When I see a mid(exceptional) fossil, it haunts me with images of sentient interstellar carnivorous plants which used mammals with clear human foreshadowings sometimes as food sometimes as buffoons too.
I read At the Mountains of Madness in high school from a battered paperback I borrowed from my uncle, and the fossil angle never clicked for me until now. I always thought Lovecraft was inventing the whole thing. Knowing he was riffing on real finds from his own time makes the story feel less like pure invention and more like a guy reading the news and getting carried away, which I like more, honestly.
You see a lot of this in older science fiction. They were writing "science fiction", but we read it as "science fiction".
There's tons of things like ESP or pheromones or giant red suns which a contemporary reader, who's not very familiar with the history of ideas or science, will read as colorful fantasy, and yet the original author was giving a speculation, or believed it was simple fact (https://gwern.net/dune-genetics#scientifiction).
Lovecraft did this quite a lot. The Essential Lovecraft does a lot of "This happened to lovecraft, then he wrote this story" and a lot of it is either stuff he read or things that happened to him.
Antarctica was still little known, but penguins were already familiar to the world because they are present in Argentina and Chile in regions already colonized and transited through. As the other poster said, Lovecraft could have seen stuffed specimens and drawings and photographs.
I find it very difficult to believe that Lovecraft had not at least seen a photograph or drawing of a penguin, having lived through the heroic age of polar exploration when popular culture was filled with stories set in Antarctica. Even a taxidermied specimen would have been easily available to him in the average natural history museum.
When I see a mid(exceptional) fossil, it haunts me with images of sentient interstellar carnivorous plants which used mammals with clear human foreshadowings sometimes as food sometimes as buffoons too.
I read At the Mountains of Madness in high school from a battered paperback I borrowed from my uncle, and the fossil angle never clicked for me until now. I always thought Lovecraft was inventing the whole thing. Knowing he was riffing on real finds from his own time makes the story feel less like pure invention and more like a guy reading the news and getting carried away, which I like more, honestly.
You see a lot of this in older science fiction. They were writing "science fiction", but we read it as "science fiction".
There's tons of things like ESP or pheromones or giant red suns which a contemporary reader, who's not very familiar with the history of ideas or science, will read as colorful fantasy, and yet the original author was giving a speculation, or believed it was simple fact (https://gwern.net/dune-genetics#scientifiction).
Lovecraft did this quite a lot. The Essential Lovecraft does a lot of "This happened to lovecraft, then he wrote this story" and a lot of it is either stuff he read or things that happened to him.
He would be even more haunted if he was shown the skeleton of a white man next to a black man's one.
He also famously deduced Penguins were Grotesque despite never having seen one.
"On the barren shore, and on the lofty ice barrier in the background, myriads of grotesque penguins squawked and flapped their fins"
Antarctica was still little known, but penguins were already familiar to the world because they are present in Argentina and Chile in regions already colonized and transited through. As the other poster said, Lovecraft could have seen stuffed specimens and drawings and photographs.
I find it very difficult to believe that Lovecraft had not at least seen a photograph or drawing of a penguin, having lived through the heroic age of polar exploration when popular culture was filled with stories set in Antarctica. Even a taxidermied specimen would have been easily available to him in the average natural history museum.