannot comment on the specifics, they change with time. I had few interaction with technologists in one of the federal government body almost a decade ago. Those people were thoughtful, expert with first primitives and open to what you are doing as long as the intent is met.
Compare to that, most people in industry at this point are either business disguised as technologist or in some cases experts in one vertical.
In government security is political. And what we had with 18F was the beginning of a government office that was both tech savvy and politically savvy.
Who decides when a DDOS of Trumpcare.gov that is traced back to Akamai servers was an attempt to extort government contracts or “those pesky Chinese state actors”?
Lots of strong opinions on 18F's closure. Here is the GSA Inspector General's October 2024 assessment, done during Biden, and prior to Trump/DOGE actions.
Well, when you put it that way, it’s amazing how much just a drop in the bucket is able to accomplish. We should fill all of our buckets with at least a drop.
Yeah, the assumption that 18F would have prevented this is ... absurd. The problems we're facing are ai related, and external entities are more capabile, nimble, and motivated than our beloved government (right now anyway).
I hope the DOGE investigations result in so much prison time and laws being changed specifically to codify what can’t happen.
The whole conservative thesis of the “imperial president” is an embarrassment to non-servile Americans. Glad we showed them the door in the last election (in a generational ass beating). Fingers crossed everyone involved ends up in prison forever.
I believe that even less than I believe the pardons won't be issued. The world has expected a lot of things from the US, only to see the exact opposite happen in last years.
I wouldn't be surprised if Trump pardoned his corrupt friends, as many US presidents have done before. But I also wouldn't be surprised if he went a step further and issued preemptive pardons to all his loyal servants who so cheerfully supported him throughout his circus show.
That would mean nobody would face any personal responsibility for the damage they've caused. The main reason this hasn't been done on such a massive scale before is the political backlash. And Trump simply doesn't give a damn about that.
We need a court finding that says preemptive pardons are not what the Constitution allows. It makes no sense for even the President to offer a get-out-of-jail card with no expiration date.
Guess who screams I’m competent the loudest? The incompetent workers.
On a serious note, I see it as a paradox. Competency is built through struggles, and the non-competent do not want someone that seemed lesser at some point to outrank them, be the go to person.
What I haven't seen mentioned is whether it's possible that these are a rogue or state-controlled AI cyber-attack and it's just doing a really good job at covering its tracks?
Or it's too humiliating, or too close to national defense secrets, to publicly admit what it is. Imagine if it's some sort of "Die Hard 3" -style threat made by Putin: "Don't attack my refineries or I'll shut down your industries — here's a shut down of your NSA for proof."
Give it a minute. Bespoke networks fall down all the time. We are probably only hearing about this because of the coincidence of the other recent network failures. It is a self-fulfilling prophecy. As we become more sensitive to outages, every normal everyday outage becomes part of the global pattern.
If the network was one of those no-fail important ones (think NORAD stuff) then nobody would be talking about it as doing so would be treasonous. So, at most, this is a less-important internal network. It will probably be back up by end of business.
There's even a name for this fallacy: it's called the frequency illusion [0]
> The frequency illusion, also known as the Baader–Meinhof phenomenon, is a cognitive bias in which a person notices a specific concept, word, or product more frequently after recently becoming aware of it.
Also drone/UFO "Flaps". If ATC tells pilots that a drone has been seen near an airport, every scrap of paper, every possible light in the sky becomes a quadcopter. Flaps have actually shut down major airports, even though nothing is ever photographed let alone found.
>> Flap, originally a military term to describe a "period of panic or chaos", is used by ufologists to describe surges of sightings in one geographical area. Longer surges spanning multiple countries may be called waves. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UFO_flap
What happens is that the media catches whiff of a new fear, and goes to work harvesting it for every last ad-view. Each story amps up the fear too, so it becomes a flywheel of money.
Anything the catches the public's collective conscious, the media is there to stoke it into piles of ad dollars.
Any journalist worth their pay is paying close attention to what is getting traction on social media.
It's extremely profitable to write stories telling social media pitchfork mobs how correct they are. Influencers have been catching onto this game in the last decade too, and went from "here is what is actually going on" contrarians to "here is what is actually going on" agenda towing. It just pays so much more, and people trust you more (because people naturally trust those who tell them they are right).
> Give it a minute. Bespoke networks fall down all the time.
Including NSA Net? How often does it fall down?
> We are probably only hearing about this because of the coincidence of the other recent network failures
This seems to be an explanation for why the press is covering it - this time. Which also hints that NSA Net failures happen with some kind of regularity and that that news orgs had been getting wind of it.
I suspect that the opposite is true. That it's rare to unheard of for NSA Net to fail like this and rare for a news org to get wind of something so deeply protected.
I feel like this is attention bias. A government built messaging service used by one agency for a subset of their data isn't going to have 3 nines in the first place.
Why not, that seems like a pretty well understood scope and scale. GitHub going down because it has 400 interdependent systems and a billion new users is more understandable.
Where can you even find information about how it's secured? Also, are they monitoring for security or for everyday bugs? Is this high-assurance software running on high-assurance systems?
I'll probably get downvoted for this but I feel like CNN stopped being a serious source of journalism a long time ago (along with Fox and most of the networks). A real story is the exception, so it's hard for me to take most of these things seriously.
Have you considered endorsing a better source instead of just disparaging the rest and leaving us to guess how we're supposed to achieve enlightenment? "Trust no one" is not a winning strategy.
funny I sat there for a minute thinking to myself.. I should provide a better source. I came up blank. Sorry. I could probably go on and on about independent journalism, but it's probably healthier to just turn it all off and go outside.
We just had a full ground stop of all flights, and a major banking outage yesterday, following a major microsoft outage. I am starting to have doubts about them not being related.
Conspiracy theories are flying, but don't you think that enough people are involved in maintaining these systems that if it was, for example, an attack by a foreign country, it would have leaked from one of the tens of thousands of people involved?
Also consider that the media absolutely loves to run any story it can find about a network going down right now because it causes fear, and fear gets clicks. Now think about how many major networks have a problem in a given week. You just never hear about them until now.
Besides recency bias, another problem with this specific outage story or really anything to do with current national security/defense matters is that by definition only uninformed opinions are widely available. "Those who know don't talk, those who talk don't know" – excluding one-in-a-generation whistleblowers like Snowden, and even those are necessarily limited to one-time snapshots because once they disclose they are shut out and (presumably?) methods, technologies, and operations change afterward.
> don't you think that [...] it would have leaked from one of the tens of thousands of people involved?
No I don't. Why would you risk your career and potentially your freedom to leak a report about enemy action, in which doing so could potentially harm your country too?
So we are to believe that 6 people leaked the fact that the classified NSA network is down, but also no one is willing to leak evidence of widespread cyber attacks?
The 6 people that “leaked” the outage are likely executive leaders in the organization and also being very careful to not release information that would actually pose a threat to national security. It’s pretty common in DC, see David Pozen’s article The Leaky Leviathan[0]. These people are sometimes prosecuted (see Gen. James Cartwright) but it’s rare because it’s both tacitly understood as necessary to allow for coordination with the rest of the government and american society, and they take effort to color within the lines.
>Also consider that the media absolutely loves to run any story it can find about a network going down right now
It's exactly like the media reporting every aviation notice after an airplane crash. Leading people to speculate "why is everything broken right now!" even though it's the normal course of business, they're only just noticing it now because they're being told to notice it.
I doubt this is the case, but since we're talking about conspiracy theories: this looks more like things breaking by accident as things are shimmed for control by a third party and less like a focused attack.
I’ve heard people suggest this is growing pains for the Genesis Mission coming online (we’re hitting the one year mark, and they may be a little cavalier trying to meet their timeline).
No, it’s across the government and headed by the department of energy. The nominal goal is to achieve advances in scientific research, but it gets there by connecting all of the disparate networks across agencies (and creates a “superintelligence”)
Knowledge of the existence of the network isn't the same as knowledge of what traffic flows across it.
Just like good crypto must survive robust cryptanalysis, good network security needs to be robust even when adversaries know the network exists (and perhaps even where in physical space key nodes are located).
That being said: the network being down isn't something that immediately makes me worried in the near term. "Turn it off" is a better first response than "observe if anything seems weird" for communications channels that prioritize secrecy over availability.
All bits of classified information have to have justification to be classified. Typically unless its a critical classified network (think operational/urgent military comms) then the status of the network is usually not classified. Its only classified if a good argument can be made that the status is a national security risk. Usually its preferred to have as little as possible classified as its a great hindrance to fixing or getting things done because of all the overhead of security, meetings and paperwork involved.
This country continues day after day to get exactly what we voted for. Incompetant old men who would rather play golf and point fingers than take any form of decisive leadership and fix things.
(I'm not saying the dems would do better, i'm saying we all need to stop voting for old men in primaries because they are more "electable")
There is a fine line between attributing this to mass conspiracy and cyber attack (which no one wants to believe) and attributing this to random bugs popping everywhere. Too many people are eager to cross this line. While others are trying to stay behind it.
The truth lies somewhere in the middle. My theory: someone figured out how to bring down each network. And is progressively breaking each system to help developers fix their security holes. Given enough breaks, we will figure out their modus operandi. And then figure out who they are.
Or something even more conspiratorial: us govt is halting each system to install back doors.
Well, Nasdaq is down 2%. "On the news", and on every single other piece of news that's out there. Tracing it to any one piece of news is usually pure guesswork.
It was. They've been on a streak of journalistic malpractice recently - including an egregious example a few years ago where they slandered and doxxed a minor.
For me, 2 is coincidence, 3 is a pattern. Now we are at 4:
1. All flights grounded
2. Microsoft outage
3. Optimizely malware
4. Classified NSA network down
I don't know what, but something is clearly happening.
Very much agree with you that there is a pattern emerging. I think I agree with your conclusion as well.
There are a couple of things to keep in mind with nsanet though:
- It can handle anywhere between confidential to TS//SCI information
- It is largely (completely?) an off-infra network, meaning that it doesn't run over the same infrastructure that the open internet uses. It uses an entirely(?) discrete backbone. SIPRNET uses similar architecture.
- You cannot easily cross pollinate data from unclassified networks to nsanet. Everything from removable media to EMSEC is considered prohibited without proper channels being informed and paperwork being performed.
- Lastly, we're unaware of the timing of this supposed source. This could have been over the last week or a month ago or <n>. Scant detail is given, so I'm unwilling to believe "lolz nsa pwnd" just yet.
I used to routinely watch people pull thumb drives out of SIPRNET machines and put them into NIPRNET machines and vice-versa.
I would not be surprised if something similar was involved here. It worked with stuxnet, too.
SIPRnet and the other confidential networks are transporting data on regular Internet but use encryption. It’s like a VPN.
Do you have an estimate of NSA uptime over the last 10 years?
It occurs to me that even if the recent outages are mostly just growing pains from rapid/careless AI adoption, a sufficiently advanced AI cyberattack would be designed to be indistinguishable from normal outages.
> ...a sufficiently advanced AI cyberattack would be designed to be indistinguishable from normal outages.
Aren't these being treated as "normal" outages by the media and powers that be?
They are so far, but I would expect the same kind of public do-not-fear response if this was a coordinated cyber attack and the US is at war with an adversary that has experienced the power and consequence of targeted cyber capabilities. If they didn't pursue their own program in earnest after StuxNet I would be shocked.
We collectively are very much in arm-chair speculation at this point. If this is a coordinated cyber attack the US government right now wouldn't want to demonstrate weakness or fault. Iran would be the obvious culprit... but going full arm-chair on speculation... There was a major and disappointing result in our elections to the current powers that be...
If this was a staged set of attacks carefully done to minimize casualties... I bet it would be enough to declare a state of emergency and get additional executive powers "legitimately". If that was the case I would expect more propaganda and less bury it under the rug if that was going on.
Be careful out there the world is scary. Don't take any of this as fact, this is all personal speculation based on my own observations. Let me stand-up from my armchair and go for a walk...
Iatrogenic outages would happen at similar times with overlap, versus convenient-for-narrative day-to-day outages.
Wasn't there a bank outage too? OpenAi must be cooking. The new model is so strong it will mass destruct your ass!
US Banks down, United grounded a second time.
Chase had an issue. Other banks' only problem was that they couldn't work with Chase, which makes up a large % of external accounts.
According to what?
banks: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/banks-online-service-outages-jp...
united: https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/united-airlines-system-...
Story about United fixing issue: https://ground.news/article/united-airlines-says-it-resolved...
All over the news yesterday.
They could just be asking AI to attack different things and find weaknesses as an attack everything goes down things go down 1 by 1 its more like testing. Or more cynical read it could be the plan to hose the american people for all the AI investment scare them into investing in and allowing ai data centers
We're in an interesting time when Hanlon's razor seems to be being tested. "Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity".
AI-accelerated attacks, I think most of the cybersecurity ones are attributable to that exploiting previous incompetences. But the flight grounding and microsoft outages? Looks more like direct incompetence to me
Either way I think the takeaway is that we've been slacking for a long time and now we have something that doesn't need man-hours, caffeine, and obsessive human focus to take advantage of that fact. At least for those of us who have been in the field for a while there's lots of work cleaning up these messes for the foreseeable future but I been on calls with peers of mine in infosec who have definitely been losing valuable sleep and health over it
Hanlon's razor reads more to me like a malicious thought terminating cliche than an actual law via averages that still requires testing. Anyone operating with Hanlon's razor can have their perception of anything easily hacked by simply pretending to be stupid, thus converting an act of malicious intent presumably brought about through some motive into an opaque act that requires no further scrutiny.
Hanlon's razor is a useful tool for your personal human relationships, but it is a bad tool for geopolitics.
Interesting perspective. Do you have any better proposals?
At the very least you should take "cui bono" into account, weighted by frequency.
What do you mean by "better proposals"?
Of what?
It seems we're in a 2-for-1 situation nowadays: "Hanlon's Cut-Throat"?
Although I don't know the answer, and have not done the work to analyze this situation properly, in cases like this I find it helpful to try to focus primarily on the overall epistemological framework rather than only the matter at hand (since it is easy to get lost in all the uncertainty, lack of knowledge, and presence of disinformation); an especially useful and simple tool here is Bayesian inference.
For instance, I have heard that Iranians have developed rather sophisticated cyber-warfare capabilities. I don't know if that is true, and if true, I don't know how likely it would be that they would have reached capabilities to cause the observed outages. But even if you assume that the probability (or rather degree of belief) is quite small but still realistic, say between 0.1 and 10 percents, than considering the current situation it might be absolutely rational to see it likely that they are behind these outages. The full analysis requires estimation of the probability that this is all just a coincidence, and of other major "non-coincidental" branches. But one can do this at various levels of precision and explicitly observe how the output depends on the priors and the estimated probabilities (and therefore, on the assumptions).
PRISM update is being rolled out.
It's a big change so hiccups are expected.
What kind of CLASSIFIED network is this one, that when it goes down we hear about it on CNN?
The size and scale of something like SIPR, JWICS mean they're interacted with by tens of thousands of people at facilities worldwide on a daily basis as part of their regular relatively mundane work. It would be hard not to notice.
The existence and status of the network are not classified, just some of the data on it, I'm guessing.
The kind that you need clearance and polygraph to get on.
Here is a question for your next polygraph test: "Are you the source who told CNN about our internal IT stuff?"
I am just surprised this is not happening all the time, after piling on layers upon layers of software and merely looking for a checkbox to check and someone else to blame (and pay). Even the vertically integrated tech companies that used to be in control of the whole stack are having their Outlook moments now, everyone else is worse off.
The pattern is that a bunch of software kind of sucks
Pretense for Iran ground operation
Iran's strong hits against our military, which were barely reported, could easily have been the excuse of they wanted to go that route.
They don't. This administration thought they could Venezuela Iran from the air.
Do they even need a pretense these days?
It has come to my attention that the political elites and the Epstein class simply do as they please with virtually no consequences.
Four unrelated things?
Idk why you're being downvoted. Optimizely getting malware doesn't seem connected to Outlook going down last week in any meaningful way.
It's easy to spot patterns when paranoid.
the pattern is more and more poorly trained people are effing around with running "AI" agents on their massive, fragile codebases
none of these systems are even vaguely similar
"Mr. Bond, they have a saying in Chicago: Once is happenstance. Twice is coincidence. The third time it's enemy action."
It's clear, there is a screaming need for competent, well paid IT across all sectors.
We used to have 18F (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/18F) but DOGE eliminated the office.
Not to defend the cut or weigh into politics, but how much of 18F was specifically security related? Because that's what's required here, rather than tech generalists.
I cannot comment on the specifics, they change with time. I had few interaction with technologists in one of the federal government body almost a decade ago. Those people were thoughtful, expert with first primitives and open to what you are doing as long as the intent is met.
Bad software engineering practices makes security kind of hard to do
There is a well known intersection between reliability and security. Arguably they are two sides of the same coin:
https://google.github.io/building-secure-and-reliable-system...
GSA's 18F played a major role in applying Site Reliability Engineering (SRE) and modern DevOps practices to federal government infrastructure.
In government security is political. And what we had with 18F was the beginning of a government office that was both tech savvy and politically savvy.
Who decides when a DDOS of Trumpcare.gov that is traced back to Akamai servers was an attempt to extort government contracts or “those pesky Chinese state actors”?
Or in the case of Trump, somehow Biden's fault.
Lots of strong opinions on 18F's closure. Here is the GSA Inspector General's October 2024 assessment, done during Biden, and prior to Trump/DOGE actions.
https://www.gsaig.gov/sites/default/files/management-challen...
Sure, that's a good example, but 250 employees is just a drop in the bucket across all North American IT departments.
The problem is much more systemic than having 1 decent org.
Well, when you put it that way, it’s amazing how much just a drop in the bucket is able to accomplish. We should fill all of our buckets with at least a drop.
Yeah, the assumption that 18F would have prevented this is ... absurd. The problems we're facing are ai related, and external entities are more capabile, nimble, and motivated than our beloved government (right now anyway).
You sure can hire a lot more external consultants to do the job now.
I hope the DOGE investigations result in so much prison time and laws being changed specifically to codify what can’t happen.
The whole conservative thesis of the “imperial president” is an embarrassment to non-servile Americans. Glad we showed them the door in the last election (in a generational ass beating). Fingers crossed everyone involved ends up in prison forever.
Investigate all you want, but who's going to do the actual prosecuting? The Trump DOJ?
The next DOJ?
I expect all these incompetent or corrupt actors to be preemptively pardoned.
The world expects all pardons issued by a convict to be reversed for the US to regain standing.
I believe that even less than I believe the pardons won't be issued. The world has expected a lot of things from the US, only to see the exact opposite happen in last years.
If he keels over suddenly, that gets interesting, especially with Vance having to look towards 2028.
He is just more and more senile than sick. With his medical care I would be very surprised if person in his position perish prematurely.
I wouldn't be surprised if Trump pardoned his corrupt friends, as many US presidents have done before. But I also wouldn't be surprised if he went a step further and issued preemptive pardons to all his loyal servants who so cheerfully supported him throughout his circus show.
That would mean nobody would face any personal responsibility for the damage they've caused. The main reason this hasn't been done on such a massive scale before is the political backlash. And Trump simply doesn't give a damn about that.
We need a court finding that says preemptive pardons are not what the Constitution allows. It makes no sense for even the President to offer a get-out-of-jail card with no expiration date.
this isn’t IT. it’s network engineering which is much harder to find truly good people
Competent but understaffed is more likely the problem.
Guess who screams I’m competent the loudest? The incompetent workers.
On a serious note, I see it as a paradox. Competency is built through struggles, and the non-competent do not want someone that seemed lesser at some point to outrank them, be the go to person.
I think most of "IT experts" are having a collective sigh right now and thinking everyone should vibe fixes into existence
if only hunger wasn't an issue
Should we hire the million laid off engineers out there or go with the 22yo who hasn't done a bootcamp? We'll see!
If you don’t hire juniors and grads you get the future you deserve.
And sometimes you even get a junior who isn't just an AI parrot and your confidence in the future increases;
Nnaaahhhh Ai will fix all of it. It's only been 1.5 years of vibe coding and everything seems broken beyond repair.
But give it another year, trust me bro.
AI's being used to find good old human-coded vulnerabilities and rapidly exploiting them. Ten year old holes in PHP, for example.
> everything seems broken beyond repair.
It does? Can you share an objective metrics that can highlight this that doesn't focus on single, isolated events?
I know you'll provide this because of your strong anti-"trust me bro" stance and dedication to scientific fact.
Check the news lately... There is no needs to act like a "try-hard" with both your eyes closed.
The comment sections are starting to read like Reddit threads. That is what I find most bizarre since all of this started happening.
I hate to be that guy but this apparently an HN trope that you’re describing: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1524184
What I haven't seen mentioned is whether it's possible that these are a rogue or state-controlled AI cyber-attack and it's just doing a really good job at covering its tracks?
Or it's too humiliating, or too close to national defense secrets, to publicly admit what it is. Imagine if it's some sort of "Die Hard 3" -style threat made by Putin: "Don't attack my refineries or I'll shut down your industries — here's a shut down of your NSA for proof."
Foreign Bad Actors... State level resources ... AI enhancement. Cyber warfare could get really ugly here.
Thus far an increase in AI-enhanced buggy code patches seems to have been more disruptive than any AI-enhanced cyber warfare.
It's an increase in AI-assisted bug discoveries in existing code for the most part.
A lot of impromptu discoveries in production the last few days.
Or laid off tech workers. Instead of smashing knitting looms, they are bringing down networks.
Why do we even know about this? This is likely not information that should be known outside of the NSA.
You blabbed, Quaid! You blabbed about Mars!
Give it a minute. Bespoke networks fall down all the time. We are probably only hearing about this because of the coincidence of the other recent network failures. It is a self-fulfilling prophecy. As we become more sensitive to outages, every normal everyday outage becomes part of the global pattern.
If the network was one of those no-fail important ones (think NORAD stuff) then nobody would be talking about it as doing so would be treasonous. So, at most, this is a less-important internal network. It will probably be back up by end of business.
There's even a name for this fallacy: it's called the frequency illusion [0]
> The frequency illusion, also known as the Baader–Meinhof phenomenon, is a cognitive bias in which a person notices a specific concept, word, or product more frequently after recently becoming aware of it.
Or at least it is very similar.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frequency_illusion
Also drone/UFO "Flaps". If ATC tells pilots that a drone has been seen near an airport, every scrap of paper, every possible light in the sky becomes a quadcopter. Flaps have actually shut down major airports, even though nothing is ever photographed let alone found.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gatwick_Airport_drone_incident
>> Flap, originally a military term to describe a "period of panic or chaos", is used by ufologists to describe surges of sightings in one geographical area. Longer surges spanning multiple countries may be called waves. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UFO_flap
What happens is that the media catches whiff of a new fear, and goes to work harvesting it for every last ad-view. Each story amps up the fear too, so it becomes a flywheel of money.
Anything the catches the public's collective conscious, the media is there to stoke it into piles of ad dollars.
Is it professional media or social media? Someone posted it on HN and here we are talking about it.
Both, and they feed on each other
They also definitely both make money on this kind of engagement.
Any journalist worth their pay is paying close attention to what is getting traction on social media.
It's extremely profitable to write stories telling social media pitchfork mobs how correct they are. Influencers have been catching onto this game in the last decade too, and went from "here is what is actually going on" contrarians to "here is what is actually going on" agenda towing. It just pays so much more, and people trust you more (because people naturally trust those who tell them they are right).
> Give it a minute. Bespoke networks fall down all the time.
Including NSA Net? How often does it fall down?
> We are probably only hearing about this because of the coincidence of the other recent network failures
This seems to be an explanation for why the press is covering it - this time. Which also hints that NSA Net failures happen with some kind of regularity and that that news orgs had been getting wind of it.
I suspect that the opposite is true. That it's rare to unheard of for NSA Net to fail like this and rare for a news org to get wind of something so deeply protected.
> Including NSA Net? How often does it fall down?
I rather doubt they have a public status page.
> This seems to be an explanation for why the press is covering it - this time.
That's one possibility. Another is it goes down sometimes, but that morale in the administration has sunk to where it gets leaked.
I feel like this is attention bias. A government built messaging service used by one agency for a subset of their data isn't going to have 3 nines in the first place.
It definitely is, these networks go down all the time and it never ends up on the news.
Why not, that seems like a pretty well understood scope and scale. GitHub going down because it has 400 interdependent systems and a billion new users is more understandable.
It's such a small scope and scale that the issue could easily be, like, "We restarted the server and for some reason it's not booting back up".
That is crazy - even crazier than if SIPR or JWICS was broken
NSANet is one of the most locked down, observed and monitored networks on the planet
> JWICS darn it I was going crazy trying to remember this one. ahhh to get a sneak peek there...
I oversaw multiple JWICS nodes over my career and it’s pretty normal boring networking stuff tbh.
I was under the impression that _interesting_ military tech videos were available.
Go get a job a Booze Allen, Accenture Federal Service, BAE, CACI, or any number of DoD federal contractors.
non american thus non starter!
Where can you even find information about how it's secured? Also, are they monitoring for security or for everyday bugs? Is this high-assurance software running on high-assurance systems?
The only way is to get an NSC networking job and TS/SCI with CI polygraph
I'll probably get downvoted for this but I feel like CNN stopped being a serious source of journalism a long time ago (along with Fox and most of the networks). A real story is the exception, so it's hard for me to take most of these things seriously.
Have you considered endorsing a better source instead of just disparaging the rest and leaving us to guess how we're supposed to achieve enlightenment? "Trust no one" is not a winning strategy.
funny I sat there for a minute thinking to myself.. I should provide a better source. I came up blank. Sorry. I could probably go on and on about independent journalism, but it's probably healthier to just turn it all off and go outside.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50533089
Yes but the Reuters headline is literally "......CNN reports"
We need more transparency ASAP or this should essentially be treated as a serious AI related event.
"A copper wiring problem" this is all we gonna know
Once is happenstance. Twice is coincidence. The third time it's enemy action.
Enemy action or incompetence?
Hanlon's Razor seems very appropriate here.
Right? These are the same companies that laid off their tech staff because "AI".
When did this happen to the NSA before? (No criticism, I just don't know.)
The outage that got the most press was in January 2000.
https://www.nsa.gov/portals/75/documents/news-features/decla...
We just had a full ground stop of all flights, and a major banking outage yesterday, following a major microsoft outage. I am starting to have doubts about them not being related.
Once is happenstance, twice is coincidence. the third time is the media has realized that outage stories are getting lots of eyeballs right now.
Keep seeing this movie quote like it's something serious. No, this is just more stupidity at the root.
Conspiracy theories are flying, but don't you think that enough people are involved in maintaining these systems that if it was, for example, an attack by a foreign country, it would have leaked from one of the tens of thousands of people involved?
Also consider that the media absolutely loves to run any story it can find about a network going down right now because it causes fear, and fear gets clicks. Now think about how many major networks have a problem in a given week. You just never hear about them until now.
Besides recency bias, another problem with this specific outage story or really anything to do with current national security/defense matters is that by definition only uninformed opinions are widely available. "Those who know don't talk, those who talk don't know" – excluding one-in-a-generation whistleblowers like Snowden, and even those are necessarily limited to one-time snapshots because once they disclose they are shut out and (presumably?) methods, technologies, and operations change afterward.
> don't you think that [...] it would have leaked from one of the tens of thousands of people involved?
No I don't. Why would you risk your career and potentially your freedom to leak a report about enemy action, in which doing so could potentially harm your country too?
So we are to believe that 6 people leaked the fact that the classified NSA network is down, but also no one is willing to leak evidence of widespread cyber attacks?
The 6 people that “leaked” the outage are likely executive leaders in the organization and also being very careful to not release information that would actually pose a threat to national security. It’s pretty common in DC, see David Pozen’s article The Leaky Leviathan[0]. These people are sometimes prosecuted (see Gen. James Cartwright) but it’s rare because it’s both tacitly understood as necessary to allow for coordination with the rest of the government and american society, and they take effort to color within the lines.
[0] https://harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-127/the-leaky-leviath...
It isn’t. Some crypto keys were rotated. That’s it.
Source:
We're supposed to believe than seven people leaked a plan to set off a radiological weapon in DC. So presumably they'll expect us to buy this, too.
https://www.cnn.com/2026/11/16/politics/us-intelligence-iran...
> don't you think that enough people are involved in maintaining these systems
No and that was the purpose of DOGE
(yes that quote was separated from its context with some malice)
How did DOGE effect United Airlines, banks, and Microsoft?
>Also consider that the media absolutely loves to run any story it can find about a network going down right now
It's exactly like the media reporting every aviation notice after an airplane crash. Leading people to speculate "why is everything broken right now!" even though it's the normal course of business, they're only just noticing it now because they're being told to notice it.
Not if that country is an agent swarm.
I doubt this is the case, but since we're talking about conspiracy theories: this looks more like things breaking by accident as things are shimmed for control by a third party and less like a focused attack.
I’ve heard people suggest this is growing pains for the Genesis Mission coming online (we’re hitting the one year mark, and they may be a little cavalier trying to meet their timeline).
That’s NASA
No, it’s across the government and headed by the department of energy. The nominal goal is to achieve advances in scientific research, but it gets there by connecting all of the disparate networks across agencies (and creates a “superintelligence”)
https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/11/laun...
How many IT peolke weee later by doge? For some agencies it was all of them.
Perhaps the most visible casualty of vibe coding has been predictive typing.
Spelling mistakes are now a shibboleth
Sure, but then it's only so long until someone figures out how to prompt Claude without "don't make mistakes." Then it's all over.
Pretty sure the pool of people using it (and therefore training it) got a lot dumber.
If more people misspell than not, then what do the predictive statistics result in?
It peaked at early mature swype, and has been downhill since then.
dawg are you driving and texting
So the NSA also uses Microsoft 364?
NSA Net, for those in the know. (TS/SCI/NOFORN, IIRC)
If it's highly classified, we probably shouldn't know whether it's up or down.
Knowledge of the existence of the network isn't the same as knowledge of what traffic flows across it.
Just like good crypto must survive robust cryptanalysis, good network security needs to be robust even when adversaries know the network exists (and perhaps even where in physical space key nodes are located).
That being said: the network being down isn't something that immediately makes me worried in the near term. "Turn it off" is a better first response than "observe if anything seems weird" for communications channels that prioritize secrecy over availability.
All bits of classified information have to have justification to be classified. Typically unless its a critical classified network (think operational/urgent military comms) then the status of the network is usually not classified. Its only classified if a good argument can be made that the status is a national security risk. Usually its preferred to have as little as possible classified as its a great hindrance to fixing or getting things done because of all the overhead of security, meetings and paperwork involved.
Leaking this information ought to be a very serious breach.
This country continues day after day to get exactly what we voted for. Incompetant old men who would rather play golf and point fingers than take any form of decisive leadership and fix things.
(I'm not saying the dems would do better, i'm saying we all need to stop voting for old men in primaries because they are more "electable")
admittedly, this one cant be blamed on h1bs :(
Or Biden
Certain folks will definitely still try, and a subset will believe it.
Wrong. This is definitely Biden's fault. Or Obama. Or Clinton. The usual suspects.
And the cost to fix this is gonna be $12-billion. No wait, $30-billion. Fuuck it, make it $50-billion. And give it to me now or else!!!
The records are all right there on Hunter Biden's laptop!
Obama's not a citizen, so Biden hired him as an H1B to turk our cybersercuraty jerbs! Then teh hackerz came in thru Hillarty's emale serpers!
so, war is brewing and I guess people got the memo to patch...
NSA sysops: They're just like us!
"That's life"-Donald J. Trump when asked about recent service outages.
But don't worry guys, it's totally not related to Microsoft, FAA, all major banks, United Airlines, and Microsoft again.
Definitely just a big coincidence due to firing people, upgrades, and AI.
...maybe.
Seriously though at what point does this become justifiably suspicious?
Or maybe these disruptions are constantly occurring but are just now reaching the national spotlight due to the massively impactful FAA one?
There is a fine line between attributing this to mass conspiracy and cyber attack (which no one wants to believe) and attributing this to random bugs popping everywhere. Too many people are eager to cross this line. While others are trying to stay behind it.
The truth lies somewhere in the middle. My theory: someone figured out how to bring down each network. And is progressively breaking each system to help developers fix their security holes. Given enough breaks, we will figure out their modus operandi. And then figure out who they are.
Or something even more conspiratorial: us govt is halting each system to install back doors.
turns out we maybe needed all those people that were laid off a year ago
Anybody know anything about how it's deployed? Nasdaq down 2% on the news?
Well, Nasdaq is down 2%. "On the news", and on every single other piece of news that's out there. Tracing it to any one piece of news is usually pure guesswork.
> Anybody know anything about how it's deployed?
Nice try, foreign hacker
Source:
> according to six people
I don't think people leaking infos about a highly classified network would want to have their names published
six people... and CNN's vetting of them, resulting in CNN deciding to publish
Wasn't it CNN who published that the national weather service's radar was down the other day when that wasn't true?
It was. They've been on a streak of journalistic malpractice recently - including an egregious example a few years ago where they slandered and doxxed a minor.
The same CNN that is currently peddling another WMD accoring to some super-classified intel
"That's life"
SI will solve that
So it is not that classified after all? /s