5 comments

  • hereme888 a day ago

    Looks promising. I've been using a modified version of simple-english with my agents, and it's only sometimes better than not using it.

    Could you add a license file?

    • dannypovolotski 19 hours ago

      MIT license added. I've been using Simple English with mixed results. The biggest annoyance with it is that sometimes it ends up actually exaggerating some Claudisms I really hate, since it trends towards shorter sentences. Let me know if this approach feels effective to you after you try it!

      • hereme888 5 hours ago

        It's working well!

        I decided to combine multiple writing skills into one codebase, with yours as the default. Here's an example of what I consider significant improvement to one of my readme files: https://github.com/sm18lr88/VS_Code_Check/commit/1dfa3d31126....

        I gave you access to my version of the skill, which I'm keeping private until I know it works well and makes sense.

  • pentaphobe 2 days ago

    I like the definition of slop as "when we put less effort into producing something than we ask the consumer to spend understanding it." [^1]

    rather than some amorphous "made by an LLM and I can tell"

    That'd make "deslop" more of a "slop camouflage" since it just makes it less overt when a human has vibed the content instead of putting in any modicum of effort. :)

    Still - impressive example in the readme, if we can't prevent slop then at least can reduce how much reviewer lifetime is wasted

    [^1]: https://www.slopmanifesto.com/

    • dannypovolotski a day ago

      I agree! I personally either heavily edit or rewrite consequential communication to others if it includes anything that was written by AI.

      Often if I want to get over writers block, I'd describe a messy idea to an LLM and limit it to giving me THOUGHT_A_GOES_HERE and help me structure my writing, but then I actually write what I was going to.

      This is more aimed at making the way an agent talks to ME more tolerable, or at least understandable.

      I do, however, think that it goes beyond just "camouflage" because it addresses specific readability and understanding gaps that make the output meaningfully more useful to me when I read AI output and save time.