A wave of plastic-free coffee pods and machines

(cnn.com)

89 points | by thunderbong 18 hours ago ago

100 comments

  • troyvit 17 hours ago

    Huh, cool. If you want to save a few bucks you can go with a stainless steel French press or a mason jar if you're into cold brews. You're symbolizing a different kind of status though.

    This summer was sunny and hot in Colorado, so every morning I'd make a jar of sun coffee. I'd leave it out through the day and overnight. The next morning I'd pull it in, filter it, refill it with grounds and water and take it outside again. It was cool enough to enjoy and really smooth.

    • hedora 5 hours ago

      If you want to save fewer bucks, get to zero plastic and get better espresso, you can buy one of these and a burr grinder:

      https://flairespresso.com/products/the-flair-classic

      I've had one for about a decade. It reliably produces better espresso than >99% of Bay Area coffee shops. (>95% if you exclude national chains).

      If I were buying one today, I'd toss the flow control head, silicon sleeve on the cylinder and the pressure gauge, but those come with it for free now, so to each their own, I guess.

      The trick is to boil the stainless steel cylinder in your kettle (PID at sea level, conventional above ~ 2000 ft elevation) with the water so that you get the temperature dialed in within a degree C or so, like a conventional (lead-filled, unlike the flair) Italian machine. I use a pair of tongs to pick up the stainless steel cylinder, so I don't need the sleeve. (Check the boiling point of water at your elevation -- unlike a steam machine, this can't exceed that temperature, so stuff might start to run kinda cool at 3000 ft or so).

      Flair doesn't sell a "true" classic anymore, but I bet they could get the bare bones variant I use to < $100 if they tried. Maybe someone else will when any patents run out. My only other complaint is that the two-in-one bottomless porta-filter I have runs the espresso across plastic when in non-bottomless mode.

      Note that the thing I linked has a plastic plunger. They make a stainless steel one as an upgrade. At that point, you're down to one silcone o-ring in the water / coffee path. Everything else is stainless, so no lead. The next thing to worry about is nickel, but that only matters if you're allergic. I used to use the SS plunger, but then you need to boil it too if you want to dial in the water temperature.

      • senderista 2 hours ago

        I've tried the Flair and I find the Aeropress much less fussy.

        • bayindirh 27 minutes ago

          Aeropress is accelerated drip coffee. It's not espresso by any means.

        • lerchmo an hour ago

          Aeropress cannot really do an espresso at a full 7,8 or 9 bar. It’s more like a pour over.

    • throwaway81523 9 hours ago

      French press coffee isn't so healthy either because of stuff like cafestols in the fines (small diameter grounds) that slip through the french press screen. To get rid of those you want a brewing scheme with a paper filter. The simplest no-plastic approach is a Chemex. They have a history and they also look cool as heck. Unfortunately, since they are made of glass, they can break if you're not careful. https://chemexcoffeemaker.com/

      • bayindirh 30 minutes ago

        If you don't want to use paper filters, you can use Swiss Gold, generic all-steel or cloth ones as well. Also there's Stanley's all steel pour-over.

        When you want to go low or no plastics, there are many choices now.

      • Barbing 3 hours ago

        Nice lazy method: overnight cold brew + pour into a [glass] pourover w/paper filter.

        Make a lot to only use a couple paper filters a week. Most days, your coffee is already ready in the fridge, no wait (unless you wanna microwave it or something).

        Make it really strong and dilute with a lot of [non-dairy] milk to go easy on the stomach.

        • littlecranky67 2 hours ago

          How do you heat it up then? Or is it supposed to be drank cold?

          • senderista 2 hours ago

            I heat it up in the microwave all the time. Smooth as a pour-over and much less of a hassle to make.

            • littlecranky67 an hour ago

              That is the advise I got before, but I find this is super difficult to hit the right temperature. I either get boiling coffee, or luke warm.

              • bayindirh 28 minutes ago

                When you get used to the microwave you have, you can hit the same spot every time. It's a formula depending on your cup, the wattage of he microwave and time.

                I can hit the temperature I want every time on a Bosch microwave from 80s which has two power levels and a rotary, mechanical timer.

      • hyperbovine 8 hours ago

        Which is ironic because if you’re into Chemex you’re into vinyl, in my experience.

      • VladVladikoff 7 hours ago

        What is the advantage of this over a normal paper filter coffee maker?

        • throwaway81523 2 hours ago

          It's hard to find plastic-free normal paper filter coffee makers. A few exist but mostly only for small batches. Also, the porcelain or glass ones are breakable just like the Chemex. I'm a bit suspicious of copper (Hario makes one of those). Kalita has a stainless steel one but it's small and expensive. I'd be interested if you know of anything else.

      • nickff 8 hours ago

        The Chemex can also be a little annoying because of the tendency of the filter to block the 'spout', causing the brewer to stall, and requiring a chopstick or straw to avoid. That said, I use my Chemex twice a week.

    • asdff 6 hours ago

      When I broke my french press I got by fine with just throwing grounds in a pot of boiled water and decanting it off after a few minutes steep. Basically all the press does anyhow just less convenient.

      • seemaze 5 hours ago

        Cowboy coffee. Simple, bur effective.

    • kombookcha 3 hours ago

      I haven't heard the expression "sun coffee" before. Is it just a colloquial cold brew?

    • mathgeek 9 hours ago

      > You're symbolizing a different kind of status though.

      Now I'm curious whether you mean a higher status (which I infer when folks are using such things) or a lower status (which I could also infer).

    • roflchoppa 17 hours ago

      I should get my cold brew setup out, thanks for the reminder.

    • dominotw 17 hours ago

      i dont like french press coffee

      • Marsymars 17 hours ago

        FWIW, French press and cold brew are entirely different - the fact that a French press was used to filter cold brew is really kind of incidental.

      • Fricken 17 hours ago

        I use a moka pot. I don't feel comfortable calling what it makes espresso but for it's still pretty decent. If I had more patience I would do pour over at home.

        • bulbar 16 hours ago

          Well, the moka pot makes moka, not espresso ;-).

  • seemaze 17 hours ago

    Hate to be the bearer of bad news, but even the $10k slayer espresso machine has a plastic water resevoir. Granted the brewing assembly is mostly plastic free.

    While I sympathize with the sentiment to eliminate plastic from the transport chain for anything ingestible, it's practically impossible in the modern world.

    Simple is usually best; glass or ceramic pour over, stainless press, or even the traditional South American coffee sock[0]

    [0]https://perfectdailygrind.com/2016/01/coffee-sock-old-school...

    • benrutter 35 minutes ago

      > While I sympathize with the sentiment to eliminate plastic from the transport chain for anything ingestible, it's practically impossible in the modern world.

      I think the argument is pretty simple:

      - Plastic is bad (environment, microplastics, etc) - We should minimize it

      That doesn't necessitate a "all the way to zero or don't bother" logic, which what you're saying reads as.

      Coffee pods machines have been an environmental nightmare, great to see a growing trend that addresses this.

      • 233mhz 24 minutes ago

        If you care enough about the environment to get rid of plastic you should get rid of coffee too, this argument makes no sense

    • saidnooneever 17 hours ago

      stainless steel might be less bad for environment if u chuck it in the bin but if you look at the entire process from getting ores to having the steel item i dont really think its a very big difference.

      used to live nexto a huge steel refinery and many mental diseases and cancers in the area are up more than 50% not to mention lots of birth defects etc.

      maybe its effects are more local idk. Not sure how glass and ceramic are made.

      ofc not bad to try and eliminate plastics but having 1 plastic free device that is overly expensive is really just a status thing. it contributes nexto nothing to environmental goals which i think eliminating plastics belongs to.

      u can just put the grounds in a cup and pour hot water on it afterall. tastes fine.

      • coolestguy 11 hours ago

        It’s not about the environment for a lot of people, it’s about microplastics and their body

    • panos_news 13 hours ago

      This one has a glass reservoir. Look at the product page images before you decide to bear any news

      • seemaze 8 hours ago

        Well, it was paywalled, but that's beside the point. The point is that this marketeering contraption solves a problem that the marketeers created.

        Coffee was enjoyed for hundreds of years before plastic was invented. The answer is not to get rid of the plastic, but get rid of the machine.

    • plorg 17 hours ago

      And unless you're picking it up at your roaster in a container you bring yourself the beans have probably been rattling around in a polyethylene-lined bag.

    • wackget 16 hours ago

      I was very skeptical but apparently the Caraway machine uses a glass reservoir and stainless steel pipes.

    • ninininino 16 hours ago

      > it's practically impossible in the modern world

      This sort of defeatism is why people don't try. Consumers can shift products through purchase behaviors. We're already seeing improvements in kitchen appliances and gear, cosmetics, some outdoor gear.

      • iamnothere 14 hours ago

        Believe it or not, lawsuits and regulations are much more effective. Consumer behavior rarely moves the needle. It may make you feel better, but you can’t consume your way to a better world.

        Conspicuous consumption has many forms, “ethical” consumerism is just the latest variation.

        • zenapollo 8 hours ago

          Would love to see some research on this. My libertarian friends are a dog with a bone in their belief that our individual dollar-votes are the foremost and correct way we shape the economic landscape. I can’t imagine how anyone arrives there from research or history or experience, but I guess it keeps their Ayn Rand-ian ambition fired up.

          That being said i wish they were right. I pay a premium for organic and farmers market. As well as plastic free everything. It feels good to support those businesses, but they are still mostly just getting by.

          Beyond lawsuits and regulations - I’ve personally seen what Europe is doing to deploy financial programs for transitions to, for example, regenerative farming. It really works. With the extra funds/financing, farms are able to plan 2-5 year payback instead 10+. The incentive alignment makes a huge difference.

          • iamnothere 6 hours ago

            Asbestos, lead, CFCs, DDT, there’s a ton of examples of where it worked. The question as usual is where regulation is appropriate and how far it should go. Banning lead pipes was obvious, and it worked once people understood the downsides and limited upside, but banning drugs has been a failure.

            You have to look at the demand side of the equation, because creating black markets isn’t a good idea, and neither is creating widespread resistance and discontent. Governments aren’t all powerful (thank goodness), so regulation has to focus on the stuff that’s most harmful and has the highest chance of success.

      • jrootabega 16 hours ago

        A small subset of coffee drinkers might produce a purchase trend that leads to a brief production of an overpriced coffee machine which still ends up being produced in the cheapest, dirtiest country they can get away with. The rest do not care and never will.

    • userbinator 3 hours ago

      While I sympathize with the sentiment to eliminate plastic from the transport chain for anything ingestible

      I don't, and this is just stupid virtue-signaling for the easily gullible hypochondriacs.

      Plastics came from hydrocarbons, which make up the bulk of all living matter.

  • devindotcom 8 hours ago

    I have a Technivorm Moccamaster KBG-V and they use good plastic for their parts but it's still plastic (except the thermal carafe etc). There's a new copycat version that's all glass and plastic (Simply Good I think?) but not sure how it actually performs.

    What I'm surprised at is that no one has made non-plastic drop-in replacement parts for the reservoir, basket, and funnel. The KBG-V is highly modular so it's strange to me that no one has gone this route. It shouldn't change anything significant in the brewing process or quality of the coffee.

    • tedd4u 6 hours ago

      You can purchase a kit now that eliminates all plastic from the brew path, including a Hario V60 glass dripper, metal bracket with cork adapter, and a glass carafe with cork lid (all for $120, or buy parts separately). (No affiliation.)

      https://www.manual.is/semi-manual

    • skew-aberration 7 hours ago

      Does it even make a difference for non-heated parts? Potable water is delivered in PVC pipes and HDPE hoses these days.

  • mikeweiss 7 hours ago

    I like Moka pots. Zero plastic

    But seriously it's a shame how hard it is to find products like coffee makers and electric kettles with no plastic. Heat and plastic don't mix

    • asdff 6 hours ago

      Took me forever to find a french press that was all glass and stainless steel. Most of them the little filter at the cap (which vintage ones lack entirely fwiw) is some black plastic, but I found a bodum off crate and barrel a couple years ago that was stainless for that part too.

    • 0_____0 5 hours ago

      Still has a polymer gasket :)

    • pengaru 6 hours ago

      > Heat and plastic don't mix

      actually they do, and that's the problem

  • SomaticPirate 17 hours ago

    Aeropress makes a glass version although I was never too concerned about the microplastic risk

    • SoftTalker 17 hours ago

      Huh. They used to say they specifically did not offer a glass or stainless version because it would get too hot to hold/use.

      Instead of a new $500 coffee maker like the ones in the article, that takes special (likely costly) presssed pellets of coffee, get a Chemex pour over for $50 and you'll never need another coffee maker again (unless you drop it). No plastic, and you can use whatever coffee you want.

      • plorkyeran 16 hours ago

        The original founder sold the company and the people who took over promptly did all the things people asked for and he said no to.

        The glass aeropress is way more expensive ($200 rather than $30) and is bad in all the ways he said it'd be bad. Heavier, fragile, and makes worse coffee unless you put some extra effort into preheating it. Looks better, though.

        • mathgeek 9 hours ago

          Can't say I really have a problem with them. Let them sell expensive glass ones for the folks who care about the look. I've been plenty happy with my plastic ones (including the travel set).

      • Kirby64 9 hours ago

        > Huh. They used to say they specifically did not offer a glass or stainless version because it would get too hot to hold/use.

        The expensive glass one uses double walled glass, so it’s not too bad. It’s $200 though which is ridiculous.

      • jrootabega 16 hours ago

        Bodum makes a pourover thingy that is no more than $20-30. Chemex is just the "prestige" brand.

        • iamnothere 14 hours ago

          How are other people supposed to understand that you’re wealthy and attractive if you buy the plebeian brand?

    • grich7642 17 hours ago

      It's not actually glass but a different synthetic/plastic. They do, however, make a stainless steel version. A lot of food safe stainless steel products are coated in PFAS though.

      • BobaFloutist 15 hours ago

        Now I'm going down the same rabbit hole I went down when people started talking about using wax instead of plastic, trying to determine if something being glass means it's definitely not plastic.

        It does look like things we recognize as glass aren't plastic. So that's nice!

      • nachbo 17 hours ago

        I own one. It's glass and cast aluminum. Pricey but feels very solid. The glass does not get hot. It's very think.

  • silverFork 17 hours ago

    Typical paper cups that are used to serve coffee produce massively more plastic particles and they are more toxic. One cup per year exceeds what whole year of coffee maker plastic releases..

    plastic coffee maker: 7-20 particles

    paper cup : 25000 particles

    https://getplasticproof.com/blog/does-coffee-have-microplast...

    https://sifts.co/blogs/microplastics/microplastics-and-coffe...

    https://sprudge.com/hot-to-go-which-type-of-coffee-has-the-m...

    • amelius 16 hours ago

      Ok, but real coffee drinkers don't use paper cups ...

      • silverFork 16 hours ago

        They do when they are at work. People don't carry a tumbler when they go to the movies. There are starbuck's what do you call groupies and alike. The pods produce a lot of micro plastic too.

        Years ago I looked for all stainless coffee maker and even the most expensive ones had plastic parts. The drip mechanism for all of them had plastic parts. I don't know if they have changed or not.

  • regus 7 hours ago

    I make coffee in an electric percolator. It’s stainless steel, the coffee never touches any plastic. People online say this is the worst way to make coffee, but it tastes fine to me.

    • jmugan 5 hours ago

      We recently switched to that. I don't like the taste as much but not sure what else to do. This coffee thing is getting complicated.

  • bob1029 17 hours ago

    When I drank coffee I would use a Hario V60. Avoiding plastic is trivial (and cheap). $40-50 for the entire setup. I preferred to waste my money on expensive beans instead.

    • lanfeust6 7 hours ago

      Hario Switch for me. The cheap manual devices make the best brew. Mind you, I make only one strong cup in the am and it's just for me.

      • bschwindHN 2 hours ago

        The V60 and the Switch are so good! I prefer the V60 when I have time to brew, but the Switch also makes a great cup that's a bit smoother tasting (which is good sometimes, not as good other times), and requires less supervision to brew.

        V60 is still the undisputed champ for cleanup though. Dump the filter in the trash, rinse the dripper, and you're done.

  • ungreased0675 3 hours ago

    A Chemex with properly weighed and proportioned beans makes excellent coffee. It’s also plastic free and there isn’t a wait list.

  • comrade1234 17 hours ago

    I used to grind my coffee and manually make espresso. Years ago though I switched to an all-in-one. I was very adamant that it had to have ceramic grinders so that it will last forever. I've since had to replace some internal parts and I'm sure the display will eventually fail and not be replaceable, but those grinders are going to last centuries!

    • giwook 17 hours ago

      I'm assuming you've already noted in your will that the ceramic grinders be harvested from your coffee maker when everything's being sold at an estate sale otherwise what was the point of anything

    • Marsymars 17 hours ago

      > I was very adamant that it had to have ceramic grinders so that it will last forever.

      I wonder about this - I've got a few 1Zpresso grinders - they're rated for 100-200kg of coffee, and napkin math says my most-used one has probably done about 70kg to date. At grinder prices and my age though, not sure I'd ever come out ahead with BIFL burrs though.

      • Kirby64 9 hours ago

        No ceramic burr grinders make comparable coffee to steel burrs. They’re all worse. Enjoy your steel burrs and don’t overthink it. Even “worn out” I bet they will taste better than ceramic burrs.

        • ungreased0675 3 hours ago

          Can you explain why? I don’t know enough about coffee grinders to work out how there could be any difference in the end product.

  • zaphar 17 hours ago

    I mean, among real coffee snobs the status symbol is mostly not using a Keurig or Lavazza machine at all. Pour overs, Espresso machines, most status symbol coffee equipment is pretty light on the plastic already.

    • schnevets 17 hours ago

      I think it's less about status or quality and more about a convenient cup of complimentary coffee in a waiting room that doesn't come with two ounces of environmental guilt.

    • Marsymars 17 hours ago

      Yeah, my normal morning coffee for my wife and I is from a Kalita Wave glass brewer. No plastic touches the coffee. Costs $40. Ceramic or stainless steel also available.

    • shostack 17 hours ago

      This. Anyone serious about coffee who is not going with one of these machines purely for convenience and speed would not otherwise consider them in a million years.

    • jrootabega 16 hours ago

      It's CNN. Not exactly news snobs.

  • turtlebro 16 hours ago

    Join team instant coffee. It's way better then its rep. No microplastics either.

    • viciousvoxel 7 hours ago

      Unfortunately instant coffee still has microplastics from the production process. Probably even more than regular coffee actually.

    • bschwindHN 2 hours ago

      > It's way better then its rep

      Sorry but no, it has the reputation it deserves. It's an admirable invention for fast caffeine delivery, but you can get so much better flavor out of coffee that it's not even close.

  • zekehernandez 17 hours ago

    I would enjoy a plastic-free drip machine with a thermal carafe for convenient large batches. For now, been enjoying a stainless steel french press and pour over.

  • sfpotter 8 hours ago

    Love my La Pavoni.

    • boplicity 7 hours ago

      Check out Coffee Sensor -- they make non-plastic replacement parts, so you can get fully plastic free.

  • zodwick 17 hours ago
  • PowerElectronix 16 hours ago

    Do people take pods coffee seriously? If you want to signal true status with coffee you pull your roasted coffee beans from a very exotic place, ground them in your very expensive stainless steel manual grinder and make a very strong, very flavorful espresso in your generic chinese espresso machine (that steo is just heat, water and pressure, no need to go overboard there).

    • nstents 16 hours ago

      In the hinterlands we use a variable speed drill, a Hilti at this level, to power our manual grinder for the roasted exotic beans before using a stainless steel Alessi moka pot for our coffee.

      No sense using our hands to belabor the point when grinding.

  • jlarocco 4 hours ago

    Does it fix the weird chemical taste of pod coffee?

  • dachworker 17 hours ago

    Hmm, is all the metal food safe? To what extent?

  • elchief 17 hours ago

    i just use a stainless steel electric kettle, and a glass ikea french press

    $55ish CAD total

    • rafram 17 hours ago

      This setup does not make good coffee compared to an espresso machine.

      • chocochunks 17 hours ago

        I think you mean that setup does not make good espresso compared to an espresso machine. As someone that enjoys good coffee but doesn't particularly like drinking an overly strong thimble of coffee, a cup of milk on top of a thimble of coffee or a grossly stringent cup of coffee I hate the equation that espresso is the best coffee. My favourite bits of coffee, what I enjoy in lighter roasts is lost in espresso. Espresso is nice for cafes because it's a quick non-batch brew, that's about it.

        You can have good coffee from any method.

      • skinfaxi 17 hours ago

        I wouldn't consider a French-press coffee to be espresso. In fact, espresso is probably too fine for a French press.

      • mcmcmc 17 hours ago

        It does if you like French press

      • Milner08 17 hours ago

        Nonsense. They are different drinks. Filter coffee through a French press can be fantastic, as can Espresso. You can also get dreadful espresso and dreadful filter coffee. However if you start with good beans the chance of getting good coffee out of a French press is much higher than a proper espresso machine (If you know what you're doing it can be amazing, but dialing it in properly is no easy task)

  • cjoelrun 17 hours ago

    Status: titanium credit card at expensive local coffee shop.

  • christkv 17 hours ago

    So ridiculous we already have ESE pods for traditional expresso machines. We replaced the Nespresso machine in the office with a normal expresso machine so people can make bring their own ground coffee if they want but we also offer ESE pods for people who don't care but still want a good coffee.

  • amelius 16 hours ago

    I hate it that Apple products still have so much plastic in them. Makes them look flimsy.

  • zombot 15 hours ago

    I must be hot shit then, my portafilter has no plasic and neither does my grinder.

  • throwitaway222 17 hours ago

    I think the status symbol is not having enough time to make it at home and also being able to afford it at Starbucks.