Washing machines took decades to catch on

(daily.jstor.org)

22 points | by herbertl 5 days ago ago

20 comments

  • bob1029 an hour ago

    > Second, the semiautomatic washing machines themselves may have taken some of the drudgery out of clothes washing, but they did not really save time. Scott explains that the person washing “had to manually feed each item of clothing through the powered wringers between each part of the cycle.” You could not just close the door and turn the machine on and leave.

    Second? Why not first? This could be the entire article. Why would I buy a machine that doesn't actually provide meaningful value? Everything else in this article is ragebait for HN.

    • tdeck 18 minutes ago

      It saved your muscles from the very tiring work of agitating the contents of the washtub.

    • magneticnorth 18 minutes ago

      It still seems like that would save a ton of unpleasant work, if not time.

      I own a pasta machine where I have to hand-feed the pasta sheets, and it's so much easier and more fun to make pasta compared to rolling by hand, even though it doesn't save me any time.

      Simply feeding an item into a wringer is easy and a bit meditative; wringing by hand is a lot of work and a lot of wear on your skin.

  • mauvehaus an hour ago

    My grandmother had a washing machine with a manually fed electric wringer until she moved into assisted living. It would've likely been no newer than the immediate postwar era, as that's when she moved into the house she lived in. I doubt she would've owned it earlier (steel being needed for the war).

    It was a bit of a production to do laundry with it. I can buy the argument that it was tough to sell machines that weren't fully automated. It looked fun as a kid, but I can't imagine it's fun for more than a load or two!

    Edited to add: they lived north of the Mason-Dixon in an area with very few Black residents.

    • Isamu 37 minutes ago

      When I was young I did summer work for a woman who described how difficult it was getting to find a new washer with a wringer, which if you are not familiar is a pair of rubber rollers above the washtub to really squeeze out the water. This was a wealthy woman who just couldn’t change her workflow.

  • singpolyma3 19 minutes ago

    I imagine there was also the ethical concern of putting all those people out of work...

    • cowlevel a minute ago

      No there wasn't. Literally nobody worries about the ethical concern of putting people out of work when they do the work more efficiently.

  • small_model 12 minutes ago

    We should have put more research into clothes fabric technology so that clothes never get dirty, no washing machines needed.

    • hobo123 3 minutes ago

      There's polyester sports clothing which seems to be more stain resistant (because it doesn't really absorb moisture), but for some reason bacteria seem to stick to it even better, so it gets smelly.

  • gib444 an hour ago

    If electricity gets any more expensive in the UK (it will), I might have to start hand washing clothes!

    • collabs 15 minutes ago

      From what I understand, the dryer is a bigger concern. In the UK and in Europe, you are already ahead of the curve by reducing use of the electric dryer.

  • mrits an hour ago

    It just takes 5 seconds to think about the treatment of white workers in coal mine to debunk this entire article. My grandmother was a middle class family in mid 20th century and still preferred to hand wash the families cloths until arthritis took over.

    • archole an hour ago

      that wouldn't disprove it. You haven't understood the article

      • mrits 22 minutes ago

        disprove and debunk are not the same word

        • gpvos 15 minutes ago

          Oh, so you are a troll.

        • hluska 19 minutes ago

          You're good at being pedantic and playing linguistic hopscotch but you still don't have a clue what you're talking about.

          • mrits 16 minutes ago

            If you think that is being pedantic I can understand why you thought the article was well written.

    • hluska 20 minutes ago

      My great-grandfather died in a coal mine so, I have an intimate understanding of your argument. Intimate enough to tell you that you did not understand the article.

      • mrits 19 minutes ago

        Sounds very intimate

        • hluska 18 minutes ago

          Oh, you're just a troll. Sorry for engaging - carry on with your bullshit.