How Should Armies Fight?

(worksinprogress.co)

27 points | by ersinesen 6 hours ago ago

27 comments

  • Kuyawa a minute ago

    If I had nukes and you crossed over my border just once, I'd bomb your capital city into oblivion and get done with it

    I believe they are just using this war as a test for new weapons, there is no other reason to keep this going on for so long. War in Iraq showed us that full air power is enough to topple any government in less than a week, and that was more than two decades ago. Russia has the military power to erase Ukraine and Europe from the map and they haven't done it, what's their long run strategy?

  • elevation 21 minutes ago

    You don't fight wars for the fun of fighting, you have tactical objectives.

    If your nation only survives the winter because of a supply of grain and heating oil, then any threat that cuts off those supplies will kill you eventually. Often economic solutions suffice, but if you must protect yourself by kinetic means, then the battlefield is determined by the location (and supply lines) of the threat.

  • pjc50 an hour ago

    See the "survivability onion": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivability

    The Ukranian war is stuck in a slightly dystopian equilibrium because neither side can afford to gain WW2-scale air superiority, or even Iraq-war levels of air superiority. The increase in use of cruise missiles by Ukranians against strategic oil infrastructure may be the only way of changing that.

    • somenameforme an hour ago

      It's not about cost, but possibility. Iran is a relatively mid-tier power, and yet is still producing and flying drones/missiles in spite of the US blowing a huge chunk of our entire arsenal on it. The days of 'air superiority' in the classical sense, where you control the air domain and your opponent can do nothing about it, are simply over. And that means nearly all tactics that rely on air superiority are also obsolete.

      The most likely scenario is what we're seeing in Ukraine. Wars turning into battles of attrition. Two sides face off and whoever runs out of soldiers (or another finite resource) first, ends up catastrophically collapsing at some point. There is a great thing about this. It means that the cost of war is going to skyrocket. No more flying over, dropping some bombs, and waving a victory flag. If you want to win, it's going to take a lot of suffering, and not just of the other side.

      • AnimalMuppet an hour ago

        The allies gained air superiority in World War II only after several years of battles of attrition. The US could, perhaps, do that in Iran as well... but the price would be high, higher than the administration is willing to pay.

        • horsawlarway 9 minutes ago

          I'm not sure they can. At least not without doing what the above poster suggested and winning a war of resource attrition that prevents Iran from making/buying any more drones or missiles.

          I feel like the problem is that there's nothing to "control" anymore. It used to be that getting a plane into the air required a large factory to produce it, training grounds to prepare people to fly it, and then a runway to actually launch it.

          All of which were relatively vulnerable to disruption. You can bomb/shell any of those, and meaningfully disrupt the enemies capabilities to contest your air superiority.

          Now a guy in the field can just throw a drone and it's up.

          Worse, the drone itself is disposable and cheap, piloted by computer, and produced in mass quantities by 3rd parties who you can't meaningfully bomb/disrupt (at least not without starting another world war).

          So what does "control" actually look like in that case?

        • wtch98 19 minutes ago

          The Nazis failed to gain air superiority over the UK in 1940, it was close, but they still failed. The battle took three months.

          One advantage the UK had was their pilots who were shot down would parachute out, jump on a train, and be back in the air a few hours later, where German pilots were captured.

      • tosapple 36 minutes ago

        it's not a good thing, imagine an AI claiming (with drones and kin) an area where inputs like pure silicon or germanium are mined. mining operations run the risk of becoming carbon lifeform exclusion zones at some point as we them they occupy like termites the land.

        edit, forgot to mention africa is frequently the victim of parasitism. i hope it doesn't end this way.

    • pmg101 an hour ago

      For myself and other interested readers: what effects do you expect from such an increase in use of cruise missiles in shifting the equilibrium?

      • ceejayoz an hour ago

        Economic damage sufficient to put an end to the war?

  • spicyusername 2 hours ago

    Pretty horrific to consider

  • rdtsc an hour ago

    > The attacking Russians, who have no holes to sit in, no cities to shelter in, and can neither concentrate nor achieve surprise, are suffering astonishing losses

    But it still doesn’t bother them too much. Consider that they haven’t even started a full mobilization yet. They just keep sending groups of soldiers who then get droned, send another and so on. Eventually a few get through, so it’s a slowly advancing front.

  • jghn 39 minutes ago

    How should armies fight?

    The leaders of both belligerents should be locked in a room and forced to settle things on their own.

  • walrus01 an hour ago

    A fair bit of the modern era change (2022 and later) is: "Well, IEDs fly now..."

    • spwa4 an hour ago

      Only if you have at least hundreds of millions to invest in it.

      Of course, Iran does and keeps attacking everyone. If the news is right, they're trying lots of sabotage actions in Europe now. Will they move up to IEDs?

      • walrus01 an hour ago

        I'm not sure what you mean by that, I was referring to the immediate eastern front Ukrainian situation of improvised munitions on things as small as quadcopters with 10" size propellers and cheap carbon fiber plate frames.

        You don't need hundreds of millions or even dozens of millions or even 1 million to embark on a somewhat effective "strap explosives to a small FPV UAV" program.

        • spwa4 44 minutes ago

          At distance, you need high tens low hundreds of drones to guarantee you'll get through. Also, to do real damage they do seem to need to be multiple tens of kilograms of weight.

          So "strap a grenade to a DJI" is only ever going to work if you have someone launch it 100 meter from a target they can see, because you won't have reliable radio near the target with the normal equipment. And I wonder if there's really going to be that much of a difference between that and launching a grenade (you know, with those an military grenade launcher). I imagine that would be devastatingly effective against a target or a crowd if either you launch 10 grenades or it's not immediately clear it's a grenade to the target. Of course you could automate those too, but it'd be significantly more complex than a DJI FPV drone.

          • ceejayoz 24 minutes ago

            > you won't have reliable radio near the target with the normal equipment

            Fiber optic drones have been a thing for several years in the Ukraine conflict, and on-device visual guidance is starting to be a thing.

            • bluGill a few seconds ago

              There are downsides of fiber optic drones such that Ukraine prefers to use radio if they can get any through. Radio vs interference has been a constant battle in this war and depending on who has what you see different tactics in different parts of the battlefield and what you see changes

      • BigTTYGothGF 10 minutes ago

        > If the news is right

        If the news is right, the Spaniards have sunk the USS Maine.

  • jareklupinski 2 hours ago

    in coliseums

    • jrm4 an hour ago

      Nailed it.

      War was already kind of stupid -- and with basically perfect information,today even more so.

      Just do games.

      • t43562 43 minutes ago

        The consequences of losing are what matter - it's why it would be foolish to accept the result of a game depending on who you are and who your opponent is.

        • jrm4 8 minutes ago

          You're missing the point.

          You don't do coliseums and sports to "decide a winner," that doesn't matter; that's what diplomacy is for.

          War is not logical. War is a weird anomalous result of the fact that people, usually dudes, love complicated fighting, there's something about it in our nature.

          • jareklupinski a minute ago

            > people, usually dudes, love complicated fighting

            i still dont understand offsides rules

  • eth0up an hour ago

    Against those who would abuse their power