44 comments

  • WhyNotHugo an hour ago

    I wrote a guide on copying photos from an iPhone onto a Linux host: https://whynothugo.nl/journal/2024/12/22/exporting-photos-fr...

  • gerdemb 3 days ago

    Where is the link? How can iPhone backup directly to an external hard drive?

  • gaudat 2 days ago

    >home NAS setups aren't realistic for most users

    Citation needed. Get a Synology NAS and use their Photos app which backups Live photos on both iDevices and Androids. Buy it for life.

    • thenaturalist 2 days ago

      Let's be real, that's already far less approachable to 90% of consumers I know.

      The simples hurdle just being knowledge.

      The existence of NAS is probably an unknown unkown to a large part of the population.

      Compare that to "there's an app for that" & plug USB.

      Drastically simpler.

      No skin in the game either way, but I can very much understand OPs reasoning and would reach the same conclusion.

    • pdxandi 2 days ago

      I've been doing this for many years and am pretty happy with it. I can sync from my Android and my wife's iPhone. The Photos app is nice and smooth. Backups happen automatically in the background. It can even de-dupe and clean up old photos that have been backed up. All in all, quite pleased with it.

    • HuwFulcher 2 days ago

      You’re looking at £300ish for an entry level Synology and the storage. That isn’t a realistic expense for many users.

      • Jnr a day ago

        Over time it saves money. I got a home server and a tiny remote backup server 8 years ago and it runs quite a few services saving me hundreds each month and costing in electricity and hardware (over time) about 15EUR/mo. The longer it runs, the cheaper it is. Most of the updates are automatic so no babysitting required.

    • MehdiHK a day ago

      Synology is still my go to with the model I already purchased. But I'm not sure I'll be buying them again after this:

      https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-components/nas/synology-requ...

    • michaelraiwet 2 days ago

      A Synology NAS doesn’t last for life.

      • uuddlrlrbaba a day ago

        And isn't protection against fire, flood, theft or other disasters.

    • kzisme 2 days ago

      Or checkout https://immich.app/ !

  • jlarocco 2 days ago

    I wouldn't use it personally, but I could see it being useful for my parents or family.

    ifuse and rsync works fine for me.

  • SwamyM 2 days ago

    I would love this if it allowed me to backup all photos taken with the iPhone to an external drive. Currently, Apple dumps all pictures (from the Camera, from iMessage, WhatsApp, etc.) into folder makes it difficult to backup just my pictures.

  • polymatter 2 days ago

    Thank you for including a non subscription “lifetime” payment option.

  • atmosx a day ago

    I am using PhotoSync to backup photos from iPhone to a self-hosted Photoprism via WebDAV (accessible from everywhere via tailscale).

  • 2 days ago
    [deleted]
  • 1970-01-01 2 days ago
    • msh 2 days ago

      It’s more like PhotoSync as it only does photos

    • tempodox 2 days ago

      I loved the idea until I saw that it's only available as a subscription.

      • 2 days ago
        [deleted]
  • mindwork 2 days ago

    Would immich work for this? You can run it locally in docker container

  • scriu 10 hours ago

    Can you add a feature to upload to a ftp server?

  • mfa1999 2 days ago

    Will it work with large (huge) photos libraries? Eg. 150k photos/videos - most of them in iCloud. Does it preserve album/folder structure?

  • mattfrommars a day ago

    Btw, there is also LocalSend. Pretty nifty app

    • coldtrait 11 hours ago

      Isn't that to transfer wirelessly to devices?

  • mattfrommars a day ago

    Is this a native IOS app?

  • keroro 2 days ago

    How much does it cost?

    • recury 2 days ago

      In-App Purchases

      BackiGo Pro Yearly (1 Year) $6.99

      BackiGo Pro Monthly (1 Month) $0.99

      BackiGo Pro Lifetime $14.99

  • alain34 2 days ago

    [dead]

  • er0k 2 days ago

    I just use rsync, works great

    • rsync 2 days ago

      Would you explain how you are using rsync to backup photos on an iPhone ?

      I'm not aware of an iOS app named "rsync" and ... presumably you don't have a shell ... ?

      • sandreas 2 days ago

        Don't know if still works, but this is how I did it back in the days I had an iPhone:

        https://pilabor.com/blog/2022/01/access-and-recover-files-fr...

        Nowadays I'd use immich or ente.io, which has and e2e encryption cloud as well as self-hosted setup

      • er0k a day ago
      • slicktux 2 days ago

        You can load the IPhone’s pictures on Linux using the folders namespace and then rsync from the loaded namespace to /local…

        • trinix912 2 days ago

          But does it work for Live Photos which is the main premise of this app?

        • wood_spirit 2 days ago

          I use a usb cable and a Linux laptop to copy to a couple of external hard drives (which I store separately). It’s all manual but not too orrenous although i ought backup more often. The biggest hassle is accessing the new heic format on pretty much everything.

          Could it all be made into a sd card image for a pi zero perhaps? Even with a web ui accessible over Wi-Fi? A basic cheap sync-cable-appliance that non-techies can easily use?

          • rsync 2 days ago

            I think I heard that the latest 'rclone' now, finally, support iCloud ... but I think there is an issue there because you can't sync full quality / RAW photos to icloud, can you ?