40 comments

  • Someone1234 2 hours ago

    The article is confusing, they state the problem, then bring up two examples both of which broke even in terms of costs Vs. income, but then claimed local officials were disappointed they weren't profitable instead.

    I thought the point of these things was to get people to pull off of major roads, into local towns/areas, and potentially spend money at local businesses. If they're breaking even, and still accomplishing that, then there isn't a problem?

    • bluGill an hour ago

      Until the things wear out and need to be replaced. Many of them were built in older/worse safety standards - they have "worked", but they would not be allowed for good reason today and should be torn down.

      • redwood an hour ago

        Imagine if Paris had said that about the Notre Dame

        • bluGill 7 minutes ago

          Imagine what Paris could be if they didn't have that building there - that space could be used for many other things.

          What is right I do not know. However if you cannot imagine many other futures you are too stuck in the past.

        • lotsofpulp 11 minutes ago

          Imagine if a town in the middle of nowhere France said that about the Notre Dame (assuming it had been built there).

    • nonethewiser an hour ago

      Are the attractions private businesses though? I mean do the entities running them actually care if they spend money elsewhere?

    • diego_moita an hour ago

      Drumheller is a special case.

      The city is very far from the major highway and it has its own world-class big tourist attraction: the Royal Tyrrell Museum[1], i.m.o. by far the best dinosaur museum I've ever seen.

      Yes, I've been to New York's, London's and Vienna's natural history museums. When it comes strictly to dinosaurs, Drumheller is still better. But on the remainder of natural history Vienna's is better than all others.

      [1] https://www.tyrrellmuseum.com/

      • mhurron an hour ago

        Ya, I don't see why Drumheller would feel the need for this monstrosity.

  • lavendermon 44 minutes ago

    I once saw the world's largest purple spoon somewhere in the northwest and it's stuck with me for at least 15 years now. Ridiculous roadside attractions add to the aura of adventure on a road trip and especially with the rise of Instagram and such I am surprised that fad is fading.

    Towns have seemingly replaced some of the schlocky roadside attractions with large and beautiful murals on buildings, which I believe accomplish similar goals: encourage people to stop in the town and potentially spend some time and money.

    • TFNA 12 minutes ago

      In random little places all over the world I have seen signs erected in public squares "I [heart] [name of town]". So identical in shape and material that there must be one factory in China pumping these out for everywhere. But only when I read your post did I realize these are essentially selfie magnets.

      The funniest I have seen so far is the sign "I [heart] Karakalpakstan" in the square of the little railway village in the desert after the Kazakhstan-Uzbekistan border. There are few tourists who can sincerely say "I love Karakalpakstan" (though the place has its charms if one does some reading on it before visiting).

    • goodmythical 21 minutes ago

      That's funny, I've always used "(State's) second largest purple spoon" as an example of a big fish in a small pond type of situation.

      It could be an approaching-a-laddle purple spoon in order to qualify, after all, but the title makes it sound vastly more important than "awkwardly sized novelty spoon"

    • cnees 13 minutes ago

      I wouldn't stop for a mural. I'd stop for a giant squirrel.

  • skyberrys an hour ago

    I do big road trips with the kids. World's largest pistachio anyone? It was somewhere in New Mexico. I appreciate all of the weird things we find along the side of the major highways in the US. Bonus points for clean bathrooms and dog friendly.

    • komodo99 14 minutes ago

      Ah, I know that one, its about an hour away from the world's largest chile pepper too (apparently, its red, who knew?)

  • bookofjoe 6 days ago
  • roosterIllusi0n 12 minutes ago

    If you do not own the land your business sits on, you don't own a business.

  • nemomarx 3 hours ago

    I wonder if they couldn't let the exterior degrade and turn her into a fossil? If the structure is still good that could be about as aesthetically appealing to tourists.

    • schiffern 3 hours ago

      Dilapidated structure in the middle of nowhere Kansas with bored kids, what could go wrong

  • xg15 3 hours ago
  • CalRobert 35 minutes ago

    Don’t take away the biggest ball of twine in Minnesota!

  • jpm_sd 3 hours ago

    https://youtube.com/watch?v=Yv_QUiDYTTg

    The Biggest Ball of Twine in Minnesota - Weird Al classic!

  • redwood an hour ago

    Hangar 1 at Moffett Field is the SV equivalent of this

  • adolph 3 hours ago

    Seems like the longer than refill charging times of bev could make a new market for roadside attractions at certain intervals.

    • mrngld 2 hours ago

      That keeps getting shorter though with each generation. I've got a fairly slow charging EV, don't take many road trips but every time I've stopped to charge I've ended up charging more than I strictly needed for the next leg of the drive simply because the time involved in walking into the adjacent WalMart, Buc-ee's or whatever to use a restroom, maybe grab a drink or some fast food, ended up taking more time than the car needed.

      Of course, if you need none of those things it can't compete with pumping fuel. But with home and destination charging that's increasingly rare.

    • vjvjvjvjghv 2 hours ago

      I have been thinking about having coffee shops next to charging stations but when you take a close look it's only a few people per hour.

      • galago an hour ago

        An Uber driver I talked to recently said it takes his car about 20 minutes to charge for the day (he lives in an apartment and can't charge at home). He goes to a strip mall with a grocery store and a coffee place, maybe Dutch Brothers. Its part of his routine. It makes sense in places people are going already, to the point that the slow charge is just free while you're in the business. This is in Portland, Oregon.

  • efields 3 hours ago

    Just a hunch as I haven't read the article, but weren't most of these built in an era before communication devices in your pocket let you beam videos of anything anywhere, diminishing the novelty of something you once only had to "see with your own eyes" to believe?

    There's obvious creativity and charm to some of these things, but if they don't stick around, I get it...

    • TFNA 7 minutes ago

      DeLillo's novel White Noise, written in the early-mid 1980s, has a scene involving a visit to "The Most Photographed Barn in America". Pictures of these kind of things have been taken and shown to other people since long before the smartphone era.

    • swatcoder 2 hours ago

      There've been postcards and magazines and photos and even 8mm and videos for ages.

      These roadside monuments and tourist traps weren't about seeing-is-believing, but about stretching your feet and breaking up the monotony of a long drive.

      What changed isn't that you can see them or other monumental or quirky things more conveniently, but that many people have become insulat and screen-addicted prefer to stay in the car for a fresh scroll through tiktok than to move around or engage with locals or other tourists.

      • jerlam 2 hours ago

        I think the era of the Great American/Canadian Roadtrip is over which makes roadside attractions irrelevant.

        Flying is cheaper and more accessible than it was 50 years ago. Instead of spending a week to drive somewhere and stop at these small cities, people are just taking a day to fly where they want to go and fly back.

        • bluGill an hour ago

          If you are single (and often a couple) flying is cheaper. If you have kids road trips quickly become much cheaper. Some of those attractions are worth seeing for everybody (but there are more things worth seeing in the world than you will live to do unless you are born rich and never do anything except travel)

        • galago an hour ago

          For myself and some people I know, driving is a luxury. It means you have the time to go out and see things. Flying is for people who have to be someplace at a certain time, or who can't afford to travel in comfort.

        • skyberrys an hour ago

          I love a road trip. It makes it about the journey and not just the destination. Plus I can't fit my giant dog into the plane with the family.

    • mitchdoogle 2 hours ago

      Well now they are an easy social media post. They tick multiple boxes for the things people like to post about - they show that you're traveling, doing something unique, and they are often goofy or humorous. The article talks mainly about how these things are popular, just that many of them are near the end of their lives and cost too much to renovate or rebuild.

    • itake 2 hours ago

      I live in Seattle and the costs for everything drives people to either stay at home or go to work. There isn't time to drive across the state and stop at dinosaur exhibit.

      Millennial parents (unlike the boomers) can't afford homes near their work, so they are losing hours each from their kids and away from activities like this.

      --- edit clarification ---

      less money means:

      - High fuel prices mean shorter or less road trips.

      - staying home (or local) is cheaper than going out.

      less time means:

      - choosing flights for lower transit time costs

      - instead of spending limited time on a C-tier amusement stop, they choose to drive past and focus on A-tier experiences.

      • motionlessveloc 2 hours ago

        Nobody goes to Big Things on their commute? They're strictly a road trip stopover, and the most successful ones are those that are in the middle of nowhere but along a major route between large cities.

        • itake 31 minutes ago

          I think people have less time and money in general.

          less money means:

          - High fuel prices mean shorter or less road trips.

          - staying home (or local) is cheaper than going out.

          less time means:

          - choosing flights for lower transit time costs

          - instead of spending limited time on a C-tier amusement stop, they choose to drive past and focus on A-tier experiences.

        • xp84 an hour ago

          If I’m understanding GP properly, I think they are theorizing that a certain group of people spends so much time commuting that they don’t have time to visit this type of thing.

          I don’t think I buy that very specific explanation though.

          Honestly, this whole story feels kind of like fluff. “Big thing constructed 20 to 50 years ago with cheaper labor, materials, and potentially regulatory/permitting expense, costs a surprising amount to refurbish and/or maintain, may not be profitable” doesn’t make as exciting of a headline.

    • morkalork 2 hours ago

      Probably more interesting to the driver than the passengers these days