I don't find trimming videos with ffmpeg particularly difficult, is just-ss xx -to xx -c copy basically. Sure, you need to get those time stamps using a media player, but you probably already have one so that isn't really an issue.
What I've found to be trickier is dividing a video into multiple clips, where one clip can start at the end of another, but not necessarily.
Missed opportunity to reference the famous Dropbox hn comment.
I just think there are other closely related use cases where a separate program can add more value, especially in the terminal. I wouldn't suggest most people should use ffmpeg instead of a gui, those are too dissimilar. Another example is cutting out a part of a video, with ffmpeg you need to make two temporary videos and then concatenate them, that process would greatly benefit from a better ux.
Point of order: the Dropbox HN comment is famously misconstrued. People think it was about Dropbox; it was about the Dropbox YC application, and was both well-intentioned and constructive.
I used a plugin in mpv to do it but I can't find it anymore. You just pressed a key to mark the start and end. And with . and , you could do it at keyframe resolution not just seconds.
This is very cool. I built one of these myself around Christmas; Claude Code can put one together in just a couple prompts (this is also how I worked out how to have Claude test TUIs with tmux). What was striking about my finished product --- which is much less slick than this --- was how much of the heavy lifting was just working out which arguments to pass to ffmpeg.
It's surprisingly handy to have something like this hanging around; I just use mine to fix up screen caps.
Commenting mostly because when I did this I thought I was doing something very silly, and I'm glad I'm not completely crazy.
You can use AI to figure out the arguments to ffmpeg. But indeed it seems like there's just a single call to FFmpeg CLI to power the whole thing which is amazing.
yeah I remember learning this trick in like 2007 with libaa and later caca for color.
It looks like this app is shelling out to ffmpeg to get the bitmap of a frame and then shelling to something called chafa to covert to nice terminal-friendly video.
Could have really used this a couple days ago. I had to record a video an assignment, but due to lack of global hotkeys on OBS with wayland, I had to start and stop the video on the OBS GUI. I tried to figure out ffmpeg but I was too tired and it was getting close to the deadline so I spent some time learning how to to do it with kdenlive.
People that use GUIs/tools for things like ffmpeg, rclone etc really want the developer to autodetect if they have it already, and use that instead of installing a separate version/binary.
I don't find trimming videos with ffmpeg particularly difficult, is just-ss xx -to xx -c copy basically. Sure, you need to get those time stamps using a media player, but you probably already have one so that isn't really an issue.
What I've found to be trickier is dividing a video into multiple clips, where one clip can start at the end of another, but not necessarily.
I don't find Sharing files with people very difficult, just login to your FTP and give an account to another user. - Person commenting on OneDrive
Missed opportunity to reference the famous Dropbox hn comment.
I just think there are other closely related use cases where a separate program can add more value, especially in the terminal. I wouldn't suggest most people should use ffmpeg instead of a gui, those are too dissimilar. Another example is cutting out a part of a video, with ffmpeg you need to make two temporary videos and then concatenate them, that process would greatly benefit from a better ux.
Point of order: the Dropbox HN comment is famously misconstrued. People think it was about Dropbox; it was about the Dropbox YC application, and was both well-intentioned and constructive.
> with ffmpeg you need to make two temporary videos and then concatenate them
It can be done in a single command, no temp files needed.
FWIW, here's a simple command line utility for joining and trimming the multiple video files produced by a video camera.
https://metacpan.org/dist/App-fftrim/view/script/fftrim
I used a plugin in mpv to do it but I can't find it anymore. You just pressed a key to mark the start and end. And with . and , you could do it at keyframe resolution not just seconds.
I asked about this tool 3 days ago, HN is a magical place! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47363432
This is very cool. I built one of these myself around Christmas; Claude Code can put one together in just a couple prompts (this is also how I worked out how to have Claude test TUIs with tmux). What was striking about my finished product --- which is much less slick than this --- was how much of the heavy lifting was just working out which arguments to pass to ffmpeg.
It's surprisingly handy to have something like this hanging around; I just use mine to fix up screen caps.
Commenting mostly because when I did this I thought I was doing something very silly, and I'm glad I'm not completely crazy.
You can use AI to figure out the arguments to ffmpeg. But indeed it seems like there's just a single call to FFmpeg CLI to power the whole thing which is amazing.
Invoking ffmpeg, gzip and tar commands is a sort of reverse Turing test for LLMs
I think this is the first instance I've seen of an actual terminal video player. Very fun to play with.
mplayer, mpv and I think VLC can do it, with the right output driver settings (libcaca or a few other choices.)
You can just use ffmpeg to extract frames, and then just render the raw images with unicode blocks.
(There's Kitty Graphics too, but I couldn't figure out how to make terminal UI layout work with it.)
yeah I remember learning this trick in like 2007 with libaa and later caca for color.
It looks like this app is shelling out to ffmpeg to get the bitmap of a frame and then shelling to something called chafa to covert to nice terminal-friendly video.
https://github.com/hpjansson/chafa/
I have been using this one[0] and it is small, fast, and seems to work pretty great for me so far.
[0]https://github.com/wong-justin/vic
Happy to hear! Some of my thoughts when building it:
- I haven't implemented audio support yet, but it would be nice
- I like --dry-run
- I didn't use a TUI widget library, but now it's at the point where it's tedious to refactor the UI / make it prettier
- I like OP's timeline widget
- Wanted to focus on static binaries. I got chafa static linking working for Linux, but haven't bundled ffmpeg yet
- which reminds me of licenses -- chafa and ffmpeg are LGPL iirc
- a couple other notes from early on: https://wonger.dev/posts/chafa-ffmpeg-progress
On MacOs I just press space and trim with finder. Even avoids re-compressing.
Could have really used this a couple days ago. I had to record a video an assignment, but due to lack of global hotkeys on OBS with wayland, I had to start and stop the video on the OBS GUI. I tried to figure out ffmpeg but I was too tired and it was getting close to the deadline so I spent some time learning how to to do it with kdenlive.
Having to separately download ffmpeg in the windows distribution does not really make sense
Just bundle it
I disagree, I don't want another ffmpeg binary, I already have one. Winget works well, especially since this is already a terminal program.
People that use GUIs/tools for things like ffmpeg, rclone etc really want the developer to autodetect if they have it already, and use that instead of installing a separate version/binary.
How do I know? I built one (https://github.com/rclone-ui/rclone-ui)
afaik winget can automatically manage package dependencies.
I've been using ffmpeg with claude as video editor for long time.
You mean you let create claude command or it itself runs ffmpeg on your local machine and returns you finished cut?
I guess I can find another implementation to combine trimmed parts after taking out certain scenes?
Write a text file with all the parts like this:
Then call ffmpeg like this: And I guess you could make an LLM write a {G,T}UI for this if you really want.