Signal: Online MIDI Editor

(github.com)

24 points | by modinfo 4 days ago ago

6 comments

  • mkl an hour ago

    The project looks interesting. Screenshots would help, as well as a link to the demo at https://signal.vercel.app/edit. The demo asked for MIDI permission, but didn't accept input from my MIDI keyboard until I realised you have to enable it in settings. There's enough lag in the system that most of my notes end up a bit delayed, and the snap-to-grid doesn't seem to be working.

    Please consider changing the name. A generic common word is hard to search for, and there is already well-known software named Signal.

    • WhereIsTheTruth an hour ago

      > Please consider changing the name. A generic common word is hard to search for, and there is already well-known software named Signal.

      People are free to use the name they want, whether it is the NSA or an individual, it doesn't matter

      • mkl 28 minutes ago

        Of course people are free to use any name, no matter how much it sabotages their project. That doesn't mean it's sensible. Names absolutely matter. At work I use a thing called STACK, because it's the best option available to do what we need to do, but the name is a real problem as it makes it really hard to find anything about it.

  • atoav 2 hours ago

    Interesting, but would be better if there was at least a screenshot in that Readme.

    • jchw an hour ago

      There's one here: https://signal.vercel.app/

      Maybe it should be added to the readme.

      • atoav 37 minutes ago

        That would be good I guess, especially since it looks so good that there is no need to hide it : )