On The Brutality Of Amdahl's Law

(bosoncutter.substack.com)

22 points | by optimalsolver a day ago ago

5 comments

  • MattRogish 17 hours ago

    This is Amara’s Law in action:

    “We tend to overestimate the effect of a technology in the short run and underestimate the effect in the long run.”

    Or Bill Gate’s version:

    “Most people overestimate what they can do in one year and underestimate what they can do in ten years.”

    Mixed with Gibson:

    “The future is already here – it's just not evenly distributed.”

    To the folks like us in the middle of a mania like AI, it’s hard to not get carried away with the exuberant feeling that the rate of change is increasing ever faster - it is. For some parts of the world.

    Will AI eventually dramatically change everyone’s lives? Yes. Is it tomorrow or next year? Not a chance. For OP’s article’s reasons and others, it will take a lot longer.

    This kind of change is not a tsunami where it hits everywhere all at once. It’s more of a climate change - it hits various places at different times, but everybody will be hit eventually.

  • joerick 15 hours ago

    This has long been my favourite counter-argument to the 'singularity'. How often in your own life is intelligence the limiting factor? I'd say frustratingly rare. If only! One reason I play games is that it's fun to briefly enter a scenario where intelligence is everything.

  • pacificmaelstrm 19 hours ago

    This is being ignored now but in ten years it will likely be obvious in hindsight.

  • TGower 18 hours ago

    The author's argument of "ASI will be bottlenecked by the slowest part of the existing process" is true for the existing process, but it's an argument along the lines of "Steroids can only speed up horses so much, so people can only travel so fast" before we invented jet planes.

    Assuming we actually get ASI, it will be used to find a better process for producing the widget, or a better solution to the problem the widget tries to address.

  • ferroman a day ago

    This site can’t provide a secure connection bosoncutter.subsbosoncutter.substack.com uses an unsupported protocol. ERR_SSL_VERSION_OR_CIPHER_MISMATCH