19 comments

  • plaidfuji a day ago

    Slightly off topic, but I found this particular sentence interesting:

    > This is software that isn’t ready for prime time, hasn’t been fully cooked, and is operating in a country that’s too corrupt to pass meaningful modern privacy laws or to regulate data brokers.

    Something about the way this is worded, whether intentional or not, really drives home the reality of the US’ diminished standing as a trusted global partner. Like, we’re simply not taken seriously anymore. And it’s not just because of corruption - the corruption is there because of deep-seated political ignorance.

    • guywithahat a day ago

      [flagged]

      • drawfloat a day ago

        Your president and his wife both separately were involved in blatant crypto rug pulls only 18 months ago. The fact you still have freedom of speech has no bearing on whether the country is comically corrupt.

        • georgemcbay a day ago

          > Your president and his wife both separately were involved in blatant crypto rug pulls only 18 months ago.

          Sadly that isn't even close to the worst of it. Trump regularly pardons people of federal crimes in exchange for money and forcibly shuts down insider trader investigations into his own family.

          We are living in a time of unprecedented open corruption in the US government.

          • plaidfuji 20 hours ago

            Also the funding of Trump Jr’s wedding by a Russian oligarch…

            Private sponsorship of personal vanity projects (White House ballroom)…

            Jet gifted by a foreign entity (Qatari AF1)…

            Ambassadors demanding personal payment for guaranteed audiences (Guilfoyle)…

            And that’s just in recent memory. The Left isn’t blameless either. The fix needs to be systemic (repeal Citizens U, re-build independent oversight and nerf the executive), but unfortunately I only see it becoming a deeper and more acrimonious blame game.

        • guywithahat 20 hours ago

          [flagged]

          • plaidfuji 20 hours ago

            > What I'm saying is the US broadly has low corruption. I don't have to pay a bribe to get my drivers license or to get through the airport.

            Low compared to who? Third-world countries? Again, just shows how far we’ve fallen that these are the comparisons being made. The problem with the US isn’t direct low-level corruption, it’s systematized high-level corruption.

            > Broadly speaking you can't purchase bills or laws, and have to convince the public.

            There is a multi-billion-dollar lobbying industry whose purpose is essentially this, but through legal indirect channels. And the public are so ill-informed that spending money = convincing the public.

            > The US has issues, but any supposed lack of data privacy laws isn't due to corruption, it's due to the will of the people

            I tend to agree with this, but if there ever was broad momentum to strengthen data privacy laws, systematized corruption would stymie it. And is likely already actively suppressing it.

          • etblg 20 hours ago

            > a literal illegal immigrant was elected to the House in Minnesota.

            who?

          • AnimalMuppet 20 hours ago

            An alleged illegal immigrant.

            • guywithahat 18 hours ago

              That's fair, although the evidence is pretty solid

      • a day ago
        [deleted]
  • zamadatix a day ago

    Previous discussion https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50033517 76 comments, 10 days ago

  • matt3210 a day ago

    Is the Elon post true? Is the CEO of a public company promising to make you whole in a public forum a binding statement? probably not.

    • lern_too_spel a day ago

      He promised to make specifically that person whole if he tried it out.

  • cestith a day ago

    The scary thing is the agent that could read the bank account information and the agent that posted the information were separate agents.

    • gregglain 20 hours ago

      The failure IMO is trusting anything that has not proven itself first with a year or three of experience.

      US privacy laws - has anyone gone to jail or massive impacting fines for violations?

    • 4ndrewl a day ago

      In what sense "separate" though? No shared memory? No IPC? No what?

      No-one can ever deterministically test any of this - just expect the worst to happen.

      "Don't write any bugs"

      • cestith 4 hours ago

        Not separate enough, it seems.

  • yunicc 17 hours ago

    [flagged]